Post

Thanks to @mayor.nyc.gov for the PARTIAL moratorium on "A.i." in the schools. But PLEASE tell him to CANCEL the high school "A.i." pilots that would use our kids as guinea pigs! Send him a message at HeyMamdani.fyi He just said they're proven to help English language learners - I DON'T BUY IT! 🧵

heymamdani.fyiContact the Mayor - NYC Mayor's OfficeSend a message to NYC mayor on the web. You can also get links to media contacts and submit FOIL requests.
Greg Pak@gregpak.net

People's AI Assembly streaming link! Live, now! www.youtube.com/live/JZ7DnHo...

I've been reviewing the websites of the "A.i." pilots @mayor.nyc.gov is pushing on the schools - and I do not see independent proof of their value! When asked how we know these pilots are effective at a city council hearing, the DOE said these pilots would demonstrate that. By testing on our kids???

12 reposts35 likes

The sheet says the district chose the "A.i." program in part because of "1:1 AI Math Coaching for each student on every problem in their native language." So was it the "A.i." that helped - or was it teaching kids in their native language?

There's no evidence here of an actual scientific study. None of these programs show independent studies proving their effectiveness. Meanwhile, we've seen MULTIPLE studies showing kids who use "A.i." have declining cognitive skills and exam scores. Here's one: blogs.worldbank.org/en/investinp...

blogs.worldbank.orgA Warning Shot for Human Capital: Evidence of an AI Learning PenaltyUncontrolled AI use may harm human capital more than controlled interventions help. A China study found student exam scores fell 20% despite improved homework, signaling a critical, understudied risk.