Post

Stanton Glantz
@profglantz.com

I did read it. That’s how I knew she didn’t address the fact that e-cigarettes are associated with increased risks in never smokers. (All these critics make essentially the same arguments, all of which are anticipated and addressed in the papers. They ignore that, too.)

Charles A. Gardner, PhD@chancethegardener.bsky.social

You don't know Dr. Selya is a she. If you had read her critique, then you would know she's a she (not "he" or "his").

0 reposts0 likes

Charles A. Gardner, PhD
@chancethegardener.bsky.social

She HAS addressed that elsewhere in this systematic review of 10 prospective studies: "Evidence is lacking for moderate or severe respiratory outcomes, but there may be a risk of mild coughing/wheezing...” www.sciencedirect.com/science/arti...

sciencedirect.comRespiratory effects of electronic cigarette use in individuals who never smoked: A systematic reviewCurrent evidence on whether electronic cigarettes (ECs) pose respiratory risks is unclear, due to confounding by cigarette smoking; evidence among nev…