Derek Silva

Derek Silva

@derekcrim.bsky.social

// prof, writer, podcaster 🍉 // words in Time, LA Times, The Guardian, etc. // podcast @endofsportpod.bsky.social // book link in bio @uncpress.bsky.social https://uncpress.org/book/9781469683461/the-end-of-college-football/

6.9K followers1K following778 posts

Pinned

1/9 We cannot accept the findings of the federal CASE report. The methodology is fundamentally broken. Its data is highly questionable, but the resulting political weaponization is actively harmful. We unpack why for @canadiandimension.bsky.social. canadiandimension.com/articles/vie...

canadiandimension.comCampus antisemitism report is based on fundamentally flawed methodologyStudents deserve protection from bigotry. Antisemitism exists in Canadian society and must be confronted, and this study documents real examples. However, its methodology is flawed: by merging critiq...
Canadian Dimension@canadiandimension.bsky.social

A federal report on campus antisemitism makes sweeping claims from a self-selected, unweighted sample. It also repeatedly blurs the line between antisemitism and criticism of Israel, write @nkalamb.bsky.social, @derekcrim.bsky.social, @dansailofsky.bsky.social, and @privaricate.bsky.social.

Derek Silva reposted

really appreciated yall having me chat about the really cool, you-won't-find-this-elsewhere stuff we're doing at readeyeblack.com, and, despite the challenges of producing good storytelling in a struggling industry, building work you can believe in!

The End of Sport@endofsportpod.bsky.social

The State of Sports Journalism in 2026 @bwd.bsky.social joins to discuss the sports/media complex, pro sport GBV malfeasance, Colin Kaepernick AI slop, and Palestine and athlete activism. open.spotify.com/episode/1lfg...

I think that “injuries are part of football” is a massive understatement. There are very few sports where *devastating,* life-altering injury is fundamental to the functional play of the game. Football is not morally defensible commodity spectacle.

Nathan Kalman-Lamb@nkalamb.bsky.social

Two college football players have died from football related injuries this year. One hundred years ago this was cause for reevaluating the place of the sport in universities. Today? Barely rates mention. sports.yahoo.com/articles/col...

Derek Silva reposted

Techbro professors everywhere screaming about the relationship they have developed with their chat bot

Nathan Kalman-Lamb@nkalamb.bsky.social

Personally, I think it would be embarrassing to have to acknowledge the use of AI in the production of academic work, particularly at the sentence level.

Derek Silva reposted

Thread. Still disgusted by how @thebigstory.bsky.social laundered this crap.

Derek Silva@derekcrim.bsky.social

1/9 We cannot accept the findings of the federal CASE report. The methodology is fundamentally broken. Its data is highly questionable, but the resulting political weaponization is actively harmful. We unpack why for @canadiandimension.bsky.social. canadiandimension.com/articles/vie...

Derek Silva reposted

At the end of the day, the Canadian government's Campus Antisemitism and Student Experiences (CASE) study is propaganda politics laundered as legitimate social science by Canadian scholars. We break down all the methodological flaws in this work of professional malpractice 👇.

Derek Silva@derekcrim.bsky.social

1/9 We cannot accept the findings of the federal CASE report. The methodology is fundamentally broken. Its data is highly questionable, but the resulting political weaponization is actively harmful. We unpack why for @canadiandimension.bsky.social. canadiandimension.com/articles/vie...

1/9 We cannot accept the findings of the federal CASE report. The methodology is fundamentally broken. Its data is highly questionable, but the resulting political weaponization is actively harmful. We unpack why for @canadiandimension.bsky.social. canadiandimension.com/articles/vie...

canadiandimension.comCampus antisemitism report is based on fundamentally flawed methodologyStudents deserve protection from bigotry. Antisemitism exists in Canadian society and must be confronted, and this study documents real examples. However, its methodology is flawed: by merging critiq...
Canadian Dimension@canadiandimension.bsky.social

A federal report on campus antisemitism makes sweeping claims from a self-selected, unweighted sample. It also repeatedly blurs the line between antisemitism and criticism of Israel, write @nkalamb.bsky.social, @derekcrim.bsky.social, @dansailofsky.bsky.social, and @privaricate.bsky.social.

View full thread

Derek Silva reposted

Our piece on the specious CASE report is out now at @CDN_Dimension Derek's thread on the article's main arguments 👇🏽

Derek Silva@derekcrim.bsky.social

1/9 We cannot accept the findings of the federal CASE report. The methodology is fundamentally broken. Its data is highly questionable, but the resulting political weaponization is actively harmful. We unpack why for @canadiandimension.bsky.social. canadiandimension.com/articles/vie...

1/9 We cannot accept the findings of the federal CASE report. The methodology is fundamentally broken. Its data is highly questionable, but the resulting political weaponization is actively harmful. We unpack why for @canadiandimension.bsky.social. canadiandimension.com/articles/vie...

canadiandimension.comCampus antisemitism report is based on fundamentally flawed methodologyStudents deserve protection from bigotry. Antisemitism exists in Canadian society and must be confronted, and this study documents real examples. However, its methodology is flawed: by merging critiq...
Canadian Dimension@canadiandimension.bsky.social

A federal report on campus antisemitism makes sweeping claims from a self-selected, unweighted sample. It also repeatedly blurs the line between antisemitism and criticism of Israel, write @nkalamb.bsky.social, @derekcrim.bsky.social, @dansailofsky.bsky.social, and @privaricate.bsky.social.

View full thread

7/9 Antisemitism is real and students absolutely deserve protection – yet weaponizing a fundamentally flawed study doesn’t keep anyone safe. It merely provides administrative cover to censor and surveil legitimate student academic freedom.

8/9 Funding such a questionable project while anti-Palestinian racism skyrockets across our institutions tells you everything you need to know about the actual priorities at play. Bad science protects no one. We absolutely have to do better.

1/9 We cannot accept the findings of the federal CASE report. The methodology is fundamentally broken. Its data is highly questionable, but the resulting political weaponization is actively harmful. We unpack why for @canadiandimension.bsky.social. canadiandimension.com/articles/vie...

canadiandimension.comCampus antisemitism report is based on fundamentally flawed methodologyStudents deserve protection from bigotry. Antisemitism exists in Canadian society and must be confronted, and this study documents real examples. However, its methodology is flawed: by merging critiq...
Canadian Dimension@canadiandimension.bsky.social

A federal report on campus antisemitism makes sweeping claims from a self-selected, unweighted sample. It also repeatedly blurs the line between antisemitism and criticism of Israel, write @nkalamb.bsky.social, @derekcrim.bsky.social, @dansailofsky.bsky.social, and @privaricate.bsky.social.

View full thread

5/9 The report claims 95.7% of respondents experienced or witnessed antisemitism. Predictably, media repeated this ad nauseum. But the authors buried a crucial finding. 92% of students who said Zionism was not important to them reported their campus was safe and inclusive.

6/9 This exposes a massive problem around what we call construct validity. The survey instrument collapses Jews, Judaism, Israel, and Zionism into a single monolithic category. It makes separating actual bigotry from political critique of a foreign state analytically impossible.

1/9 We cannot accept the findings of the federal CASE report. The methodology is fundamentally broken. Its data is highly questionable, but the resulting political weaponization is actively harmful. We unpack why for @canadiandimension.bsky.social. canadiandimension.com/articles/vie...

canadiandimension.comCampus antisemitism report is based on fundamentally flawed methodologyStudents deserve protection from bigotry. Antisemitism exists in Canadian society and must be confronted, and this study documents real examples. However, its methodology is flawed: by merging critiq...
Canadian Dimension@canadiandimension.bsky.social

A federal report on campus antisemitism makes sweeping claims from a self-selected, unweighted sample. It also repeatedly blurs the line between antisemitism and criticism of Israel, write @nkalamb.bsky.social, @derekcrim.bsky.social, @dansailofsky.bsky.social, and @privaricate.bsky.social.

View full thread

3/9 In that piece, the authors defend making sweeping, generalized quantitative claims based entirely on an unweighted, self-selected convenience sample. Qualitative survey methods cannot, by definition, be generalized. It is a frankly irresponsible error. @indjewishvoices.bsky.social

1/9 We cannot accept the findings of the federal CASE report. The methodology is fundamentally broken. Its data is highly questionable, but the resulting political weaponization is actively harmful. We unpack why for @canadiandimension.bsky.social. canadiandimension.com/articles/vie...

canadiandimension.comCampus antisemitism report is based on fundamentally flawed methodologyStudents deserve protection from bigotry. Antisemitism exists in Canadian society and must be confronted, and this study documents real examples. However, its methodology is flawed: by merging critiq...
Canadian Dimension@canadiandimension.bsky.social

A federal report on campus antisemitism makes sweeping claims from a self-selected, unweighted sample. It also repeatedly blurs the line between antisemitism and criticism of Israel, write @nkalamb.bsky.social, @derekcrim.bsky.social, @dansailofsky.bsky.social, and @privaricate.bsky.social.

Derek Silva reposted

Deep-dive into the controversy engulfing the UEFA Nations League fixtures btw Ireland & Israel. Irish Sport for Palestine's Rebecca O’Keeffe breaks it all down w/ @privaricate.bsky.social & @nkalamb.bsky.social on @endofsportpod.bsky.social ahead of Sunday's rematch open.spotify.com/episode/0hbo...

Jules Boykoff@julesboykoff.bsky.social

My latest, co-written with @edgeofsports.bsky.social: "Irish Goalkeeper Gavin Bazunu’s Refusal to Play Against Israel Puts Him on the Right Side of History." For @thenation.com www.thenation.com/article/soci...

I think the most striking thing for me is Rubin accuses **everyone else** of doing politics instead of looking in the mirror.

Julian Go@juliango.bsky.social

Latest news: 2 of my sociology colleagues, John Levi Martin & Geoff Wodtke & I each wrote separate reviews of the Vanderbilt-Wash U Report on Sociology by A. Rubin. For my brief opinion and links to all 3 reviews, see this blogpost: scatter.wordpress.com/2026/09/19/g...

Anyway, I find it humorous that Rubin doesn't see the irony in statements about sociology losing credibility because of supposed "politicization" without realizing (or admitting) that she is literally doing politics with shit research. Can't make this stuff up.

I am not sure I agree with the critique that Rubin doesn't have a PhD in sociology so can't speak to sociology (seems a bit gatekeeper to me) but I do think the rest of this stands as a strong response to shitty "research."

John Levi Martin's response to Rubin's report. It used AI which gets a big NO from me, but I guess this is what we have to live with now. The reason I am sharing it is because it systematically dismantles basically every one of Rubin's bad claims. osf.io/preprints/so...

Derek Silva reposted

This (superb) reporting reveals ASU has basically attempted a full cover-up and the only reason they aren’t going to get away with it is the genuine courage and solidarity of his teammates. Very rare in college sport.

Nathan Kalman-Lamb@nkalamb.bsky.social

Exceptional solidarity from ASU hockey players who have demanded their coach be placed on leave for essentially overseeing the murder of their teammate and have disputed the university’s findings. www.nytimes.com/athletic/764...

Derek Silva reposted

Today’s absolute must read from @julesboykoff.bsky.social and @edgeofsports.bsky.social. 👇👇👇

Jules Boykoff@julesboykoff.bsky.social

My latest, co-written with @edgeofsports.bsky.social: "Irish Goalkeeper Gavin Bazunu’s Refusal to Play Against Israel Puts Him on the Right Side of History." For @thenation.com www.thenation.com/article/soci...

Derek Silva reposted

"Institutions that recruit international athletes & benefit from their athletic labor must build systems capable of supporting them when their immigration status places them at risk," write @nkalamb.bsky.social Simran Kaur Sethi, & @derekcrim.bsky.social in a powerful & important essay

Nathan Kalman-Lamb@nkalamb.bsky.social

ICE has abducted Senegalese WBB player Aminata Seck and won't release her. DHS 'policy' is to provide medical care to prisoners at intake, yet they admit to denying her care for an ACL injury for 1.5 months. The NCAA is letting it happen, despite its predatory recruitment of ICAs. We explain.

Derek Silva reposted

'International college athletes are among the most exploited campus athletic workers in the current political economy of US college athletics...' @nkalamb.bsky.social, Simran Kaur Sethi, & @derekcrim.bsky.social shed light on the case of Aminata Seck who was abducted by ICE in August this year

Nathan Kalman-Lamb@nkalamb.bsky.social

ICE has abducted Senegalese WBB player Aminata Seck and won't release her. DHS 'policy' is to provide medical care to prisoners at intake, yet they admit to denying her care for an ACL injury for 1.5 months. The NCAA is letting it happen, despite its predatory recruitment of ICAs. We explain.

Derek Silva reposted

Shoutout to SSHRC for making it impossible to submit a reference letter for a student that is finished and ready to go. Great use of everyone’s time and effort!

READ THIS.

Jules Boykoff@julesboykoff.bsky.social

My new academic article—"Greenwashing in Technicolor: The 2026 FIFA World Cup"—was just published by @cnsjournal.bsky.social. 50 free copies are available here: www.tandfonline.com/eprint/XWNYM...