Pinned
jmargaris.substack.com/p/a-plea-for... Some people are saying "it's a new essay." On writing dialogue that reflects what a character might genuinely think, on posing the wrong questions, and 10 paragraphs on "yeah armor -- good idea."
James Margaris
@markymarg2.bsky.social
A perfectly harmless box. Game dev, half of Dark Roast Entertainment. Games criticism at http://jmargaris.substack.com
182 followers94 following2K posts
Pinned
jmargaris.substack.com/p/a-plea-for... Some people are saying "it's a new essay." On writing dialogue that reflects what a character might genuinely think, on posing the wrong questions, and 10 paragraphs on "yeah armor -- good idea."
Genuinely sad that this is the end state of this sort of community - the biggest no-lifers imaginable constantly celebrating because a game's CCU is low. There's one dude there who posts like 200 times a day doing CCU grave dancing.
now that resetera is down who's gonna inform us about the CCU of launch games
Importantly, Yglesias believes that, once Democrats win, they *still* shouldn't do anything, because that will jeopardize their chance to win *again.* This is a common belief among these Dem centrists types: we have to win because the other guys are evil but opposing evil is a losing strategy.
A helpfully clear exchange here Hasan: "So your argument is that [Minnesota ICE protesters] should stay at home because immigration is a salient issue for Donald Trump. Opposing ICE is only going to help Trump. Wait until we win the election in 2028." Yglesias: "Yes that is what I would have said"
It's worse than being infiltrated by like....paid CIA operatives or whatever. They are infiltrated by people who wreck just for the love of the game, purely out of ego. The kind of person who thinks 45 minutes of a 1-hour meeting should be about their dumb bullshit.
i don't actually think most of these groups are actually getting infiltrated or whatever but you probably should not structure your volunteer org to be maximally vulnerable to the simple sabotage field manual, as a suggestion
Fun fact: Matt Darling's main policy area is pushing to make it easier for corporations to lay people off, because he thinks that laying people off is too difficult for American corporations. Including, specifically, American video game companies. Who according to him hate doing layoffs!
Matt do you agree with the goals of the searchlight institute to make the dem party more conservative? If not why’d you join?
This is what prompted me to write about Mixtape - so much of the criticism amounted to "the wrong kind of person likes this." Where the wrong kind of person wasn't even a bad person just...white, a hipster, a millennial, etc. (I won't call that criticism dogshit but it was "left wanting"...)
sometimes you just read some dogshit criticism that gives you the sense the person writing it isn't really criticizing the game so much as the audience they imagine the game to have. It's working backwards from "who likes it" to come to a conclusion
This is similar to the "rationalists" who believe AI will kill all humans. If they genuinely believe that they should be working frantically to kill all AI researches - that would be the rational response. Instead they just send tweets and write snarky blogs. It's pure LARP.
I don't know how precisely to articulate this but...there is a level to which people are simply LARPing stuff, and I feel like we could solve a lot of problems and make other problems easier to deal with if we could simply switch off the LARP and deal with things as they are
Instant pivot from "how dare you accuse of us making up news" to "yeah we made it up, so what?" "Proved controversial." Yes - it is in fact "controversial" when journalists make up news stories! This is "well we started a conversation!" (based on something we made up wholesale)
Ok correction - the story they planted was the one about schools giving out pro-furry homework (or something), which dovetailed with the litterboxes story. Now that said, Jesse's writeup incudes the following: "After all, who doesn’t long for the chance to debunk their own hoax?"
This is a good time to remind people that Jesse had his podcast producer "break" - aka entirely make up - a story about furry kids using litterboxes in public schools, which morphed into a story about trans kids using litterboxes at schools, for podcast "content."
You own website still has a writeup about how *you* made up the story that you want credit for debunking. (lol) www.blockedandreported.org/p/how-i-conv... Even the Blocked and Reported superfans were like "uh journalists making up a story seems bad!" Yeah - that does seem bad!
This is all extremely well-documented. The only question here is if Jesse knew about this hoax in advance or if his podcast producer went behind his back. But that producer wasn't fired or even reprimanded, and the hoax was made into podcast "content" so hmm....
YOU STARTED THE RUMOR. Your podcast producer wrote about this AT LENGTH and you did an episode about how YOU planted this story. You want credit for debunking a hoax that YOU perpetrated? Be serious.
One of the episodes was 112. They claim that they planted the story as a sort of Sokal test. So Jesse, who is obsessed with what he thinks are outrageous identity issues among kids, made up a story about outrageous identity issues among kids, but as some sort of double-reverse psychology? Lol.
The thing that's weird about "you don't like new ideas" here is that the game feels like an average of 20 other modern indie Metroidvania games. What are the new ideas?
Really feeling the “oh you like pancakes, so you hate waffles/dat is a whole new sentence” vibe when I say I wish Belmont’s Curse demo felt more like Castlevania and people act like I’m some sort of old gaming traditionalist who could never possibly accept change or new ideas.
This is a good time to remind people that Jesse had his podcast producer "break" - aka entirely make up - a story about furry kids using litterboxes in public schools, which morphed into a story about trans kids using litterboxes at schools, for podcast "content."
If you push out a rumor that turns out to be 100% bullshit, you didn't "break a story."
I think it's weird that 3 months ago you were a normal person and now your entire life revolves entirely around a holy war you imagine you're in with "antis." Nobody is even fighting against you, your tweets get zero or one replies lol. It's all from reading Reddit or whatever.
I think it's weird that 3 months ago you were a normal person and now your entire life revolves entirely around a holy war you imagine you're in with "antis." Nobody is even fighting against you, your tweets get zero or one replies lol. It's all from reading Reddit or whatever.
Small self-plug, I wrote about a related topic recently here: jmargaris.substack.com/p/a-plea-for... Carrie is more an issue of authentic action than dialogue, but same principle: ask "what would this character do?" without adding "in a CW show"
What makes the movie is she's sympathetic until you get to that scene and it turns into Shit's Complicated (tm) rather than straightforward revenge. It's, for lack of a better term, very "real." How a person might actually behave, not how a sympathetic girlboss would girlboss it up.
Crazy that this series is devoted to missing the point of the original and balking on the single most interesting aspect of it. I watched the movie in I dunno...the 90s? And I still remember Carrie losing it and murdering even the people who were nice to her. That *makes* the movie!
What if I'm polite very sarcastically, like "great job lil buddy" or "this is totally wrong but great effort" or "thank u king for this sadly incorrect information"? I'm not saying I talk to LLMs this way. But, just theoretically, if I did....
I don't think LLMs are conscious but I do think (and I don't know if there have been studies on this or if this has been verified, it is just something I think is likely) people who regularly use LLMs and also frequently behave extremely abusively to LLMs are more likely to be dicks to humans too
This is what I've been talking about with regards to romantasy readers and how their attitude is becoming widespread. All "content" is becoming kink/fetish porn where people know exactly what they want and demand work that, while low quality, checks every box.
maybe i'm old fashion but the coolest thing about video games is being taken to new worlds that i hadn't thought up and experiencing something exciting that the artists behind the game want to show me
Porn chatbots and such make sense as a product because people have very specific wants and don't care if the quality is bad. But I think it's very bad that people use that same approach with all fiction writing, TV, video games, etc. This dovetails with AI but I don't think it's an AI issue exactly.
I'm really baffled by the people who see someone's youtube subs drop from 1.5 million to a paltry 1.48 million and are prompted to write an essay like "and yet you say you believe in prison abolition? Haven't we learned anything about draconian punishments?" Like...did you get lost?
Its weird that "you don't get to be famous anymore" is seen the same as "life in prison." Like man, you can do art without being famous. You won't make the same money or acclaim, but also...you fucked up bad, there should be some ceiling for trust to make sure you can't abuse that power further.
Not wrong but it's not like today where a PS5 and Series are 95% the same hardware and you can just compare clock speeds. The PS2 was better than the XBox in a few ways - massively higher fill rate, faster float ops, etc. Bit more apples to oranges.
There are caveats because of the capacity of the GameCube's discs, but it's widely known that it and the Xbox were noticeably more powerful than the PS2, right?