Robert Hirschfeld

Robert Hirschfeld

@rfhirschfeld.bsky.social

Director of Water Policy at Prairie Rivers Network in Illinois. The rural Midwest doesn’t have to be a sacrifice zone for corn and soybeans.

3.6K followers403 following1.6K posts

Pinned

Much like the human figures etched onto the Pioneer spacecraft plates, this water tower ensures that, should any intelligent lifeforms arrive in Ashkum, they will understand the nature of its inhabitants.

Q: Who is standing in the way of “better industrial ag?” A: Industrial ag.

Tamar Haspel@tamarhaspel.bsky.social

The answer to bad industrial agriculture isn't non-industrial ag, it's better industrial ag. Yet the good-food movement has been all in on non-industrial, thanks in large part to the work of 2 people who are excellent writers & good men: Wendell Berry & Michael Pollan. (gift link) wapo.st/47sistr

Robert Hirschfeld reposted

The public not having the right to a return on the massive investment we make in farm subsidies is a constant of US ag policy. Though the New Deal farm bill subsidies were touted as promoting conservation, they really didn't. Now we have many fewer, MUCH larger operations. Change is necessary.

Robert Hirschfeld@rfhirschfeld.bsky.social

The public is expected to constantly bail out row crop agriculture. Meanwhile the public is told that we cannot demand anything back from our investment--no pollution reduction, no wetlands protections, no soil conservation, no crop diversification. Just hand over the money.

The public is expected to constantly bail out row crop agriculture. Meanwhile the public is told that we cannot demand anything back from our investment--no pollution reduction, no wetlands protections, no soil conservation, no crop diversification. Just hand over the money.

Robert Hirschfeld@rfhirschfeld.bsky.social

If these farmer bailouts go through (on top of the other farmer bailouts), we're approaching the point where government payments will make up almost half of farm income.

If these farmer bailouts go through (on top of the other farmer bailouts), we're approaching the point where government payments will make up almost half of farm income.

Aaron Rupar@atrupar.com

Trump: "I'm pleased to announce that the Department of Agriculture will be launching a new harvest fuel relief program providing our farmers with $8 billion in support to offset diesel costs during this harvest season. And Roger Marshall is the leader who fought for that to happen."

Robert Hirschfeld reposted

"But agricultural companies and commodity groups don’t have financial incentives tied to oats because oats don’t require hybrid seeds, crop insurance or as much fertilizer. These big players aren’t opposing oats, but they aren’t cheerleading either."

And a follow-up: if we admit Illinois agriculture is increasingly a fuel-production industry, can we end the agricultural exceptionalism? The exemptions from pollution rules? The sweetheart tax rates? Time to treat ag like other fuel-production industries.

Robert Hirschfeld@rfhirschfeld.bsky.social

Our leaders have no vision for the rural Midwest beyond turning it into a sacrifice zone for corn and soybean interests.

Robert Hirschfeld reposted

So many "always has been" meme possibilities here. Extractive systems such as US ag do quite well what they are designed to do - from their inception.

Robert Hirschfeld@rfhirschfeld.bsky.social

Our leaders have no vision for the rural Midwest beyond turning it into a sacrifice zone for corn and soybean interests.

Our leaders have no vision for the rural Midwest beyond turning it into a sacrifice zone for corn and soybean interests.

Governor JB Pritzker@govpritzker.illinois.gov

Illinois has all the pieces to be a world-class hub for biofuels. We’re the nation’s #1 soybean producer, #2 corn producer, and responsible for 90% of US oilseed production. Alongside our manufacturing ecosystem, busiest aviation hubs in the world, and a growing workforce.

Illinois Corn Growers: Our business model is entirely dependent on exporting our low-margin, undifferentiated commodities into a brutally competitive global market and asking the public to pay for the runoff and regular bailouts!

Robert Hirschfeld reposted

Replying to @rfhirschfeld.bsky.social

327 threatened or endangered species. USDA's own analysis says repeal of the Roadless Rule is "likely to adversely affect" 327 threatened/endangered species across the county. In the Shawnee, that includes the Indiana bat and timber snake.

Robert Hirschfeld reposted

Replying to @rfhirschfeld.bsky.social

Illinois was once 40% forest. Today it's about 14%, and what's left is fragmented. The Shawnee's six roadless areas (Bay Creek, Burden Falls, Burke Branch, Clear Springs, Eagle Creek, Ripple Hollow) are among the few intact tracts left.

Robert Hirschfeld reposted

There are precious few wild places left in Illinois. We should zealously protect those that remain. Instead, USDA wants to repeal the Roadless Rule, putting 10,666 acres of the Shawnee National Forest at risk. 🧵 gift link to the @chicagotribune.com:

chicagotribune.comTrump plan would remove protections for national forests like Shawnee: ‘We stand to lose our solitude’More than 170,000 acres in the Midwest could be opened to roads, logging and mining, threatening fragile ecosystems.

I can’t even bring myself to utter my dirtbag husband’s name, but I’m urging you to vote for him because “team.”

David@davidslosttt.bsky.social

Angela Paxton out with the weirdest ad of the cycle. This feels like an example of consultants somehow not knowing what the Streisand effect is despite working in politics

There are precious few wild places left in Illinois. We should zealously protect those that remain. Instead, USDA wants to repeal the Roadless Rule, putting 10,666 acres of the Shawnee National Forest at risk. 🧵 gift link to the @chicagotribune.com:

chicagotribune.comTrump plan would remove protections for national forests like Shawnee: ‘We stand to lose our solitude’More than 170,000 acres in the Midwest could be opened to roads, logging and mining, threatening fragile ecosystems.
View full thread

The feds keep cutting Forest Service staff and funding, and the agency already can't keep up with the roads it has. Its road maintenance backlog tops $9B. The roads mean access for logging and mining. Selling off the public's birthright to private extractive industry.

There are precious few wild places left in Illinois. We should zealously protect those that remain. Instead, USDA wants to repeal the Roadless Rule, putting 10,666 acres of the Shawnee National Forest at risk. 🧵 gift link to the @chicagotribune.com:

chicagotribune.comTrump plan would remove protections for national forests like Shawnee: ‘We stand to lose our solitude’More than 170,000 acres in the Midwest could be opened to roads, logging and mining, threatening fragile ecosystems.
View full thread

327 threatened or endangered species. USDA's own analysis says repeal of the Roadless Rule is "likely to adversely affect" 327 threatened/endangered species across the county. In the Shawnee, that includes the Indiana bat and timber snake.

And the economics don't add up. USDA estimates up to $11M in new timber revenue, but $9M/year in lost recreation and up to $6M more in lost business & wildlife recreation value. It's a money loser. So why do it, unless it's a corrupt giveaway to mining & logging interests?

There are precious few wild places left in Illinois. We should zealously protect those that remain. Instead, USDA wants to repeal the Roadless Rule, putting 10,666 acres of the Shawnee National Forest at risk. 🧵 gift link to the @chicagotribune.com:

chicagotribune.comTrump plan would remove protections for national forests like Shawnee: ‘We stand to lose our solitude’More than 170,000 acres in the Midwest could be opened to roads, logging and mining, threatening fragile ecosystems.

Illinois was once 40% forest. Today it's about 14%, and what's left is fragmented. The Shawnee's six roadless areas (Bay Creek, Burden Falls, Burke Branch, Clear Springs, Eagle Creek, Ripple Hollow) are among the few intact tracts left.

Streamgages that have been collecting data since the 40s and 50s are being shut down in Illinois. If we're having trouble finding funding to monitor pollution in our waterways, here's my suggestion: The industry responsible for that pollution should pay for it.

news-gazette.comMy Turn | Illinois needs more water monitoring, not less"Time is of the essence. The streamgages will be turned off Thursday, but we should have several more weeks before they will be removed entirely. Once the gauges are pulled

Data center water issues aren't "fake." They are situational. And perhaps just as important, if the data-center-water discourse shines a spotlight on other, even more water-intensive industries and Illinois' lack of tools to manage water use generally, that's a good thing.

Chicago Reader@chicagoreader.com

Two massive data centers are eyeing drinking water from Lake Michigan. Advocates and experts are unsure if that's the best way forward. https://bit.ly/4itMeVt

Robert Hirschfeld reposted

Robert Hirschfeld reposted

Robert Hirschfeld reposted

Replying to @rfhirschfeld.bsky.social

We speak for the rivers! In this case, the Illinois river—which was receiving discharges from the Alto Pekin ethanol plant (formerly Pacific Ethanol) that were up to 40 degrees hotter than its permit allowed. So Prairie Rivers Network and @sierraclub.org served notice of intent to sue.

We speak for the rivers! In this case, the Illinois river—which was receiving discharges from the Alto Pekin ethanol plant (formerly Pacific Ethanol) that were up to 40 degrees hotter than its permit allowed. So Prairie Rivers Network and @sierraclub.org served notice of intent to sue.

Robert Hirschfeld reposted