Phil Gentry

Phil Gentry

@pmgentry.bsky.social

musicologist at the University of Delaware, citizen of West Philly. Current: •Anti-Communism in the Music Industry, 1945-1960 •Performance and History in the Semiquincentennial Past: •What Will I Be: American Music and Cold War Identity (Oxford, 2017).

2.6K followers580 following3K posts

Tenor of the times: I serve in a very low-duty volunteer role for a very casual hobby (amateur lake sailing in old wooden boats) and everyone is suddenly screaming at each other over email about some arcane timing issues for next summer’s races. 🙃

Americans, with childlike glee: “look, it’s a chocolate volcano!” British, sneering: “that’s right, pudding, you work for me now. I’ll just watch.”

Dr. Garrett Schumann@garrt.bsky.social

What the fuck were British people thinking when they came up with a dessert called the, "self-saucing pudding"?

I have been quarantined and bedridden with a terrible norovirus for a numbers of days now, and I am pretty sure that I have now seen every last short form vertical video available on every platform. All of it, I have seen. A new level of consciousness.

I didn’t know her socially, but Mary and I were both music majors in the same class and I still very distinctly remember some of her first concerts which were like 😳🤯

Just to give an example of what I mean, for over two decades the CPUSA published New Masses, a general audience-oriented magazine of cultural criticism. Many ups and downs, but consistently published amazing artists and left an indelible imprint on modernism and mass culture.

Phil Gentry@pmgentry.bsky.social

I think the challenge of Jacobin is they are a part of the left that has ceded “culture” to liberalism, and don’t take it seriously. Which in addition to being bad politics, means you are very susceptible to dumb takes.

I think the challenge of Jacobin is they are a part of the left that has ceded “culture” to liberalism, and don’t take it seriously. Which in addition to being bad politics, means you are very susceptible to dumb takes.

It ends up being kind of amusing/depressing because it results in some truly vapid, superficial cultural criticism that, were it anything else, they would denounce as PMC radlib or whatever.

Left cultural criticism is a thing! Not coincidentally often paired, historically, with some of our greatest political victories! Weird to rarely see it in Jacobin.

I think the challenge of Jacobin is they are a part of the left that has ceded “culture” to liberalism, and don’t take it seriously. Which in addition to being bad politics, means you are very susceptible to dumb takes.

It ends up being kind of amusing/depressing because it results in some truly vapid, superficial cultural criticism that, were it anything else, they would denounce as PMC radlib or whatever.

Left cultural criticism is a thing! Not coincidentally often paired, historically, with some of our greatest political victories! Weird to rarely see it in Jacobin.

I gave a talk on Paul Robeson to my kid’s fourth grade class once, and made the mistake of playing Robeson singing “Joe Hill,” and for the rest of the class, all the kids wanted to know was the precise details of how Joe Hill was killed. 🙄

Seditionist Distribution@seditionist.bsky.social

Happy Birthday Joe Hill, folk poet, songwriter, union man. Born this day 1879 he would spend a life time fighting the oppressor. He was murdered by firing squad on Nov. 19, 1915. seditionist.uk/compendium/j...

Have been around higher ed long enough to recognize that sometimes important work does require bureaucratic expansion, but also, lol that they began by hiring a VP and buying new software, lol, classic move.

Just to acknowledge that there is an addendum to the Vanderbilt anti-woke humanities report that focuses on music, written by a very distinguished musicologist, and it is unsurprisingly both malicious and poorly-reasoned. I'm torn; I don't want to give it oxygen, but also find it quite toxic.

View full thread

Okay, I think the only thing on the merits I will say about this mendacious report is that it was written in the year 2026, a year in which Donald J. Trump is the president of the United States, and in which there are currently only 7 tenure-track jobs in musicology being advertised.

Just to acknowledge that there is an addendum to the Vanderbilt anti-woke humanities report that focuses on music, written by a very distinguished musicologist, and it is unsurprisingly both malicious and poorly-reasoned. I'm torn; I don't want to give it oxygen, but also find it quite toxic.

The issues are complex enough that social media isn't a great place to discuss them, but also not sure of what the proper venue would be; again, it doesn't need more attention!

It would be very easy to write a long thread detailing all the things the authors--Simon Morrison and Kit Fine--get factually wrong, the oversimplifications, the fallacies, the unacknowledged ideology. But unlike the authors, I take freedom of expression seriously, and it deserves more space.

On our tour of umpteenth german musical establishments, I paused dramatically and said, "but on Wednesday, after going through Leipzig, Berlin, Mannheim, and Bayreuth, we get to...Esterháza!" But there is no reaction because they are normal people who vaguely know there is a composer named Haydn.

Phil Gentry@pmgentry.bsky.social

Update: I’m looking for a recording of a singspiel (Hiller’s Die Jagd, in 1769) that the textbook swears was a huge hit and that everyone knew this one lied from it in particular. Best I have is a live video recording of an outdoor performance on YouTube, in Latvian.

Gotta take any journalist job you can, I know, but I really feel for whoever's it is at the NYT to dutifully write up a detailed summary of SNL each week.

I have to say, I think Philly would be a happier, healthier place if they got rid of all the professional sports teams.

Will Bunch@willbunch.bsky.social

What a week for Philadelphia when the Flyers losing their opening game 7-0 doesn't even make the list of the worst things that happened

I just still don’t understand how the traffic mitigation for the Market St. bridge closure included turning these blocks of Walnut into a three-lane highway and getting rid of the bike lane protection.

I absolutely love the Schuylkill River Trail, I cheer on every new part that opens, but..am I the only one who thinks that it is quite ugly? Like mini-freeway ramp clogging up the river.

The eternal dilemma; do I take the godforsaken early train that gets me to campus two hours before class, or the reasonable train that gets me to campus 18 minutes before class, if there are no delays.

My wife and I, using four separate devices, attempted to get reservations at Mawn anywhere in November the moment reservations opened up today at 12:00pm. We failed.

This is niche west philly content, but: the whole faking-being-Palestinian thing was mostly a reflection of one bad actor, but it’s definitely also a reflection on her organizing community, and if I were them I would not be continuing to plant more stories in the paper about it! 🤯

My neighbor talked to me about baseball tonight, and I did such a good job imitating being a real man (“yeah, that Harper!”) thanks to little bits of sports stuff I see on Bluesky.

My gentle giant of a daughter is doing a girls-only basketball program (trans inclusive, thank you very much), and after years of her enduring shitty boys in coed leagues, it warms the heart to see her play without all the noise. 😭

Update: I’m looking for a recording of a singspiel (Hiller’s Die Jagd, in 1769) that the textbook swears was a huge hit and that everyone knew this one lied from it in particular. Best I have is a live video recording of an outdoor performance on YouTube, in Latvian.

Phil Gentry@pmgentry.bsky.social

I’ve taught 18th century music surveys so many times in my life, but we switched to a new textbook which is possibly the nerdiest, least undergrad-friendly text one could write, and it’s really kicking my ass.

Searching frantically for the famous lied within the opera, Google translating the synopsis out of Latvian, finally drag up the score on IMSLP, going back and forth, still can’t find it, now pretty sure that this production cut out the definitive lied of the era. 🤯