Post

there was a point during the first boss fight (no spoilers) where I walked away for like 2 weeks b/c I was irritated, but I picked it back up & as the book went on I felt like I could see which parts were deliberate and the point they were trying to make more clearly. I enjoyed enough to get book 2!

charsl.bsky.social@charsl.bsky.social

I’m really interested in hearing what you think of Dungeon Crawler Carl!

0 reposts50 likes

The first boss fight really bugged me. I think the series has a lot going on that people overlook, though, including self-avowed fans... much like there's a lot of right wing "fans" of Rage Against the Machine and System of a Down. Now that DCC is as political as them, but you know.

oh idk, DCC is pretty political??? like I'm sure there are lots of people who read it without noticing. A Federalist Society member also once told Courtney that the Beyond books were her favorite. Lots of people miss the point. 🤣

It has some pretty specific stuff to say but also I felt while reading it that Dinniman was pulling punches a fair amount of the time. Although if we want to discuss "books that are political????" apparently Andy Weir thinks his books, including "Project Hail Mary," which involves all the

Thank you! Yeah I had a similar experience. I’ve read all of them that are out now. Something I find fascinating is how values that are pretty commonplace in the romance genre may or may not be a big part of the Dungeon Crawler Carl-verse. (Keeping it spoiler-free).

Judging by the "when is book 2 coming out" date at the end of the audio, these first ones were written quite a while ago so it's actually pretty interesting (?) that our current tech overlords/AI nightmare hellscape has only made the political commentary increasingly awkwardly on point.

I can absolutely see how people are both enjoying them just as fun books without thinking about them that deeply, but also how there is a lot to discuss within them about the Hunger Games-esque nightmare of our current reality.

The further you go in them, the more the story is about something else - the Hunger Games sort of aspect becomes unavoidable and there is some amount of 'what does it mean to be a person'. It feels around book 4/5, there is a significant turn in where the story is going.

I mainlined them all at once and yeah, the solid turn into the delicious parfait of “does this unit have a soul” with “fake memories but real feelings” is not nearly as sharp as I bet it was with one book every couple of years.

I found the book both incredibly funny and also heartbreaking at times. It definitely wasn’t just an escapist read; it made me think about the state of things and how we can take care of each other and make the world better. I’m also on to book two after spooky season reading.

I’ve seen a decent number of people bounce off the series because of the first part of book one, and yeah, that first boss fight does just feel sort of mean at first. Without adding spoilers, the purpose of it all does become clear pretty quickly after that.

We were talking about it in the group chat, and I feel like if the gym bro had been first I would have responded to it entirely differently. Also the narration added a layer of "do I have to listen to men talk like this in my own kitchen" that was hard to tolerate in 2026. LOL

The problem, of course, is that dude SFF authors have earned very very very little trust as a collective and if I don't know someone or have a strong trusted rec (in this case I did) that sort of thing will absolutely make me go "I ain't got time for this"

The first book feels like a critique/parody of reality TV to me. Although I might have a different perspective if I re-read it now that I'm up-to-date in the series. The entire series is about imperialism, appropriation, and resource exploitation.

the talk show stuff is definitely the overt text, but I was interested in the underlying implications of it and some of the worldbuilding backstory which definitely had far deeper thematic shit going on.

Operation bounce house is a standalone that came out just as the US military was advertising using COD and it was a little too real. But it's similar themes to DCC, just hitting you over the head with them as opposed to quietly ramping them up over time.

I got most of the series for free around Christmas, which rates as one of the best holiday gifts I've ever received. Even so, I almost bailed over a certain plot point in Book 2, and might have done so if I didn't already have a stack of expensive hardcovers waiting to see if I would read 'em.