Chris Sardo

Chris Sardo

@mcsardo.bsky.social

Recovering political theorist, current history/government teacher, long-suffering Sabres fan. Politics, pedagogy, music, Sabres, and other sad things. He/his.

520 followers1.2K following826 posts

Pinned

Hi there, I used to be a political theorist who worked on questions of political responsibility in both the history of political thought (esp Kant, Nietzsche, and Arendt) and contemporary questions (especially climate change and global justice). Now I teach high school history and government.

If every senior took that class instead of memorizing quotes from the federalist papers and oversimplifications of Court doctrine, we'd be in a much better place.

Sam Ulmschneider@samulmschneider.bsky.social

Once - one year - I got to teach a seminar for my advanced high schoolers where we read Putnam (Our Kids), Eirenreich (Nickel and Dimed), Yglesias (One Billion Americans), Desmond (Evicted) a whole book on how to run for local office, and more. These sorts of classes are mostly now foreclosed by AP.

Chris Sardo reposted

God, I just want to take a scythe to AP/College Board domination of advanced curriculum and student choice. Why should we be giving gifted high schoolers 5x as much AP Psychology and AP Economics instead of a diversity of options from local history to intro to philosophy to European literature etc.

I keep teaching the guarantee clause extensively in my APUSH and AP Gov classes hoping that it will stick with some future constitutional lawyer who decides to channel the spirit of Thaddeus Stevens and go to town.

Sam Ulmschneider@samulmschneider.bsky.social

The Republican Guarantee Clause and 14th Amendment's Privileges and Immunities clause are like dormant volcanoes of potential constitutional power. Sometimes I wonder if they'll erupt in my lifetime.

Chris Sardo reposted

Replying to @hellsgellswells.bsky.social

Very few people I know are against including DI in one's pedagogical repertoire. The deskilling doesn't come from learning or using DI. It comes from the policies that would mandate it across all ages, disciplines, contexts, etc. and the companies who would package, sell, & script it to schools.

Chris Sardo reposted

I feel like so much of education discourse is "how do we fix schools?" by treating schools as operating in a vacuum and as the key independent variable to fixing society, rather than flipping the causal arrow and asking "how do we build a society in which students can really learn?"

This seems right to me.

"Online Rent-a-Sage" Bret Devereaux@bretdevereaux.bsky.social

It's hilarious that Huang things not knowing his address, zip-code and phone number are a mark of how he is cognitively off-loading to technology and Klein doesn't seem to press him that what he's actually obviously doing is using the fact that he's rich to off-load onto other humans.

My thoughts on the inclusion of Smith's Wealth of Nations as a "Foundational Text" of US Government and Politics in @liberalcurrents.com

Liberal Currents@liberalcurrents.com

"AP US Government and Politics teachers received an email indicating that four new documents would be added to its list of 'required foundational documents' in order to 'strengthen alignment with college-level courses,' [including] 'core principles from the writings of Adam Smith.'"

Yes, Smith is an interesting and provocative thinker. But does he belong in a high school government course? Is he in any comparable undergraduate syllabi? And importantly - why have we let a private corporation or a couple of state governments decide what is "foundational"?

Jason Briggeman@jbriggeman.liberalcurrents.com

Smith is great of course, the real Smith is, anyway, but in a U.S. government and politics course, in high school, and surely it's some conservatized economized simplified received version of Smith, what are we doing here

View full thread

Beyond these particular questions of imposing a particular ideological framing on this course, these shifts invite further reflection on the power that both both secondary and higher education have ceded to College Board to determine the canon of American political thought.

Civics education is important and part of our civic responsibility should be safeguarding that civic education. It's well past time for collaboration between academics and high school teachers to build civics education that conforms to disciplinary standards and empowers our students.

Why is a Scottish economist who never set foot in the US a required foundational document? Well, it's likely to conform with a rash of state laws that require students to take a civics class that includes Smith's work as essential to understanding US government and politics.

College Board claims that this is to better conform to college level courses, but Smith (as well as Federalist 39, the Gettysburg Address, and Emancipation Proclamation which were also added as foundational documents) is not likely to appear on comparable undergraduate syllabi.

Chris Sardo reposted

i am genuinely bewildered by people who say that the rise of white nationalism in the republican party is a response to the "woke left." like, did the woke left cause pat buchanan's 1992 presidential campaign? is the woke left why steve king had a long career in congress?

I read Tegmark's Life 3.0 years ago, and was struck then at his effusive praise of Musk, which should be as much of an indictment of someone's judgment as you need.

Timnit Gebru@timnitgebru.blacksky.app

Guys, this is Bernie Sanders' guy for all things AI. Max Tegmark of the Future of Life Institute, funded to the tune of $665m by crypto billionaires, that's of course, after all the Muskrat + friends' money. Their "seed funding" was from Musk. 🧵 www.politico.com/news/2024/03...

This has always confused me as someone who hasn't had my reading skills rotted by a formal legal education: the clause literally says "take care that the laws are faithfully executed." How could one ever read that as an expansion of executive authority independent of Congress?

Jerry Edwards@jerryedwards.bsky.social

I am not an executive powers guy, but it seems to me that it is based on a fundamental misunderstanding of presidential authority. The Take Care Clause does not enhance the President's power. It limits it. The Constitution binds him to the rule of law. We are not governed by his arbitrary will.

This: the argument against APs should be that they are robbing students of valuable intellectual and growth experiences by getting to skip actual college classes.

This post is unavailable.

Chris Sardo reposted

A whole new type of guy just dropped - someone in his 50s+ with absolutely no familiarity with the basic archetypes of the Trojan War. Maybe those classical learning people have a point... </sarcasm>

Erin Lockwood@erinkaylockwood.bsky.social

I wish everyone the Odyssey experience @mcsardo.bsky.social and I had, seated next to a man who, based on his whispered reactions -- an awed "whoaaaa" when the Achaeans rappelled from the horse, "she turned them into animals!", "they recognize him!" -- was unfamiliar with the entire plot.

Chris Sardo reposted

Few things reinforce my strong determination to avoid AI generated materials for my students like the disrespected, riled-up feeling I get when those meant to be in charge of or training/teaching me generate slick-but-empty AI slop to do so. I don’t want my students to feel disrespected like that.

This really tracks what I see with high school students (even quite bright ones). Their first instinct is to go to the llm. They've lost the ability to think they can do it themselves.

Ersatz Doctor@ersatzdoctor.bsky.social

It’s not just that they lack basic critical thinking and composition skills (though many do), it’s that they can’t fathom doing any substantial cognitive task without AI. They lack the confidence and imagination to see what they’re capable of. They’ve given up part of their humanity for convenience.

Is it still a unitary executive if the EO has to be explained by the White House deputy chief of staff for policy while the president sits there silently gazing off into space?

For those of you following the College Board's decision to include "core principles" from Adam Smith, and were wondering what exactly they decided were "core principles", the updated "Course and Exam Description" mentions Smith a total of 3 times, with no actual guidance:

Truly disappointed and humbled to learn that the show happening next door that was popular with the youths was not in fact the thrash metal band Slayer, but some artist named Slayr.

I've been making this argument for years - nearly all of our present moment can be rooted in our inability to fully reckon with the covid pandemic and the real costs that both the pandemic itself and our policy responses caused.

This post is unavailable.
View full thread

We could reckon with this. What we did right, what we did wrong. We might come to the conclusion that certain policy responses caused more suffering than benefit. We might identify courses of action that we should have taken, but didn't. We might be in a better situation for the next pandemic.

But instead we've just memory-holed the whole thing, further eroding already precarious trust in institutions and in each other (there's a way in which the senator holding Fauci personally responsible for covid and the some of the more extremist masking rhetoric are two sides of the same coin).

I've been making this argument for years - nearly all of our present moment can be rooted in our inability to fully reckon with the covid pandemic and the real costs that both the pandemic itself and our policy responses caused.

This post is unavailable.

One side wants to complete deny that the covid was a big deal that killed lots of people and upended life. One side wants to deny that there were any negative costs to our policy responses to the pandemic. There's an utter refusal to seriously reckon with the losses the pandemic caused.

By loss I mean lives lost, but I also don't want to say that lost classroom time, missing proms, sports games, and graduations, family vacations that weren't taken, and the enormous disruption to everyday life weren't losses; they might have been worth it, but they were real losses.

Chris Sardo reposted

Hey #PoliSky, Does anyone have a good accessible article (for AP high school students) on unitary executive theory, especially in light of *Slaughter*?

Hey #PoliSky, Does anyone have a good accessible article (for AP high school students) on unitary executive theory, especially in light of *Slaughter*?

We actually don't need a film on Scrooge's backstory, it's literally all covered by the Ghost of Christmas Past.

DiscussingFilm@discussingfilm.net

First poster for ‘EBENEZER’, a new film based on ‘A Christmas Carol’ starring Johnny Depp. “Before he was Scrooge, he was Ebenezer”

Our children are going to be insufferable

Erin Lockwood@erinkaylockwood.bsky.social

Learning to weave while being told about the importance of weaving and the fiber industry to pre-industrial and industrial European political economy, touching on the Luddites and labor conditions for girls in textile mills, is peak Getting Parented by Erin Lockwood.