Post

Anyone who says with their full chest that Actual Play is one thing is going to be working from a false first premise. It’s shoddy, cheap thinking, & it isn’t helpful to our understanding either of AP or of its (debatable) impact on people’s play.

16 reposts126 likes

And at this point if you even get near the comparison of TTRPG Actual Play to pornography without: - being a sex worker - citing the actual contributions of SWers to the history & practice of AP, you’re being deeply unserious and careless.

And engaging in the "porn vs RP" debate risks the suggestion of arguable validity to an analogy so weak that it simply doesnt exist. Because sex is motivating for such largely different reasons than storytelling that we are creating more fiction than truth by trying to make a connection.

Agreed I suspect that the western perspective of sex is much too convoluted for it to be used accurately or effectively as an analogy for much of anything We understand only a fraction of the psychosocial and biological workings of Analogy that I attempt patience with cheap and lazy wordplay.

I will credit the poor analogy with exposing a much more exciting and valuable topic to explore. Which is the discussion regarding the performative aspect of all human interactions. With a special focus on the route of these interactions.