Political Analysis

Political Analysis

@polanalysis.bsky.social

Official Journal of the Society for Political Methodology https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/political-analysis

1.2K followers11 following166 posts

View full thread
View full thread
View full thread

Currently in FirstView: In “Let Them Eat Pie: Addressing Sample Selection in Multiparty Elections,” Ali Kagalwala, @tmqm.bsky.social, Guy Whitten, and Yongzhi Xu introduce a novel maximum likelihood approach that accounts for the biases that come from sample selection in a compositional setting.

Currently in FirstView: In “The Power of Prognosis: Improving Covariate Balance Tests with Outcome Information,” Clara Bicalho, Adam Bouyamourn, and Thad Dunning show how balance tests can lead to false conclusions and develop tests that upweight covariates associated with outcomes.

Currently in FirstView: In “Post-Treatment Problems: What Can We Say about the Effect of a Treatment among Sub-Groups Who (Would) Respond in Some Way?,” Chad Hazlett, Nina McMurry, and Tanvi Shinkre propose the treatment reactive average causal effect (TRACE).

Using a simulation and two replication studies, they demonstrate that this approach adheres to the compositional data constraints and offers a more accurate interpretation of estimated treatment effects for proportional outcomes. You can read the paper here: www.cambridge.org/core/journal...

cambridge.orgEstimating Treatment Effects on Proportions with Synthetic Controls | Political Analysis | Cambridge CoreEstimating Treatment Effects on Proportions with Synthetic Controls

Their framework, UNITAS, reduces the dependence of inferences on specific datasets, cut-offs, magnitude-of-change and time-window assumptions, while efficiently handling missingness and measurement uncertainty. You can read the paper here: www.cambridge.org/core/journal...

cambridge.orgDemocracy Manifest or Democracy Latent? A Unified Framework for Identifying Regime Types and Transitions | Political Analysis | Cambridge CoreDemocracy Manifest or Democracy Latent? A Unified Framework for Identifying Regime Types and Transitions

Currently in FirstView: In “Using Multilingual Language Technology to Classify Open-Ended Survey Responses: Conceptions of Democracy in a Cross-Cultural Survey Setting,” S. Dahlberg, L. Dürlich, S. Axelsson, Y. Zhao, and J. Nivre examine the use of LMs in analyzing open-ended survey responses.

All models consistently attributed more liberal ideologies to women while racial associations differed by model. They conclude that using these models political content analysis may unknowingly introduce model-specific confounds. Read the paper here: www.cambridge.org/core/journal...

cambridge.orgFrom Faces to Politics: Vision-Language Models (Sometimes) Link Visual Demographic Characteristics to Ideological Labels | Political Analysis | Cambridge CoreFrom Faces to Politics: Vision-Language Models (Sometimes) Link Visual Demographic Characteristics to Ideological Labels

Currently in FirstView: In “Correcting Nonignorable Nonresponse Bias in Turnout Estimation Using Callback Data,” Xinyu Li, Naiwen Ying, Kendrick Qijun Li, Xu Shi, and Wang Miao look at the role of callback data as a way of adjusting for nonresponse bias in estimating voter turnout.

They propose an assumption to account for nonignorable missingness in the outcome. Integrating this assumption with covariate information provides an identifiable method for estimating voter turnout. You can read the full paper here: www.cambridge.org/core/journal...

cambridge.orgCorrecting Nonignorable Nonresponse Bias in Turnout Estimation Using Callback Data | Political Analysis | Cambridge CoreCorrecting Nonignorable Nonresponse Bias in Turnout Estimation Using Callback Data

Currently in FirstView: In “Inference at the Data’s Edge: Gaussian Processes for Estimation and Inference in the Face of Extrapolation Uncertainty,” Soonhong Cho, Doeun Kim, and Chad Hazlet illustrate the value of Gaussian Processes (GPs) for capturing counterfactual uncertainty. 

Currently in FirstView: In “A Multilevel Model for Coalition Governments: Uncovering Party-Level Dependencies Within and Between Governments,” Benjamin Rosche extends the Multiple Membership Multilevel Model to represent the multilevel structure of coalition government data.

The model is validated with data on coalition government survival, showing that ignoring party-level dependencies can produce misleading conclusions at all levels of analysis. The paper also introduces an accompanying R package. You can read it here: www.cambridge.org/core/journal...

cambridge.orgA Multilevel Model for Coalition Governments: Uncovering Party-Level Dependencies Within and Between Governments | Political Analysis | Cambridge CoreA Multilevel Model for Coalition Governments: Uncovering Party-Level Dependencies Within and Between Governments

Currently in FirstView: In “Accounting for Protest Voting in the U.S. Congress,” Anthony Fowler and Jeffrey B. Lewis estimate a model of congressional voting that allows for non-ideological protest voting. This has significant implications for roll-call estimates of ideology.

The model offers insights about stability, the direction of causation between attitudes, and their relative influence. They use their model to show the role of ideology on attitudes toward government spending and immigration. Read the paper here: www.cambridge.org/core/journal...

cambridge.orgA Dynamic Discrete Choice Approach to Attitude Stability and Constraint | Political Analysis | Cambridge CoreA Dynamic Discrete Choice Approach to Attitude Stability and Constraint

Currently in FirstView: in “Refining Gamson: The Isometric Log-Ratio Transformation and Portfolio Proportionality in Multiparty Governments,” Lanny Martin and Georg Vanberg propose the isometric log-ratio (ILR) as an alternative to the additive log-ratio (ALR) transformation.

The findings challenge Gamson’s law: the idea that cabinet ministries in multiparty democracies are distributed in proportion to seats. Because portfolio and seats are mutually dependent, ILR addresses concerns of bias and uncertainty. Read the paper here: www.cambridge.org/core/journal...

cambridge.orgRefining Gamson: The Isometric Log-Ratio Transformation and Portfolio Proportionality in Multiparty Governments | Political Analysis | Cambridge CoreRefining Gamson: The Isometric Log-Ratio Transformation and Portfolio Proportionality in Multiparty Governments

Currently in FirstView: in “Modeling Hierarchical Spatial Interdependence for Limited Dependent Variables,” Ali Kagalwala and Kankyeul Yang propose a class of spatial hierarchical models with binary outcomes to account for spatially independent and spatially dependent unobserved group effects.

They demonstrate the utility of their models by analyzing civil rights protests in the US. These models are useful because many datasets in political science are nested and can potentially have diffusion processes at multiple levels. Read the paper here: www.cambridge.org/core/journal...

cambridge.orgModeling Hierarchical Spatial Interdependence for Limited Dependent Variables | Political Analysis | Cambridge CoreModeling Hierarchical Spatial Interdependence for Limited Dependent Variables