David J. DeVore

David J. DeVore

@devoretext.bsky.social

Ancient Mediterranean historian, Cal Poly Pomona. History, the human past (those 2 aren't the same), politics, some baseball. Views here not of my institution.

2.1K followers1.2K following2.7K posts

Pinned

David J. DeVore reposted

Happy 80th anniversary of "Wittgenstein attacks Popper with a red-hot fire poker at a meeting of the Cambridge Moral Sciences Club" Day to all who celebrate #philosophy

David J. DeVore reposted

Replying to @mollyknight.bsky.social

It’s never been about money. If you could buy a championship the mets would have several. The Yankees would have won several since 2009. It’s about organizational competency, top-to-bottom. The Brewers, Rays, and Dodgers are the three best run orgs in the sport.

I’ll try to paraphrase: No one is totally neutral. It’s good to critique others’ biases. And bad to pretend you’re neutral.

Hakeem Jefferson@hakeemjefferson.bsky.social

Apropos of nothing, let me say this: Questioning the normative assumptions that motivate a focus on something like polarization IS NOT an anti-intellectual project. Pretending that one’s arguments or perspectives are free of normative commitments is the unserious, anti-intellectual make-believe.

From now on I’ll DM to alert you that I’m attacking your skeet.🫡😉

Josh Marshall@joshtpm.bsky.social

Okay, to all whom it may concern: it's no fair to delete your tweet right as i'm responding/attacking you for it. Okay? this is a long established rule. Thank you for your attention to this matter.

David J. DeVore reposted

Replying to @besttrousers.bsky.social

Lots of AI development has been aimed at software engineering, and a lot of tasks are not particularly like software engineering.

David J. DeVore reposted

Brilliant mathematician Emmy Noether was initially barred from teaching at University of Göttingen because she was a woman. She taught for 4 years as a "guest lecturer" under David Hilbert's name. Hilbert, exasperated at the stupidity of the rule: "Gentlemen, this is not a bathing establishment."

artsci.tamu.eduFrom Algebra to Airplane Crashes, Emmy Noether’s Lasting Influence on MathematicsEmmy Noether, whom some consider the “Mother of Modern Mathematics,” continues to shape modern research and the studies of mathematicians today; including research into the investigation of airplane c...

David J. DeVore reposted

Your regular reminder: If the Russians stop fighting, the war ends. If the Ukrainians stop fighting, their land will be occupied, their leaders will be killed, their history and language will be erased, their children will be kidnapped to serve Russia.

Notice who’s rejecting the “turn the page“ precedent? Trump himself, plus his Congress. Look at DOJ’s & Congress’ investigative targets (Comey, James, Fulton County, Fauci). Seems as though accountability is exactly what Trump is asking for.

This post is unavailable.

David J. DeVore reposted

AI proponents always say that “AI is already here, might as well embrace it.” But isn’t the opposite also true? If AI is already here, isn’t the rational response to put up guardrails to ensure that it doesn’t kill us all or violate privacy? We did the same with automobiles and airplanes

”Balance” is IMHO a poorly conceived ideal in academic hiring. It implies a bipolar ideological scale instead of a multidimensional perspectival space. I’m all for viewpoint diversity but not for fetishizing any one ideology. If you accept the polarity of ideology, you‘re conceding too much.

This post is unavailable.

David J. DeVore reposted

Replying to @jamellebouie.net

yeah, the thing is that if you want to give jefferson credit for creating the conditions for abolition, you also have to give him responsibility for the rapid expansion of slavery and the concomitant growth of a massive domestic slave trade: see the LA purchase and the 1808 int’l slave trade ban.

Nick Garcia @nwgarcia.bsky.social

Maybe you want to argue that Jefferson set conditions for abolition to become possible, I don't know enough of the minutiae to have that argument. But what you don't get to do is absolve him of his sins because abolition eventually did happen under those conditions. No. Absolutely not.

David J. DeVore reposted

this seems…insane? and on the face of it, a good example of how not to do historical thinking?

Pat Sobkowski@patsobkowski.com

Okay. I very much look forward to reading this paper and/or hearing the lecture if it’s recorded.

Yes. 1) Semantically, “human nature“ implies immutable & intractable. 2) Rhetorically, invoking “nature“ lumps the phenomenon under discussion with pretty much all reality in the cosmos rather than analyzing the phenomenon in question. It’s an intellectual copout.

This post is unavailable.

David J. DeVore reposted

(The post being quoted is kind of odd given that most actual historians aren’t obsessed with dates—which I say as one of the more date-conscious of our species.)

Mar Hicks@histoftech.bsky.social

Optimist: The cup is half full Pessimist: The cup is half empty Historian: The cup can teach you a lot of things that you do not want to know

Maybe unpopular opinion: ”if a Dem president did X, think how the media would react!” is a counterfactual. At best counterfactuals are thought experiments that raise new possibilities but no new facts; at worst they’re wishful thinking. They vent outrage but persuade no one to change their mind. 1/

Josh Marshall@joshtpm.bsky.social

Probably about time to formalize #IADP (if any Democratic President ...) as a hashtag

It's better to find an actual example of a Democratic (or whatever) president doing X and making the comparison. In fact, there often are examples of previous presidents doing such acts in the Trump era for comparison. /end

David J. DeVore reposted

This is an important question but very difficult to answer. A thread on the Christianization of the Roman _State_ which by proxy gives us some insight on the Christianization of the Roman _World_

Matt Gabriele@profgabriele.com

I know the era of mass conversion to Christianity didn't happen until at least the 4th century, but is there a point at which we can definitively say that the Roman world was MAJORITY Christian? #medievalsky

Do dumb wars demand a smart takeaway? (FTR, I mostly avoid the terms "smart" & "dumb" bc they're analytically blunt. There are lots of ways to be "smart" or "dumb" & it's almost always more helpful to identify those ways than hurl the broad, shaming words. But here the "dumb" shoe fits perfectly.)

"Online Rent-a-Sage" Bret Devereaux@bretdevereaux.bsky.social

Apologies if I sound angry, but it is a real problem that the 'smart' commentary on this war is trying hard to avoid the core lesson ("the president is a fucking moron") because it doesn't sound very clever when it is absolutely the most important takeaway from this debacle.

A great use of @archive.org. Please consider donating if you don't already: archive.org/donate/

archive.orgInternet Archive: Digital Library of Free & Borrowable Texts, Movies, Music & Wayback Machine
Eric Rauchway@rauchway.bsky.social

BUT WAIT! The plot thickens. @randytayler.com is correct about the anachronism but @metaclaudia.bsky.social points out the source is a 1992 CD of BBS pics, to be found at the Internet Archive (bless them) link below. I have independently verified the 1970 Plymouth pic & archive.org/details/GIFs...

When Rand Paul is right, he’s right. Also: I think both the families of our Service members and the parents of the Iranian schoolgirls killed in the US strike would say there’ve been “significant casualties.”

Aaron Rupar@atrupar.com

Sen. Rand Paul: "I've had the debate with this administration ... they told me this isn't a war. I said, why isn't it a war? They said, 'Well, a constitutional war has to have significant casualties' ... initiation or declaration of war is *before* the casualties."

1) Not pronouncing the “r” In “February.” 2) Spelling the past-tense of “lead” the same as the present tense. 3) “the decline of the Roman Empire” placed anytime before the Seljuks 4) ”the fall of the Roman Empire” placed anytime before 1204

This post is unavailable.

David J. DeVore reposted

Replying to @ericmgarcia.bsky.social

There are no laws of history. The analogous physical sciences aren't physics or chemistry, where there are laws, but evolutionary biology and historical geology, where you're explaining past events from partial evidence and so you can't simply model with equations or perform controlled experiments.

1) Aristotle’s Rhetoric, Loeb Classical Library edition (forgot I owned it, bought a second copy; later gave one to a friend) 2) Garry Wills, Reagan’s America (sold it back but needed it for another class) 3) Fergus Miller, The Roman Near East (gave it away for a relocation but needed it again)

Sophia_Nyx 🐰@sophianyx.bsky.social

Name physical media you purchased more than once.

David J. DeVore reposted

There is a lot to say about the Nolan Odyssey movie. But one point that I think has not been emphasized enough is: this is a film about living in LA, as Nolan, my erstwhile British compatriot and age mate, has done for years. I gather it’s a strange place.

Yes. Thermopylae was in fact a crushing defeat with zero upside for the Spartans. Hans van Wees, a top historian of ancient Greek militaries, proved this in 2018: www.researchgate.net/publication/...

researchgate.netThermopylae: Herodotus versus the Legend | Request PDFRequest PDF | On Nov 2, 2018, Hans van Wees published Thermopylae: Herodotus versus the Legend | Find, read and cite all the research you need on ResearchGate
⚸ Gingersnapped 🐺🌕🎃@gingerspiced.bsky.social

Pete Hegseth: "We need our warriors to embrace the Spartan mindset" U.S. Military: *suffers crushing defeat to the Persians*

David J. DeVore reposted

I’m honoured & proud to be a new FBA — a member of an institution which is defending the value of the Social Sciences, Humanities and Arts in a period when they are increasingly under threat. These disciplines are crucial for a rich, deep and critical understanding of the world.

The British Academy@britishacademy.bsky.social

The British Academy has elected 92 new Fellows in recognition of their outstanding contributions to the humanities and social sciences. Congratulations to all those elected today. Read the full announcement: https://bit.ly/4f64C4x

David J. DeVore reposted

Releasing public statements, covertly messaging on social media, trying to influence foreign leaders... Like diplomatic corps and intel agencies? Normal. Manipulating election and legal processes? Abnormal, worth countering. And as Trump just showed, the only country doing that to the US is Russia.

Will Sommer@willsommer.bsky.social

Trump's big document release tonight, supposedly meant to prove China stole the 2020 election, includes this classified intel graphic making clear that Russia was the only country trying to meddle in American voting systems.