André Brett

André Brett

@drdrehistorian.bsky.social

Historians wanna talk like they got something to say | NZ and Australian history, politics, trains, music, sport, higher ed | he/him | "Australian-adjacent person": Melburnian Kiwi in Perth

4.5K followers760 following12K posts

Pinned

It seems an opportune time to do an intro thread, since I'm included in some quite different starter packs. My bio note about "NZ and Australian history, politics, trains, music, sport, higher ed" covers the topics I post about the most, and I do *not* stick consistently to any one of them 1/18

Me: Australia not picking Boland has made it a very easy choice to watch the NZ vs India T20I instead of the Test Me, a few minutes later, after India blast 43 off the first two overs when chasing 200: so, uh, what’s cricket? There’s a NEW Zealand now?

lmao Australia not picking Boland, do they want to lose the Test? For mine, the "Lyon vs Boland" question is the wrong one to ask. He's much more than their 4th pacer. Pick Cummins first as captain, then Boland as clearly the best bowler, and only third decide on either or both of Starc or Hazlewood

"But the preferred option comes with a price tag of more than half a billion." Oh no! We couldn't possibly run hourly trains between two of the North Island's three biggest cities for a price tag as steep as *checks notes* 1/7th the cost of a motorway to save a few minutes on the drive to Northland

I was deeply confused by "nice and fancy restaurant" and I've now learnt that unlike the Cheesecake Shop in Aus/NZ, which sells the desserts indicated by its name, the Cheesecake Factory in the US is a family restaurant chain with famously cheesecake-related menu items like steak, pasta, and salad

This post is unavailable.

If I walked into our Cheesecake Shop and found the focus of the business was not on selling desserts, I’d be vexed. It would be like Liquorland turning out to be principally a furniture superstore with a sideline of beers and wines to enjoy in your comfy new armchair or at a nice outdoor setting

André Brett reposted

The AHA today wrote to the Tasmanian House of Assembly registering its opposition to proposed budgetary cuts to TMAG. Cultural institutions like TMAG are crucial to the preservation of state and national histories, and these proposed budget cuts significantly threaten their necessary work.

Me: we should increase the size of parliament somewhat Rustie: 130-seat parliament via overhang seats Me: no not like that

The Overhang@overhang-aonz.bsky.social

Some of you are going to hate this one: theoverhangaonz.substack.com/p/the-overha...

NZ used to have on-the-day voter registration but this year rolls close TONIGHT with early voting from tomorrow. It's interesting watching the discourse (which on here uniformly—and rightly—sees this as regressive) from Australia, where rolls close a week after writs are issued for federal elections

Rules vary for state and territory elections: if you're in Victoria, with a state election on 27 Nov, your deadline to register is 8pm on 3 Nov. WA, by contrast, *does* allow on-the-day rego. I haven't seen much chatter building momentum to make this nationwide though

"Everything is worse" attitudes are untenable. Many people have posted huge global changes, so here's a personal one for me today. I'm soon having beers with my dad and his brother. Sounds unremarkable until you consider: dad is in the North Island, my uncle's in the South Island, and I'm in Perth

Social media loves talking about how everything is getting worse. But what’s something that you’ve seen get _better_ in your lifetime?

This would have been impossible the year I was born, 1987. If I wanted to talk to either of them, it would have been an expensive international phone call. Even them calling each other would've been pricey. Total cost today, besides the beers: $0 and we can see each other and talk as long as we want

Also, the beer we're drinking is out of sight better than what would've been available then. One thing we do when we have these chats is share interesting and unusual craft beers we've found. Mine today are from the Blue Mountains, NSW, and Wellington, NZ. Wouldn't have got those in Perth in 1987!

André Brett reposted

Travelling 350 miles north from Sept-Iles, Québec, to the middle of nowhere - or to be precise: Schefferville, a mining town with a population of 250 - along one of the most remote railway lines in the world, today.

One of the all-time great Test victories. Basically two days lost to rain, almost everybody wrote off the prospect of a result, and when there was any play South Africa found themselves 4/40 and 6/110 in the first innings—and now they've won by an innings and 31 runs Nothing like Test match cricket

Vic Libs on the cusp of electoral victory doing one more internal drama as a treat

Leroy@leroylynch.bsky.social

Grant Hutchinson sent a legal letter to the Victorian Liberals last night demanding he be reinstated as candidate for the seat of Croydon by Friday. He was stripped of his candidacy because of his party's concern that he had failed to disclose legal proceedings with his former law firm. #springst

Without totally doxxing myself, this is... erm... somewhat too close to home for comfort Good grief, just before this happened I was even talking polarisation and political violence with the students in my Australian social history unit on Curtin's Bentley campus

It's hard to fathom where these cuts can even come from. Archives NZ has already cut services that would normally be considered essential. When I tell Australians in the sector over here that in 2024 Archives NZ wound up its digitisation unit and digitisation-on-demand service, they're gobsmacked

The Press@thepress.co.nz

In separate announcements on Wednesday, Department of Internal Affairs staff learnt 24 jobs would go, and Archives and the National Library staff learnt 45 jobs would be cut.

If you've got my book Can't Get There from Here, flick to page 214. Those lovely scans of proposed colour schemes for demotorised Fiat railcars? Lucky I ordered them in 2020 because they were digitised on demand. And every other pic from Archives NZ in the book is thanks to the old digitisation unit

André Brett reposted

Just keep stabbing the nation in the brain

The Press@thepress.co.nz

In separate announcements on Wednesday, Department of Internal Affairs staff learnt 24 jobs would go, and Archives and the National Library staff learnt 45 jobs would be cut.

If you want to know how bad public transport is in New Zealand, you need look no further than the fact long weekend rail services in the nation's largest city are a novelty and that NYE, in many cities one of the busiest PT nights of the year, *still* won't have operations on the entire network

NZ Transit Buzz@nztransitbuzz.bsky.social

#RailNews: Auckland Transport & KiwiRail have announced that Aucklanders can catch a train on Labour Weekend for the first time in five years and can look forward to rail services on the majority of the rail network New Year’s Eve. Timetables for NYE have yet to be published.

People in NZ too often treat this as a normal or natural state of affairs when it is the product of decades of underfunding and mismanagement, it should never have been allowed to occur in the first place, and allegedly ambitious proposals for NZ are in fact just fixing what should never have broken

Nice to know my state minister thinks that my colleagues and I are offering a subpar education and poor campus experience (at three separate unis), apparently on the basis of a sole student's anecdote Let's run through his goals/complaints and whether a merger is a relevant way to address them...

View full thread

"Dr Buti said greater accountability and transparency was needed to divert money from executive salaries and wasteful projects." Agreed! Let's start by not initiating another wasteful project, a mega-merger, and instead improve teaching conditions and research funding at our existing unis

Safe to say if this got handed in as an essay, I'd be giving it a poor mark for failing to demonstrate the relevance of most contentions to the topic This merger brainfart is a solution in search of a problem that does nothing to address the real issues holding back the potential of WA's unis

Nice to know my state minister thinks that my colleagues and I are offering a subpar education and poor campus experience (at three separate unis), apparently on the basis of a sole student's anecdote Let's run through his goals/complaints and whether a merger is a relevant way to address them...

View full thread

"university executives were getting paid too much" I agree entirely—but yet again, relevance? I wouldn't be shocked if the senior executives of this mega-uni, if it came into existence, demanded even *higher* salaries for the complexity of managing it

"He quoted from a National Tertiary Education Union document that found executives had 'mismanaged their existing funding with warped spending priorities' leading to 'unjustified job cuts, reduced course offerings and vanity projects'" A MERGER MEANS MORE CUTS & REDUCED OFFERINGS, GOOD GRIEF MATE

Nice to know my state minister thinks that my colleagues and I are offering a subpar education and poor campus experience (at three separate unis), apparently on the basis of a sole student's anecdote Let's run through his goals/complaints and whether a merger is a relevant way to address them...

View full thread

"there was duplication in university offerings" That's the point! We *want* there to be competition for students. If Curtin+Murdoch+UWA merge, the only other unis left in WA (popn: 3m) are ECU and the private NDUA. The mega-merger will be the main/sole uni for many disciplines. That's not good!

"completion rates were unacceptably low" Again, how will a mega-merger address this? I expect it to get *worse* as students slip between the cracks. Many non-completions could be avoided by improving staff workloads and staff:student ratios; it's *already* a struggle to follow up with AWOL students

Nice to know my state minister thinks that my colleagues and I are offering a subpar education and poor campus experience (at three separate unis), apparently on the basis of a sole student's anecdote Let's run through his goals/complaints and whether a merger is a relevant way to address them...

View full thread

"attract greater research dollars than we are currently getting" Not clear what a merger has to do with this. The main limitations are small pools of funding and little time/support to apply for research grants. The $$ the govt would spend on a merger would be better spent directly on research

"the rate of regional student enrolment in tertiary education was just 12 per cent, less than half of the national average of 30 per cent" A merger has nothing to do with this complaint and will do nothing to address it. Next!

Nice to know my state minister thinks that my colleagues and I are offering a subpar education and poor campus experience (at three separate unis), apparently on the basis of a sole student's anecdote Let's run through his goals/complaints and whether a merger is a relevant way to address them...

"We want our students to have a world-class education" At a university with 120k students sprawling across 3 main campuses (or will we abandon 1–2 to crowd onto what's left?), management and admin will be even more remote from students, and individuals will disappear into a mass So that's a no