Tanja Bueltmann

Tanja Bueltmann

@tanjabueltmann.net

Professor | history of migration and diaspora | citizens' rights | commentator | immigrant | trans inclusive feminist | she•they | my views | https://tanjabueltmann.net

13.8K followers664 following790 posts

Pinned

As a German I will forever be grateful to all who fought for the liberation of Europe. But as a historian I am looking at front pages today and must wonder: What is the point of remembering #VEDay 80 years on, what is the point of our thanks, when we are failing to protect the sacrifices made? 🧵

The far right agenda is not a grievance that can ever be settled. That is why we are where we are now, a place where there is a live conversation about who is a 'white Briton' as per below. I am not clear what it will take for people to understand the seriousness of the situation because ...

View full thread

To stop it, we need 1) leaders to make better choices; 2) the media to recognise their enabling role in normalising this escalation cycle and stop doing so 3) a significant civil society effort in support of 1) and 2). In my view, we are failing on all three currently. /end

PS: Yes, of course: some media know exactly what they're doing - apols, I might have made that clearer. I'm talking overall here and there I think 2) is a clear and urgent need, especially for the BBC.

The far right agenda is not a grievance that can ever be settled. That is why we are where we are now, a place where there is a live conversation about who is a 'white Briton' as per below. I am not clear what it will take for people to understand the seriousness of the situation because ...

View full thread

... as proof of momentum for more. This is very obvious on immigration: feed it the EU citizens (through Brexit) and it asks for the asylum seekers. Feed it the asylum seekers and it asks for a further narrowing of who can settle. Read this way, the arrival of Reform and now Restore, as well as ...

... recent far right riots, are not a random occurrence: they are the continuation of the trajectory the UK has been on for the last decade. And the trajectory continues to arrive on schedule, with ever more extreme positions and developments. This process will not simply stop on its own.

The far right agenda is not a grievance that can ever be settled. That is why we are where we are now, a place where there is a live conversation about who is a 'white Briton' as per below. I am not clear what it will take for people to understand the seriousness of the situation because ...

... it was serious years ago and so it was also years ago when this should have ended. This is not to say there are no options now, but they are more limited / difficult to achieve. Far right agendas are a mechanism that requires escalation, and every concession is taken not as a settlement but ...

Unless this “honesty” involves the recognition that immigrants are *not* the root cause of the UK’s problems *but* actually a part of the solution to them, this will be completely pointless. I cannot stress this enough. www.theguardian.com/politics/202...

theguardian.comBurnham to say UK must be honest about its challenges as he prepares to become PMLabour leader will visit king to accept role on Monday and will start making cabinet appointments that afternoon

24 June 2016. The day after when EU citizens across the UK were told to ‘go home’; when the then PM said he would not protect our rights. Stories largely forgotten. BLEA - Brexit Lived Experience Archive - which I am launching today, is here to preserve this history. #Brexit brexit.migravox.org

brexit.migravox.orgHome - BLEABLEA. Brexit Lived Experience Archive Documenting experiences. Personal experiences provide valuable insights into how Brexit is lived and understood by those directly affected. Recording these accoun...
View full thread

My piece above is one example: pitched in various forms to various outlets, together with the launch of the archive and I did not even get a single reply. I appreciate that I have no special right to being published, but to me this, in itself, is an encapsulation of what this archive is about.

24 June 2016. The day after when EU citizens across the UK were told to ‘go home’; when the then PM said he would not protect our rights. Stories largely forgotten. BLEA - Brexit Lived Experience Archive - which I am launching today, is here to preserve this history. #Brexit brexit.migravox.org

brexit.migravox.orgHome - BLEABLEA. Brexit Lived Experience Archive Documenting experiences. Personal experiences provide valuable insights into how Brexit is lived and understood by those directly affected. Recording these accoun...
View full thread

As I explain there, I hope I’ll be able to continue develop BLEA because I have a lot more data. I estimate that it’s close to 750k words overall, spread across around 7k respondents. This includes 250k worth of testimony from British citizen in the EU, who I am very keen to include next.

Bearing all that in mind, think of BLEA as a primary source collection — one that could only ever be online because of the sheer volume of data. Ultimately, I could not just let that sit in my computer files as EU citizen experiences of Brexit are already being written out of reflections.

24 June 2016. The day after when EU citizens across the UK were told to ‘go home’; when the then PM said he would not protect our rights. Stories largely forgotten. BLEA - Brexit Lived Experience Archive - which I am launching today, is here to preserve this history. #Brexit brexit.migravox.org

brexit.migravox.orgHome - BLEABLEA. Brexit Lived Experience Archive Documenting experiences. Personal experiences provide valuable insights into how Brexit is lived and understood by those directly affected. Recording these accoun...
View full thread

Each card is one response. And each card has a unique identifier, so if there are other future versions, it will still be possible to match records etc. Even if the archive moved that can be retained. BLEA should be of interest to researchers, policymakers, journalists and EU citizens themselves.

I have taken the liberty to add one personal post in Deep Dives to situate the work - Brexit has always been personal and I’m both researcher and EU citizen. There are millions of stories like mine. And in 2016 all collided with the same event: the EUref. brexit.migravox.org/first-person...

brexit.migravox.org10 Years On - BLEAThis is a First Person record – one liberty I am taking as BLEA‘s creator. The Brexit referendum has always been personal – and so is its legacy 10 years on I fell in love with this country and came t...

24 June 2016. The day after when EU citizens across the UK were told to ‘go home’; when the then PM said he would not protect our rights. Stories largely forgotten. BLEA - Brexit Lived Experience Archive - which I am launching today, is here to preserve this history. #Brexit brexit.migravox.org

brexit.migravox.orgHome - BLEABLEA. Brexit Lived Experience Archive Documenting experiences. Personal experiences provide valuable insights into how Brexit is lived and understood by those directly affected. Recording these accoun...
View full thread

I want to highlight one point from the guide: many entries describe painful experiences, including xenophobia, racism, misogyny, and impacts on mental health. Reading them can be difficult, particularly if you have lived through similar experiences yourself.

24 June 2016. The day after when EU citizens across the UK were told to ‘go home’; when the then PM said he would not protect our rights. Stories largely forgotten. BLEA - Brexit Lived Experience Archive - which I am launching today, is here to preserve this history. #Brexit brexit.migravox.org

brexit.migravox.orgHome - BLEABLEA. Brexit Lived Experience Archive Documenting experiences. Personal experiences provide valuable insights into how Brexit is lived and understood by those directly affected. Recording these accoun...

The archive currently holds 10,211 responses from 2,414 respondents — approximately 300k words worth of first-person testimony from EU citizens in the UK. The archive serves different people differently. An overview guide is available in the Deep Dives section. brexit.migravox.org/guide/a-guid...

brexit.migravox.orgA Guide to BLEA 1.0 - BLEAAbout the Brexit Lived Experience Archive This archive opens up the qualitative data behind the ‘EU Citizens’ Identity, Belonging & Representation Post-Brexit Survey‘, conducted in early 2021. The sur...

As you can see, it’s BLEA 1.0 - it remains a work in progress in some respects, but the 10-year EU referendum anniversary is the right moment to go live with this version. General details about the project are available here. brexit.migravox.org/about/

brexit.migravox.orgAbout - BLEAAbout https://vimeo.com/1203131444 Why BLEA matters and how it came about When a country changes the legal status of millions of people, the human cost is easily lost in the noise of politics, reduced...

There are, in my view, 25 things everyone needs to understand in light of recent events: 1) Those out in our communities last night were not protestors, but organised far right extremists. 2) Their actions align with fascist ideologies. 3) So yes: these are fascist practices on our streets. 🧵

4) Reporting of what is happening mostly does not recognise 1) to 3). 5) This leads to things like the description of events as incidents or protests when they are forms of race riots carried out by far right extremists - riots that exhibit some pogrom characteristics and paramilitary behaviour.

View full thread

PS: Had meant to say sorry for being late with this; as per a previous thread, life isn’t all that kind to many of us atm but that doesn’t mean I’ve abandoned my views! I see you and I hear you no matter how hard some try to erase your voices! This is about your lives and they are never a debate.

View full thread

The dynamics behind that are more complex than this thread can explore, but our history gives us knowledge about dynamics too. So it isn’t about direct parallels with the past, but it is about learning from where certain types of choices can lead us. Not to draw on that knowledge is beyond foolish.

For, as in the past, it appears that enough of us will only understand once it affects them directly. By that point it will be too late. So check your privilege and if you really do not get it yet then ask yourself the two binary questions above—if those are not enough, I cannot help you. /end

View full thread

As is common these days, too many people are more afraid of that term now than the actual first steps needed for fascism to emerge and consolidate. As a historian—also specifically as a German—that horrifies me. As a collective we humans appear to be as stupid as it gets, really.

Why would we dismiss our own knowledge like this? Why would we fall for the same patterns all over again? History cannot repeat itself, it doesn’t have agency. But people absolutely can choose the same types of trajectories and currently we collectively are doing that.

View full thread

There are, however, two choices that absolutely are binary only: The first is about human rights. They are either universal. Or they are not. For as soon as you limit the rights of one community, you limit them for all. For “First they came” is never where it ends.

The second is that transphobia is a fascistic agenda. There is no question about this. We have all the knowledge we need on this in our own history. And you either stand up to fascistic agendas. Or you do not.

View full thread

The uncertainty and anxiety this is causing; the hate it will stir up—shame on you. Do you have any idea of how many of our communities are living in fear because of your choices? Do you care? Some Labour MPs oppose these policies, oppose those on immigration. But that is not enough.

Us cis allies must listen to trans people and act in their best interests accordingly with that. If you are a trans woman and afraid at this time and I am in the same space as you, it would be my delight and privilege to go to the toilet with you—I’m sure all we both hope for is a clean toilet 🩷

View full thread

Labour ministers and MPs scrambling to make this sound less bad need a reality check. Let me be inspired by another commentator who put it with the eloquence required: changing a ‘f*ck off’ to trans people to a ‘we’re sorry but could you kindly f*ck off’ to trans people does not make it better!

Like your horrendous approach to immigration that only pushes votes to Reform and harms our communities, all of this is on you. Labour could have made different choices. You are responsible for where we are as much as the EHRC. There is no better version here. And that is how it will be remembered.

View full thread

… badges for them for toilet policing. Utterly vile and dangerous. Personally, I also cannot overstate how much I abhor to be reduced to my biological sex—it is everything feminism opposes in a nutshell. It shames me that too many do not see that. It has never been trans people who …

… threaten women’s rights, it is transphobia that does. Because those who are behind the dismantling of trans rights are also those behind the dismantling of women’s rights. Too many in the UK have not caught up with that fact yet even though a simple Google search reveals it.

So this guidance belongs only in the bin. That is likley not how it will be treated by too many, but it will also prove completely unworkable where implemented. We will have more and more stories of all of us being accosted in toilets—remember that some gender criticals already created little …