Post

Everyone should be extremely concerned that birthright citizenship was 5-4 and not unanimous.

I hear you. But the core question before the Court was: “Can Trump’s executive order stand?” The answer was no, by a 6–3 vote. Justice Kavanaugh joined the majority in striking down the executive order. Suits me. Anything else is pure speculation.

The fact Kavanaugh didn't think it was against the Constitution is not speculation.

He literally didn't join the other 5 on saying it was against the Constitution when it very explicitly is. It's not even a question. And when you have 3 Justices saying it is perfectly Constitutional and fine, that matters. He made a very deliberate decision here to separate himself.

This is Mr. Kavanaugh Stop and you are trying to go out of your way to manufacture a benefit of the doubt when he's already shown the kind of Judge that he is -- people of color just don't have the same rights to him (or the rest of the conservatives on the court for that matter).

He made a decision to set himself apart from all the other 8 justices. If he really is the justice you think he is, then he could have just gone along with the other 3. I wonder why we’re talking about him so enthusiastically here instead of the other assholes who voted against the Constitution.