Everyone should be extremely concerned that birthright citizenship was 5-4 and not unanimous.
5.4K reposts24K likes
Everyone should be extremely concerned that birthright citizenship was 5-4 and not unanimous.
5.4K reposts24K likes
For those asking whether it was 5-4 or 6-3: bsky.app/profile/chri...
BREAKING: The Supreme Court holds that the Fourteenth Amendment protects birthright citizenship, blocking Donald Trump's executive order to end it. Roberts has the opinion for the court, which is 5-4 on the constitutional question and 6-3 on whether federal law protects birthright citizenship.
More: bsky.app/profile/reic...
Notably, FOUR justices would have rewritten the Constitution by fiat. Kavanaugh only concurred because he thinks the law Congress passed in the 1950s granting birthright citizenship governs the case, but he thinks Congress could eliminate birthright citizenship along Trump's lines if they wanted.
bsky.app/profile/chri... And this...they just need one more. Expand the court.
The thing you need to understand is that there are 2 (TWO) different method for amending the constitution 1) The process laid out in the constititon itself (conventions, or 2/3's of both houses followed by 3/4 of states ratifying) OR 2) find five votes on the Supreme Court.
True 100% Trump Melts Down After US Supreme Court Rules for 14th Amendment – Birthright Citizenship newsvideoclip.com/trump-melts-...
bsky.app/profile/otro... My version of the legal opinion: "The #USConstitution states it very clearly"
And why did the useless treasonous bigoted pendejos @ #SCOTUS need 194-pages to assert this basic principle of the #USConstitution? #FuckTrump #FuckTheGOP FUCK #SCOTUS
Unfortunately, neither a law degree, or law license are pre-requisites to sit on the Court. www.supremecourt.gov/about/faq_ge...
Just a thought...
Maybe setting up our systems to reward sociopaths wasn't the best idea. That's what happens when people who feel they have the right to own human beings take a country. They really want to rule over a wasteland like they’re playing Fallout in real life. We're playing their game, it has to end.
Understanding Medieval Supremes The rule of one man is more useful than the rule of many” (De Regno, Ch. 3). Thomas Aquinas Authority, not truth, makes the law... The Führer protects the law.— Carl Schmitt “That’s not theocracy, that’s just natural law. Leonard Leo medium.com/@thcarter123...
And how can anyone come to that collusion…..I mean conclusion? Sarcasm for obvious reasons. bsky.app/profile/lala...
Firstly: get hearing aids Secondly: you were most definitely meeting with house GOP leadership, I.e Mike Johnson. Thirdly: you’re about to strike down birthright citizenship. Fourthly: stop with the absolute ghoulish smile on your miserable face Fifthly: I believe Anita Hill #Pinks #ProudBlue
It is worrisome because the 14th Amendment is crystal CLEAR and there is nothing for the four dissenters to equivocate about as the language is clear. It is no more cloudy than the 5th's "NO PERSON (my caps) shall be deprived of life, liberty or property WITHOUT THE PROCESS OF LAW" (my caps, again)!
Autocrats argue the constitution shouldn't exist. Rising fascism worldwide inspired me to write an allegorical series on its perils: unjust war; failed democracy/climate crisis; race-based oppression; persecution of others. Get The Antunite Chronicles at: amazon.com/dp/B0B1JNBCTK?