Marcel

Marcel

@macelblattner.bsky.social

Physicist and terrible programmer. Independent Scientist. Astrophotographer.

174 followers341 following113 posts

On September 8, OpenAI announced that an AI system had produced a proof about the Navier-Stokes equations, which describe how fluids move. Much of the coverage reported that OpenAI had solved these equations. The result is something different.

View full thread

On September 8, OpenAI announced that an AI system had produced a proof about the Navier-Stokes equations, which describe how fluids move. Much of the coverage reported that OpenAI had solved these equations. The result is something different.

View full thread

Second, they borrow credibility. The machine check confirms the proof is correct for the statement given to the computer. Whether that statement matches the original problem still needs confirmation by mathematicians. The headline lends the check's authority to a claim the check does not cover.

Third, they shape expectations. The headline suggests progress in simulation and engineering, where the result has no direct application. Stated accurately: an AI system produced a machine-checked proof that, if mathematicians accept it, resolves one formulation of a well-known open problem.

On September 8, OpenAI announced that an AI system had produced a proof about the Navier-Stokes equations, which describe how fluids move. Much of the coverage reported that OpenAI had solved these equations. The result is something different.

Engineers compute solutions to these equations every day, for aircraft design and weather forecasts. OpenAI addressed a mathematical question about them, one of the seven Millennium Prize Problems: whether the equations allow a smoothly moving fluid to reach infinite speed in finite time.

The proof covers the version of the problem in which an external force acts on the fluid. Whether a fluid left to itself can do this remains open. Headlines like "solved" cause three problems. First, they widen the claim: a result about one question becomes a claim about the equations as a whole.

My latest image of the Dumbbell Nebula (M27), a planetary nebula located roughly 1,300 light-years away in the constellation Vulpecula. This capture reveals the brighter central core along with some of the fainter outer hydrogen-alpha structures. #astrophotography #space #astronomy #M27

NGC 7822 is a striking and visually captivating emission nebula in the constellation Cepheus, lying roughly 2,900 light-years away. Exposure time 15 hours. #Astrophotography #deepsky #universe

The M109 Galaxy (NGC 3992) is a barred spiral galaxy located in the constellation Ursa Major. It is often nicknamed the "Vacuum Cleaner Galaxy". Distance from Earth about 70 Mio. light-years. Imaged with my CDK14 and Moravian C3-61000 mono camera. #Astrophotography #Universe #Galaxy

Caldwell 4 - the Iris Nebula. A reflection nebula about 1400 light-years away from Earth. Shot with RGB and my CDK14 hosted at e-eye in Spain. The universe is great. #Astrophotography #deepsky #space #universe

The Tulip Nebula (Sh2-101) An H II emission region located in the constellation Cygnus, approximately 6,000 light-years from Earth. The structure spans roughly 70 light-years across. #astrophotography #deepsky

1/3 Planarian fragments can regenerate normal gross anatomy after a transient bioelectric perturbation, yet display altered outcomes upon re-cutting. This implies regeneration stores a persistent hidden state. A new preprint formalizes that state geometrically.

2/3 The construction is an open-path Tangential Action Spaces formulation. The coarse anatomical trajectory is prescribed; the hidden state is a baseline-relative endpoint displacement in a higher-dimensional physiological fibre. Re-cutting acts as a challenge readout.

The Whirlpool Galaxy (Messier 51a/NGC 5194). This interacting grand-design spiral galaxy features a Seyfert 2 active galactic nucleus. Captured with a Seestar S50 (120 x 10s integration) and processed in PixInsight. #astrophotography #M51 #space #astronomy #SeestarS50 #PixInsight #Astrophotography

Jones-Emberson 1 (PK 164+31.1), also known as the Headphone Nebula, is a 14th magnitude planetary nebula in the constellation Lynx at a distance of 1600 light years. #Astrophotography

Abell 31 (also known as Sh2-290) is an ancient planetary nebula in the constellation of Cancer. It is estimated to be about 2,000 light years away. #Astrophotography