Apprecate Brendan taking the time to carefully read the paper, given how much publicity is involved. Would be curious to hear Jing and co-author responses. One very small point I'd add: headline findings (0.37SD on grades, 0.9SD on participation) are ITT estimates! /1
“The current study presents findings from, to our knowledge, the first large-scale randomized experiment evaluating the effects of AI tutoring on student learning at a large U.S. public university.” The only problem is the findings are wrong. brendanbartanen.substack.com/p/ai-tutorin...