Post

There is a debate on French Bsky because a left-wing media outlet has announced it is returning to X due to insufficient engagement on Bsky—even though they are barely active on the platform. A quick reminder: unless you are some sort of celebrity, generating engagement takes work. Sorry.

Especially on a social network without an opaque algorithm—you can't really count on "hit tweets" here. You have to create interesting posts, reply to people, interact with other accounts, and avoid looking like a bot. (The "Nazi bar" issue and the reign of bots on X are separate topics.)

4 reposts130 likes

It really sucks, especially if you were already a media outlet or mid-sized account before joining Bsky. 20% of my X followers followed me here, and anyone with a reasonably large account had an advantage here right from the start. Crossposting is nice, but you need to be present.

I just pulled up one of my old tweets from X and was met with a flood of tweets from people obsessed with the return of progressives from Bsky, accusing them of antisemitism and pedophilia. On X đź«  It gives me PTSD of my last months there.

I almost fell for it and replied (accounts with five times fewer followers after six years on X than I have after two years on Bsky claiming there’s no engagement here 🤡). Then I remembered the trap of the X algo and the much-anticipated "debates" that consists of nothing but getting insulted.

I don't understand why they dislike Bsky when they aren't even there. I, for one, have reasons to miss Twitter, since a billionaire destroyed my professional tool. And then there’s the fact that I genuinely detest racism and child pornography—that’s likely the major difference.

And being present also means there's a chance that someone who wasn't previously aware of you might start following. I'm pretty sure I didn't know you existed before joining bsky, for example.

Plus now X is purging old users (like me) because older users are not insane Nazis. So the left wing outlet will get more engagement... of people telling them that the moustache man should have gotten rid of all of them when he was 'saving' (occupying) France.

Yeah it’s kinda sad to see left wing accounts on more right wing centric platforms like X or Facebook get completely dogpiled on because it can be incredibly counterproductive. Even if those running the account don’t get dissuaded from sharing their beliefs the people who agree with them might

That's the thing - the numbers are of little use at the best of times. On Twitter, we KNOW that they are entirely meaningless. This reeks of "we have no idea what we're doing or what we want, but 'number go up' is good, 'number less than before' is bad".