Post

Here are some reasons from someone who's been on an extensive PWA <-> Electron <-> Tauri migration: - Safari is a suboptimal browser. Depending on what you're building, you might be ok or it might straight break your product. Some APIs aren't supported, other don't work as advertised.

Yeah, Safari really is a painpoint. I've found it's actually smoother than Chrome for complex CSS animations, which I like, but the lack of proper devtools and gaps in support are both painful. But my counterargument would be "if you have a web version, you should be testing safari anyways"

- Rust. Learning an entirely new language and sacrificing on a vast JS ecosystem is a time investment and AI doesn't help here. If I'm generating a bunch of code in a language I don't understand I'm in for technical debt in no time. Those two were the breaking factors for me choosing Electron.

I fully agree Electron itself doesn't come with nearly enough tools to build a meaningful product. I have to reinvent a bunch of stuff, from proper IPC to client-driven context menus to (likely) things I haven't even come to yet. If Electron is React then it's missing a metaframework.

Funny enough, PWA clears Electron almost by all metrics, but given how it's underloved, it will never match even Electron's experience because nobody's investing into it. Some APIs are missing, some are broken. It's genuinely sad.

(Most) JS devs don't want to learn Rust.

Yeah, the cross platform chaos of details is really not good. It gets worse the deeper I look into it (being restricted to least-common-denominator things really hurts at deep levels). I've been looking pretty intensely into "what if electron but better" lately and IMO it's CEF or Servo at bottom.

Tauri also has far too much minimum-viable boilerplate for me. As well as minimum-viable exposure to Rust and its toolchain hell(s). Both the mvb rust and the capabilities.json file are somewhere between 🤔 and 🫢🤢😑 imho. They're just... A lot. For little, if any, value.

I've definitely felt this pain trying to hunt down capability flags. Docs aren't clear either