Dr Benjamin Thorne

Dr Benjamin Thorne

@benjaminthorne.bsky.social

Lecturer in Criminal Law @unirdg-law.bsky.social Via PhD @SussexUni ; Interests: socio-legal studies, transitional justice, critical theory. Book http://tinyurl.com/v77a942b

1K followers530 following697 posts

Pinned

I wonder if during states & EU 'dialogue' with the US administration about sanctions against the #ICC if the election of the next ICC prosecutor might possibly be something US officials 'drop' into the conversation. Obviously if mentioned it should be a immediate off limits response by all states.

Really informative thread on the announced election procedures for the 4th prosecutor of the ICC 👇

Ezequiel Jimenez@ezejim.bsky.social

TBC for States Parties to agree during #ASP25 🚨 but ⤵️ The 4th Prosecutor will be elected in December 2027 in The Hague (confirming ASP26 will not be in the US). The extremely delayed timeline at a time the OTP requires leadership should must be spotless - but 🧵⤵️ 📍 www.icc-cpi.int/news/bureau-...

Dr Benjamin Thorne reposted

Replying to @ezejim.bsky.social

The 4th Prosecutor will make or break the ICC as the institution it calls itself to be in the Preamble. The bar is high. States Parties must take their governance responsibility to elect the best to reassure victims their hope is worthwhile. Any hint of US appeasing will end it.

This is a good summary of current domestic efforts in the US challenging sanctions against the International Criminal Court #USsanctions #ICC ICC Sanctions Lawsuit Tests Trump’s Power Over Americans’ Speech - www.military.com/icc-sanction...

military.comAmericans Challenge Trump’s International Criminal Court Sanctions in Federal CourtThe Trump administration sanctioned the International Criminal Court earlier this month, testing emergency powers and troop protection claims.

As General Licence 14 (tech) of US sanctions against the ICC is getting some news coverage, it is worth noting that whilst big US tech (Microsoft etc..) almost without doubt lobbied hard for the exemption (which does not currently have a expiration date), although #USsanctions #ICC #Tech

at this moment the work of the ICC is not being substantially effected (any more than it was prior to the sanctions announcement). However with the continuing lack of concrete counter action, the strong likelihood of companies and organizations sanction overcompliance, and #USsanctions #ICC

emerging rifts between different actors, all of this will almost inevitably manifest into a variety of forces negatively impacting on the work of the ICC in the next few months. #USsanctions #ICC

'Words like “freedom,” “justice,” “democracy” are not common concepts; on the contrary, they are rare. People are not born knowing what these are. It takes enormous and, above all, individual effort to arrive at the respect for other people that these words imply' James Baldwin #Serbia #Brazil

Dr Benjamin Thorne reposted

If the EU & (many) states continue to ignore the growing chorus for concrete action the immediate horizon is going to be dominated by sanction overcompliance, and it is overcompliance which could potential prove to be a drill going deep into the centre of ICC operations. #USsanctions #ICC

politico.euTop ICC official urges EU to act ‘as soon as possible’ on US sanctionsOsvaldo Zavala Giler said a “lack of clarity” from Brussels was leaving companies and NGOs in the dark after the White House imposed sweeping sanctions on the International Criminal Cou…

Dr Benjamin Thorne reposted

Replying to @benjaminthorne.bsky.social

Whilst the rhetoric of 'saving international justice' sounds like an appealing destination which is collectively being moved towards, however different members on this journey are reading different maps to each other & have varying notions of what the destination actually is. #USsanctions #ICC #EU

If the EU & (many) states continue to ignore the growing chorus for concrete action the immediate horizon is going to be dominated by sanction overcompliance, and it is overcompliance which could potential prove to be a drill going deep into the centre of ICC operations. #USsanctions #ICC

politico.euTop ICC official urges EU to act ‘as soon as possible’ on US sanctionsOsvaldo Zavala Giler said a “lack of clarity” from Brussels was leaving companies and NGOs in the dark after the White House imposed sweeping sanctions on the International Criminal Cou…

We can have all the talk in the world about moving away from US dependencies & building digital resilience, however non of that will really matter if on a large scale companies decide to withdraw from engaging with the ICC because of uncertainty around possible risk. www.politico.eu/article/icc-...

politico.euTop ICC official urges EU to act ‘as soon as possible’ on US sanctionsOsvaldo Zavala Giler said a “lack of clarity” from Brussels was leaving companies and NGOs in the dark after the White House imposed sweeping sanctions on the International Criminal Cou…

The ICC Registrar is completely correct to be frustrated with the EU (& states) and to publicly express this frustration. We are likely to see more and more of these fragmentations & rifts emerging in the coming months. #USsanctions #ICC #EU #internationaljustice www.politico.eu/article/icc-...

politico.euTop ICC official urges EU to act ‘as soon as possible’ on US sanctionsOsvaldo Zavala Giler said a “lack of clarity” from Brussels was leaving companies and NGOs in the dark after the White House imposed sweeping sanctions on the International Criminal Cou…

Whilst the rhetoric of 'saving international justice' sounds like an appealing destination which is collectively being moved towards, however different members on this journey are reading different maps to each other & have varying notions of what the destination actually is. #USsanctions #ICC #EU

This is an important recognition for the court, however it is somewhat problematic for the EU on the one hand to recognize the court's, and its officials, work upholding international justice, whilst simultaneously being indecisive & arguably weak regarding its responses to the US sanctions. #ICC

Dr Benjamin Thorne @benjaminthorne.bsky.social

The 2026 Sakharov Prize for Freedom of Thought is collectively awarded to the International Criminal Court (ICC) and its officials. #ICC #internationaljustice - www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/pres...

With the US sanctions against the ICC, one current conversation regarding building resilience for the court is digital sovereignty, and whilst this is a important issue, however discussions tend to assume and start with #sanctions #ICC

What would be a useful inclusion in these conversations around the court and digital sovereignty is a more nuanced engagement with current debates and divergences on how the term is being used by various actors. #sanctions #ICC

View full thread

1) Bullies (Trump) don't compromise 2) There appears, at least at this stage, to be very little compromises available to states, the ICC and organizations which would not entail throwing away the integrity and legitimacy of the court. #Ussanctions #internationalcriminalcourt #ICC

asia.nikkei.comJapan looks for off-ramp from Trump's ICC feud before US sanctions kick inHigh-level talks continue as Washington demands changes to International Criminal Court

Dr Benjamin Thorne reposted

Implementing responses & building resistance to US aggression against the ICC is going to require a massive amount of substantial collaboration across a diverse range of actors and networks. Whether this type of collaboration can be implemented to the extent required is an ongoing question. #ICC

Implementing responses & building resistance to US aggression against the ICC is going to require a massive amount of substantial collaboration across a diverse range of actors and networks. Whether this type of collaboration can be implemented to the extent required is an ongoing question. #ICC

Many companies & orgs are not going to decide to resist overcompliance with US sanctions against the ICC purely because it is in the stated interests of international Justice. Kallas calls ON 'firms not to overcomply with sanctions.' - www.politico.eu/article/kaja... #USsanctions #ICC

politico.euKallas buys time on EU response to US sanctions against the ICCEuropean lawmakers have been pushing the EU executive to take swift action over U.S. sanctions against the Hague-based court.

#Ussanctions #ICC There needs to be something much more concrete and commercially plausible offered in order for the associated risks of not overcomplying to make sense to them. #Ussanctions #ICC #internationalcriminalcourt www.politico.eu/article/kaja...

politico.euKallas buys time on EU response to US sanctions against the ICCEuropean lawmakers have been pushing the EU executive to take swift action over U.S. sanctions against the Hague-based court.

Dr Benjamin Thorne reposted

#Syria - Trials on violence committed against the Alawite population in March 2025 have concluded in Aleppo, ten months after the first hearing. 13 verdicts were pronounced in two separate sessions between 17 September and 15 October. www.justiceinfo.net/en/167585-al... #JusticeInSyria

justiceinfo.netAlawite massacres trials: verdicts handed down in AleppoTrials on violence committed against the Alawite population on the Syrian coast in March 2025 have concluded in Aleppo (north-west Syria), ten months after the first hearing on November 18, 2025. Afte...

When discussing the US sanctions against the ICC it is worth noting that there is some difference in the 4 General Licences in terms of expiration. GL 13 (Maintenance and Wind-Down of Operations) is set to expire on the 7th April 2027. This is the 6 month deadline that is commonly #ICC #USsanctions

being referred to in terms of 'dialogue and negotiations' with the Trump admisntration. The other 3 GL have no specified expiration date: GL14 (Telecommunications and Enterprise Software), GL15 (Pension Payments) and GL 16 (Transactions Related to Certain ICC Detainees). #ICC #USsanctions

Publicly embracing the need for dialogue with the US administration to negotiate sanctions against the ICC, is, amongst other things, clearly an effort to give some time for the court and states to be as prepared as possible for when the sanctions take effect in April. #ICC #USsanctions #States

View full thread

remember that when invoking the phrase 'states' they are not a homogenous entity. For example, for medium/small size states, such as Belgium, the option of different responses is not necessarily a either/or option, rather #internationalcriminalcourt #ICC #USsanctions #states

Publicly embracing the need for dialogue with the US administration to negotiate sanctions against the ICC, is, amongst other things, clearly an effort to give some time for the court and states to be as prepared as possible for when the sanctions take effect in April. #ICC #USsanctions #States

Ongoing contingency planning alongside the preparation of legal instruments will be a central part of this. It is clear to most that negotiations with the US are not going to result in the withdrawal of sanctions (without sacrificing the legitimacy of the court). However it is important to