Post

We could win the war in Iran, but at what cost? I break down this and more, in my Weekend Update on Substack. Link in reply.

166 reposts936 likes

He’s going to have to incur US casualties in order to harden his support for the war amongst his base. The more casualties, the more a lot of people in the US will want to “see it through” so they weren’t killed for nothing. They will go hard after any Dem that tries to end it

Sorry , America cannot 'win the war' at any cost. America couldn't take control of Afghanistan which was smaller, smaller military, less weaponry, less organisation. And Afghanistan can't control the world's economy. It's this US mentality which is the problem. US doesn't understamd geopolitics.

What would a win even look like? Seriously, the only outcome from this war I see that Netenyahu and republicans can cancel elections and launder money to their buddies that are just now entering the military industry. Only people benefitting from this war are Putin, republicans, and Oil industry

This is and probably always will be a two-party system. Although I'm a Democrat, I think the country realizes there's still a few decent Republicans out there. If you were to jump back into the ring and help steer your party in the right direction, we'd probably be better off. 🤷‍♀️

I don't think it's likely to win a war with "loyalists" in charge. It takes true professionals and scholars to be truly effective and efficient. People who will stand up for their professional assessments force valueable conversion, and we just don't have that right now.

Valid points but I am really not convinced that the majority of the Iranian people are on the US side. Iranians know their history. Also, they have seen how the US routinely abandons allies and breaks promises, as in their neighbor Afghanistan. Then there's Gaza.

But what are we winning. The land is the Iranian’s the Kurdish, the Persian. Are we stop a potential nuclear attack. We maintained a stand off with USSR for 50 yrs. Isn’t the goal a peaceful live for people not conquest. We failed in Vietnam Iraq and Afghanistan why are we trying it in Iran

The USA can't win the war in Iran. It's too big, with too many people, and it's pissed off the entire population after the first day, when is an impressive feat of incompetence, even for the yanky barbarians. The USA has fought many wars, it rarely wins them. Personally I blame the Exceptionalism.

We’re not gonna “win” without several hundred thousand troops (trying) to get into Iran. But I wouldn’t put it past Tramp and the Repugnants to try because it’s keeping the Epstein files off the front page. They also think they can take Iran’s oil. Like the orange monster, they’re all delusional.

A brief note on the Iranian people being generally on our side. The South Vietnamese people were generally on our side as well, until the full scope of American war on their land became apparent, and then they weren’t.

$39T in debt, which is increasing at an accelerating rate; ICE agents in the USA killing & deporting Americans, US soldiers are being killed, gas prices & inflation are soaring, the rest of the world hates us, & grand grifts are everywhere at the highest levels. Was this what "America First" means?

Not to mention what are you going to do with the country after you defeat Iran there's no plan none they have no idea and we don't have the money to do what we did in Afghanistan not with the country being insolvent as they said.

Well, they're fuckin' up reel gud so far. Iran still has two thirds of their missile launching capacity, but are calling it "lingering launch capacity" as if Iran is on its last leg. Retreating from destroyed bases is a "strategic withdrawal"

Remind me what the purpose or objective of the war was? Another MISSION ACCOMPLISHED photo op? !!!The main objective was to keep #Epstein #Trump files concealed. Yes he accomplished it quickly!!!

The visible cost is being tracked. The supply chain invoice isn't. Helium offline since March 2. September. Gallium — Gulf smelters dark. China's suspension expires November 27. Friday — China opened trade investigations. Same window. Win the war. The back invoice still arrives in November.

I don’t want any more troops to die because of an insane unwanted war! My husband survived Shield, Storm and the initial phase of Calm. My Father survived WWII. Both came home with PTSD. We as a nation do not need any more.

I see two outcomes. 1) Trump agrees to humiliating peace terms with Iran that strengthens their regime while declaring victory. 2) Trump escalates and the USA gets stuck in a $7 trillion war and 10k in casualties that ends more or less with what Obama had with the JCPOA.There is no good outcome now.