Post

Right. Writing is science, and science is writing. Because science is about communicating results. All the data in the world doesn’t matter if people don’t know about it.

5 reposts42 likes

Writing is an aid to thinking. It helps flesh out ideas and fill in the holes. To quote A A Milne, when writing “you find sometimes that a Thing which seemed very Thingish inside you is quite different when it gets out into the open and has other people looking at it”

I think where science is going now is to publish fewer papers but invest more time in them. Citation metrics have broken our field in a thousand ways and this is just another: metrics create incentives to publish more more more.

This is why I commented on the Bhattacharya / NIH proposal this summer to add new metrics for evaluating science and why I said that a metrics-first bloodless quant economics approach to science will restrain progress and innovation.

That said we can’t deny that LLMs will have a use in science. They will be some sort of a tool. As a search engine; as the internet was a tool that changed the way we read papers- from days in the library to having easy access to full text.