Post

I love the idea of the atmosphere, but looking at all the apps on @sifa.id, I still dont "get it". At least, I dont get those apps, anyway. All I feel are solutions-looking-for-problems vibes. Would love to feel differently, though.

6/8/26, 2:07 pm0 reposts2 likes

Sifa ID

@sifa.id

6 Aug

Does that mean that you dó get Sifa? 😅

Greg Munt

@gregmunt.com

6 Aug

Have to say, I am not sure. I've seen people say it is LinkedIn for the atmosphere - and I'm not really seeing that. Maybe it is a future thing that you are planning, not yet implemented?

Greg Munt

@gregmunt.com

6 Aug

At the moment, it just seems to be an aggregator for atproto content. Not intending to minimise it with "just". An aggregator is useful, up to a point.

Greg Munt

@gregmunt.com

6 Aug

Ugh, all these atmosphere apps are great and all, but they feel developer-designed. There is no story being presented. Why should I care about you? (Not sifa specifically, just any of those apps.)

Guido X Jansen

@gui.do

6 Aug

The /activity page is indeed aggregating atproto activity (or other like RSS, GitHub, ORCID) that you created (so not just simple likes). The /p/{username} pages are your classic profile/CV pages that LinkedIn also offers (although we aim to add a layer of more "proven/attested" data as well)

Guido X Jansen

@gui.do

6 Aug

Well, Sifa has an import for all your CV data from LinkedIn, so in that sense it's very similar in their original purpose. Sifa doesn't (yet) have a combined activity timeline as LinkedIn does (it's on the roadmap) and this might be the most visible/daily part of LinkedIn that Sifa doesn't have yet