Post

We've analysed this video of the shooting of Renee Nicole Good yesterday in Minneapolis frame-by-frame to highlight the positioning of the gun and phone in the ICE agent's hands. Video: @minnesotareformer.com with annotations by Bellingcat

45 seconds after the shooting, in the same video, the camera app appears to be visible on the agent’s phone as he walks away from Good’s vehicle.

A member of our Discord first spotted this detail which was then explored further by @godin.bsky.social. Discussion continues within the Server, which you can join via this link: discord.com/invite/belli...

We’ve also updated our animated map of the positions of agents and vehicles during the incident here with new footage published by @cnn.com that shows the shooter closer to a white SUV prior to the shooting bsky.app/profile/bell...

Deliberate. A report by experts studied incidents from Jan 2010 to Oct 2012 and found US Border Patrol agents stepped in front of vehicles 67 times to justify shooting drivers. Results were 19 deaths. Jonathan Ross worked for US Border Patrol from 2005 until 2015. www.latimes.com/nation/la-na...

Omg... so could this be pre- meditated murder..

The bitch shouldn’t have hit the gas. She played stupid games and won stupid prizes.

Wrong: bsky.app/profile/bell...

shooter walked around the entire vehicle Not even sure but looks like passenger simultaneously getting into the vehicle so once victim shot did the victim even mean to drive forward since her wheel was already turned or was it her injury that caused the vehicle to move forward..?

Yes.This. Looks like her feet must have mixed up pedals because she would have intended to brake to let her wife in.

She wasn’t really looking at or aware of her wife though, her attention was focused on the ICE goons demanding she get out of the car and grabbing for her door handle. I think she just instinctively tried to get away from them in a panic.

Here is some post-shooting video taken by someone who lives on the street. I can' remember what social media thread I got it from here on BSKY. You can see her wife dealing with her trauma and their pet dog.

This is devastating

And the POTUS and his officials have responded with some Alex Jones’s level of denial of reality. They are beyond despicable.

Their like our health insurance companies -- Deny, Deny, Deny

Any thoughts on how Alpha New got this video?

And was so afraid that he never even dropped his phone....not even when he called her a fucking bitch after shooting her. Wow.

Riiiiiight when he sees the truck pull up and come to a stop is when he switches the camera from his right hand, to his left. He's anticipating them stopping the vehicle and forcibly removing her from it, whereas *he* is preparing himself to pull his gun if anything happens. And something did.

Note: It's right around the ~30 second mark. And correct me if I'm wrong, but does he....hock and spit, right before pulling his gun and firing?

That audio is from one of the other clips, it's not the shooter.

Stipulating this up front: Nicole Good should never have been shot. there is 0 justification for Jonathan Ross' actions, he should be prosecuted. - that said, if Good's wife hadn't been outside of the vehicle escalating the situation - 'You want to come at us? - Nicole may well be alive today.

So many people come before that in responsibility for this murder, though. Ross, Noem, Trump, every Republican Congressman, every Republican voter - all carry more weight in this than one woman calling out some untrained bounty hunter for acting like a jerk. We’re allowed to talk w/o being shot.

I agree with you of course: yes, 'we are allowed to talk without being shot'. thank you for your reply. - my point was that......the one who talked wasn't the one who directly bore the consequences of her talking. gd sad all around and should never have happened.

I went over this a bunch of times and I’m now pretty sure the shooter skidded back because of gun recoil, not contact with the vehicle. Also he was drawing his weapon before the vehicle began moving forward.

Some might be confused by the chaotic camera movements right before the shooting. But that’s because the ICE shooter pulled out his gun and started focusing on his gun hand. And I believe he used his left hand, still holding the phone, for support, with the phone camera briefly …

… obscured by his right hand/arm at 41.14.

x.com/zhihuachen/s...

Deliberate. A report by experts studied incidents from Jan 2010 to Oct 2012 and found US Border Patrol agents stepped in front of vehicles 67 times to justify shooting drivers. Results were 19 deaths. Jonathan Ross worked for US Border Patrol from 2005 until 2015. www.latimes.com/nation/la-na...

That's true. The officer has an obligation NOT to create the jeopardy that is then used to justify the "I feared for my life" shooting. Stepping in front of a running vehicle flies in the face of this requirement. The Supreme Court decided a case back in May on "Officer-created Jeopardy"

1/2 BBC’s Today programme’s item on Good’s murder just after 7am this morning was a muddy mess. Supposedly about clarification it: Interviewed a WaPo (Bezos-owned) journalist Mentioned Good steering to the right, but not that this was AWAY from Ross (the shooter) … continued …

What has been the argument by this completely deranged senator or congressman? "He couldnt see in which direction the wheel have been pointing" The movement of the steering wheel has been clearly visible. He knew exactly in which direction she wanted to drive.

@down.blue

cant find it on ur website could u pls make this vid available outsie social media 4 the non social media user

All of it is on Bellingcat.com now.

So the victim tells her murderer she’s not mad at him for being an asshole. In turn he kills her for no reason other than he is asshole. An untrained wanna be cop asshole

He was a 10 year veteran. He had training. He was doing what his bosses wanted. Calling him 'untrained is giving them all an excuse.

He had plenty of opportunity for training. This was an untrainABLE individual who should have been assigned a desk job.

and then after shooting her in the face three times, causing her car to accelerate down the road into another car and a pole, he calls her a "fucking bitch" (also he was reportedly quite trained)

Really appreciate your very detailed analysis. Some reports claim Good was blocking traffic but the position of the vehicle in front of her indicates otherwise. Question, is that the shooter's vehicle? The same one he fled in from the scene? @bellingcat.com

Ross got out of the white vehicle (after somehow🙄 passing around her "blocking-traffic" car), circled her car recording with his rt hand, starts circling again, switches phone to lft hand as he heads in front of her car again, pulls gun with now free rt hand, shoots, kills. Left in a silver van.

I went back & reviewed everything I could find. Ross arrived alone exiting from a Champagne Silver Chevy Tahoe that he had positioned in front of Good. Afterwards, he returned to this vehicle, turned it around and left scene. Image 1 - JR own video Image 2 - JR at left returns Image 3 - JR flees

Something was edited on his video...you dont hear or see g u n s h o t s

Your version cuts out the part where Ross say, "Fucking bitch," after he fires.