Post

2) It includes a statement by Hilda Bastian who led the Independent Advisory Group (IAG) for the update of this review. "It’s hard to find a word to describe how badly they treated everybody involved in this,” she said. “It’s been pretty appalling behavior.”

3) Prof. Emeritus Jonathan Edwards is also quoted saying the review should be retracted: “It’s misleading and shouldn’t be there,” he said. “It’s now about 14 years out of date."

4) A spokesperson of Cochrane replied that they assessed requests to withdraw the review but that none meet the criteria for retraction.