Benjamin Ryan

Benjamin Ryan

@benryanwriter.bsky.social

Independent investigative reporter. http://www.benryan.net Subscribe: https://benryan.substack.com

4K followers1.3K following2.6K posts

Pinned

HOW GENDER MEDICINE SET ITSELF UP FOR DISASTER For Compact, I report on what the 100s of WPATH conference videos I obtained tell us about this troubled field: compactmag.com/article/how-... 👉I 'll be publishing the conference videos on my Substack: benryan.substack.com/p/i-obtained...

compactmag.comHow Gender Medicine Set Itself Up for DisasterAt a closed-door meeting in 2021, ACLU attorney Chase Strangio declared, “If we take away these health care options, kids are going to die.”

Benjamin Ryan reposted

Benjamin Ryan reposted

My Latest: Erin Reed Has Been Hiding AI-Generated Text in Her Reporting For Years Much of what she has written for Erin in the Morning since Spring 2023 has been written and/or influenced by AI. The resulting articles are full of unacknowledged and unretracted errors.

theneedlenews.comErin Reed Has Been Hiding AI-Generated Text in Her Reporting For YearsMuch of what she has written for Erin in the Morning since Spring 2023 has been written and/or influenced by AI. The resulting articles are full of unacknowledged and unretracted errors.

Benjamin Ryan reposted

New Investigation: 📰 Erin Reed Has Been Hiding AI-Generated Text in Her Reporting For Years 📰 The Needle's evidence shows she has made a litany of errors this year alone, including deadnaming another trans journalist who hasn't published since. theneedlenews.com/2026/09/erin...

You seem to think that people reading the article are the threat to the lesbian bar. But had you read the article you would know that it is the crazy patrons who are a threat to the bar, and the readers of the article want the bar to succeed and are criticizing the patrons.

Tressie McMillan Cottom@tressiemcphd.bsky.social

Bless your dim little heart.

In which sociology professor Tressie McMillan Cottom dismisses the article she wouldn’t deign to read about the sociology behind downfall of a lesbian bar, insisting an article about the downfall of the lesbian bar is more important.

Tressie McMillan Cottom@tressiemcphd.bsky.social

I don’t know anything about the lesbian bar you’ve all been picking on but I do know the stats on lesbian bars are depressing and that seems more important. www.smithsonianmag.com/travel/rise-...

No, I literally described what you said, and now you’re playing games with me and pretending like I didn’t. And you’re preventing me from replying, forcing me to quote tweet instead.

Tressie McMillan Cottom@tressiemcphd.bsky.social

Can you read or do you just use a random number generator to choose a sequence of words?

Benjamin Ryan reposted

I’ve covered Trump’s arch for nearly a year. I’ve watched officials reveal their plans to federal commissions and tracked them in court. Nobody, until today, made any suggestion it would be a “military complex.” But Trump has used a similar strategy to defend his ballroom.

washingtonpost.comTrump says planned 250-foot arch will be ‘military complex’ for drones, snipersThe president’s post about the 250-foot arch planned near Arlington National Cemetery comes as veterans groups, historic preservationists and others attempt to stop the project.

BREAKING: Two More Major Hospitals Reach DoJ Settlements to Keep Youth Gender Clinics Shuttered The Justice Department announced that NYU Langone and the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center had joined four other major hospitals in reaching such settlements. benryan.substack.com/p/two-more-m...

benryan.substack.comTwo More Major Hospitals Reach DoJ Settlements to Keep Youth Gender Clinics ShutteredThe Justice Department announced that NYU Langone and the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center had joined four other major hospitals in reaching such settlements, to the dismay of trans activists.

Before he blocked me, you would’ve seen this thread on youth gender surgeries from NPR’s Jesse Thorn:

Benjamin Ryan@benryanwriter.bsky.social

There is no evidence that gender-translation surgeries prevent suicide in adolescents. There is so little research about them, for starters. And Finnish research into the connection between cross-sex hormone treatment and suicide in youths did not find such a link. Thread:

There is no evidence that gender-translation surgeries prevent suicide in adolescents. There is so little research about them, for starters. And Finnish research into the connection between cross-sex hormone treatment and suicide in youths did not find such a link. Thread:

This post is unavailable.
View full thread

There is no evidence that gender-translation surgeries prevent suicide in adolescents. There is so little research about them, for starters. And Finnish research into the connection between cross-sex hormone treatment and suicide in youths did not find such a link. Thread:

This post is unavailable.
View full thread

There is no evidence that gender-translation surgeries prevent suicide in adolescents. There is so little research about them, for starters. And Finnish research into the connection between cross-sex hormone treatment and suicide in youths did not find such a link. Thread:

This post is unavailable.
View full thread

It is a common misconception that many youths seek gender-transition treatment at the immediate onset of puberty. Most minors who present at gender clinics are 15-17 year old natal girls who only developed gender dysphoria after puberty’s onset.

Making these services more available would not likely change much with regard to the fact that they usually already have breasts by this point and it is too late to use puberty blockers to prevent a need for a mastectomy.

There is no evidence that gender-translation surgeries prevent suicide in adolescents. There is so little research about them, for starters. And Finnish research into the connection between cross-sex hormone treatment and suicide in youths did not find such a link. Thread:

This post is unavailable.
View full thread

There is no evidence that gender-translation surgeries prevent suicide in adolescents. There is so little research about them, for starters. And Finnish research into the connection between cross-sex hormone treatment and suicide in youths did not find such a link. Thread:

This post is unavailable.
View full thread

Harvard set up the shaky comparison between top surgery and gynecomastia surgery with a misleading 2024 research letter that failed to note that per capita, gender-transition surgery is much more common among adolescents with gender dysphoria than among boys where gynecomastia is concerned.

There is no evidence that gender-translation surgeries prevent suicide in adolescents. There is so little research about them, for starters. And Finnish research into the connection between cross-sex hormone treatment and suicide in youths did not find such a link. Thread:

This post is unavailable.
View full thread

One question that supporters of these practices have always been unable to answer is this: If the need for these mastectomies is so intrinsically dire, why were there not waves of suicides among teenagers wanting their breasts removed prior to the 2010s?

Mastectomies may be safe per se, but they come with serious risks and downsides, such as severe scarring, necrosis of the nipple, loss of sensation, numbness and nerve pain. This is a far more drastic surgery than a gynecomastia surgery, so the comparison is a stretch.

There is no evidence that gender-translation surgeries prevent suicide in adolescents. There is so little research about them, for starters. And Finnish research into the connection between cross-sex hormone treatment and suicide in youths did not find such a link. Thread:

This post is unavailable.

As for medical necessity, this is a term that WPATH spliced into its trans care guidelines for adolescents knowing they did not have the research to back it up. What they wanted was to ensure that insurers covered such medical interventions.

As for “rare,” during the several years leading up to these practices being widely banned, about 1,000 biological girls had a gender transition mastectomy annually. That is according to an analysis by @LeorSapir. Some people think that is a high number. Others think it constitutes rarity.

BREAKING: Major New York Hospital Settles With DoJ Over Youth Gender Clinic, Keeps It Shuttered Given Mt. Sinai had a large pediatric gender clinic and is in a blue state with a supportive AG, this settlement serves as a grim harbinger for this beleaguered field benryan.substack.com/p/major-new-...

benryan.substack.comMajor New York Hospital Settles With DoJ Over Youth Gender Clinic, Keeps It ShutteredGiven Mt. Sinai Health System had a large pediatric gender clinic and is in a blue state with a supportive attorney general, this settlement serves as a grim harbinger for this beleaguered field.

Benjamin Ryan reposted

Replying to @kattenbarge.bsky.social

I will also exercise significantly greater caution when engaging with biased sources or people who have been shown to victimize others.

Benjamin Ryan reposted

Replying to @kattenbarge.bsky.social

I will independently verify claims made by anonymous accounts, approach sources’ biases with greater sensitivity, and exercise skepticism around these types of sources.

Benjamin Ryan reposted

Replying to @kattenbarge.bsky.social

I regret any other lapses in judgment that may have occurred throughout this process and will do better moving forward.

Benjamin Ryan reposted

Replying to @kattenbarge.bsky.social

As part of my reporting, I asked Alexa about allegations this individual has made against her in response. I recognize that these questions were harmful to Alexa’s wellbeing and I apologize for asking them.

Benjamin Ryan reposted

Replying to @kattenbarge.bsky.social

Finally, Alexa has taken out and renewed a restraining order against an individual she has accused of stalking, on behalf of herself and her young child. To do so, Alexa compiled extensive documentation.

Benjamin Ryan reposted

Replying to @kattenbarge.bsky.social

I regret any interactions I had with these accounts or any misplaced trust in content they posted or otherwise engaged with. To rely on or engage with these accounts causes real-world harm, and for that I apologize, too.

Benjamin Ryan reposted

Replying to @kattenbarge.bsky.social

I did not independently verify or vet their claims. Furthermore, “Abuse of Power” engaged in behavior like cyberharassment, cyberstalking, and nonconsensual intimate image sharing. I expressly denounce such content.

Benjamin Ryan reposted

Replying to @kattenbarge.bsky.social

In the process of learning about these conflicts, I encountered information posted by accounts on X called “Exposing Rich” and “Abuse of Power.” These accounts made various false, unsubstantiated, and unverified comments about Alexa and Eat Predators. They were clearly biased against Alexa.

Benjamin Ryan reposted

Replying to @kattenbarge.bsky.social

Notably, there was never any evidence Alexa defrauded members of Eat Predators, including through the group’s Patreon account.

Benjamin Ryan reposted

Replying to @kattenbarge.bsky.social

Some people left because they wanted to monetize Eat Predators or otherwise gain something to the detriment of Eat Predators. Conflicts that broke out afterward were not started by Alexa, but rather by other individuals.

Benjamin Ryan reposted

Replying to @kattenbarge.bsky.social

She did not represent the group solely as an ambassador, but rather led the group. People voluntarily joined Eat Predators, and some members later left the group for various reasons.

Benjamin Ryan reposted

Replying to @kattenbarge.bsky.social

As part of her activism, Alexa started a group called Eat Predators. In my reporting process, I asked Alexa questions about conflicts regarding this group. I now understand that Alexa was solely responsible for the creation of Eat Predators and that she did not co-opt other members’ ideas.