Post

we would not actually know how and why either CSAM or heroin or burning plastic is bad and affects victims/drug users without actual studies involving their impact. you cannot just from-first-principles every single possible issue.

Will Stancil@whstancil.bsky.social

It is absolutely bananas that one of the most prominent anti-AI experts in America is talking like this. Talking to ChatGPT isn’t like doing heroin or downloading child porn. It will not hurt you and has no ethical valence. It will help you understand the nature of something that is now endemic.

it is honestly rather revealing of the hollow moralism at play here that she thinks CSAM is illegal bc icky bad and not "necessarily entails lifelong trauma". getting CSAM legally distinguished from e.g. nude art, actually did involve victim testimonies!

5 reposts50 likes

ultimately this refusal to engage with science at all is worse than the worst caricature of the rationalists