Post

i give creatives a lot of rope when discussing AI, because their oxen have been gored the worst, especially in advertising. and it's not like uninformed opposition is always bad for mass politics. this is america, 80% of all opinions are uninformed. BUT!

Will Stancil@whstancil.bsky.social

People — including highly respected and accomplished writers — are not being sufficiently critical of the information environment on this site. A lot of smart folks are getting brain worms here, via the familiar mechanism of circular validation of ideas that feel intuitively or emotionally true.

capabilities are now to where if you let "machine god" bullshit polarize you into "mechanical parrot" bullshit, you will be at best useless and at worst actively manipulable into things like unending screeching at people who still believe in aggressive regulation, just for different reasons

10 reposts63 likes

No it is a mechanical parrots and no amount of seething or sunk cost derangement will change the reality that you think society needs to have “serious conversations” on whether your dumb chat bot is sentient or not

there is a vast middle ground that will need hefty guardrails built in the next few years, and if you are still toting around letter-counting screenshots from 2023, or constantly predicting incipient bankruptcy, you are very much doing the opposite of activism in this regard

i've used the chinese models, but i don't know much about what their companies' domestic rules are (beyond the obvious "don't cross glorious leader" but that part we've already adopted too)

No you’re just a cultist that is pretending that hedging your bets on what is essentially just NFTs 2.0 will bare fruit, it’s all worthless garbage made by tech fascists to make money, it has no use, you’re a sucker and loser that’s dragging us all down with you

Nothing is helped by the tech companies being led by folks that have acted like a millenarian death cult for a long time. Like of course I want to adjust to new information. But that’s the problem with all “dialogue” now: we all have reasons to dismiss things we don’t like. Actual reasons.

You can still get Google's default search AI to badly flub simple questions like this now, it's strange because even the lowest setting of Gemini doesn't, so they seem to be making themselves look bad for no real reason ( I guess maybe google search is used so much that this saves useful $s ?)

definitely, the newer models are expensive so i bet its some some ultra-stripped down gemini 2 flash, and this is why people who respond to cybersecurity stories about mythos/astra with "lol google dumb" screenshots are talking way past each other at this point

They do seem to have some kind of routing because it's much better at complex questions so it is a bit of a shame that it falls over on such basic questions.