Post

“Letting people get revenge on wrongdoers is what keeps societies locked in endless cycles of retributive violence. Indulging people’s thirst for vengeance only makes everyone worse off in the end. Especially in larger people groups, it only creates more net violence.” - @cathyreisenwitz.com

Cathy Reisenwitz@cathyreisenwitz.com

cathyreisenwitz.substack.com/p/lindsay-cl...

2 reposts4 likes

I like Cathy and respect her opinion a lot but on this case I have to disagree. I could write something very long and since I don’t get paid to do so I’m going to make a few brief points instead and elucidate as needed in replies. However, while I do believe that psychiatric care is important to…

…to provide to perpetrators, I do somewhat chafe at the doctrine which fully absolves individuals of the accountability for their actions on the basis of psychiatric illness more than merely mitigates that responsibility. Children are the most vulnerable people in our society, and are uniquely…

…vulnerable to their parents, who are assigned extraordinary legal leeway in the treatment of their children, and even more extraordinary social leeway; the result of this is a reality in which nearly ten percent of children suffer sexual abuse at home by the age of 18, and significantly more…

…suffer other forms of abuse, often at the hands of parents who could very much claim that their responsibility is abrogated by their own generational trauma. Offering them absolution hasn’t worked out for us over the generations which we’ve done so, and while there are questions about deterrence…