Post

What’s the deal with mastodon these days? Has it been losing ground to bluesky? Does it have a different position on the ideological spectrum? It seems likely that one of them will wind up as the default left-of-center Twitter alternative.

Bluesky seems to have attracted a large portion of the people for whom Mastodon was a little bit too technically weird and was missing features (like search and retweets and a customizable algorithmic feed) that they valued

This is it. I spent a lot of time on Mastodon a few years back, but I started to despair when it became clear that they were committed to a level of pluralism that made basic discovery features like search controversial to implement.

Honestly I think the biggest difference is that the Mastodon community made it very clear that they did not WANT to be the new Twitter, in terms of being a worldwide water cooler Bluesky wants to be that

0 reposts10 likes

i was appalled by the bridgy backlash on masto. that was one of those watershed moments where i started to doubt the fediverse could really make a difference in the world. it doesn’t want to, they’re clear about that, i should’ve believed them

yeah, social networks are inherently shared commons on some level. my impression from reading the protocol spec was that the server you joined was the split point where it stopped being shared, but then bridgy happened and it turns out everything is still shared and there’s no advantage of the fedi