Post

Free newsletter: The AI industry is lying to you about progress. Only 5GW of data centers are under construction, it takes 6 months to bring online a single quarter's worth of NVIDIA GPU sales, and LLM code is actively breaking big tech. www.wheresyoured.at/the-ai-industry-is-lying-to-you/

wheresyoured.atThe AI Industry Is Lying To YouHi! If you like this piece and want to support my independent reporting and analysis, why not subscribe to my premium newsletter? It’s $70 a year, or $7 a month, and in return you get a weekly newslet...

404 reposts1.3K likes

"Here’s what’s actually happening: data center deals are being funded by eager private credit gargoyles that don’t know shit about fuck." Dare anyone say the art of writing is dead? I'm a fan, I can't lie.

Great article and thanks. The canarys in the coal mine for AI collapse will be NVIDIA, AMD, Intel, etc. sales slowing/stock price slipping and construction companies getting stiffed.

Re-upping my prediction that as we speak there are flavors of corruption and insanity going on in the AI companies, and the big hyperscalers, all driven by this AI hype cycle, and that make Wolf of Wall Street look sane by comparison. If our economy survives, the Netflix movies will be fucking LIT

Is there any advances in the LLM or agentic models worth noting recently? There is word that some of the paid models can now do "economically useful work", including from people I trust not to BS on the matter.

Most of the studies I've seen are mixed, but they're from last year. Purportedly Claude Code got "really good" 3 months ago and is doing things it couldn't previously. But this happens every time Claude is updated. Regardless, all performance gains this cycle are coming from more spending.

So even if models are better they're subsidized and no one is paying true costs. Improving models further will require yet more money. I've seen a lot of people say LLMs are going to be a commodity. Don't really see how the economics work, then unless training runs stop.

I will say that "This update will fix it" logic was first "Beta Tested", shall we say, in the games industry. I've seen so many buggy game releases where "The next update will fix it!" was used to silence criticism. Problem is there are games that updates fixed, which is why it stuck around.

I’m not sure you’re wrong on the capacity utilization fairy tale, but it seems like a big assumption that Nvidia’s US sourced revenue is going only to US buildouts, rather than US HQ’d cos buying their global capacity?

NGL it feels like we’re all just sitting around with the popcorn waiting to see what happens when the money runs out and/or the market gets bored, because there is nothing we can do about it except watch the proceedings that will inevitably crash our entire lives. Again.

This is really good, and it lines up some puzzle pieces that I think fit together very neatly: (1) datacenter announcements way (way) ahead of actual capacity; (2) an oversupply of GPUs sold by Nvidia but not powered up; and (3) Nvidia GPUs leaking out of the U.S. into China.

There's a synergy between (1) and (2), where I don't actually know which comes first. As in, I think the companies who've bought too many GPUs might be over-eager to announce undercooked data center plans, to justify the inventory.

Oh I think they're all linked, that's why I call them puzzle pieces fitting together, with (1) and (2) I just think it's interesting that either one could be the horse or the cart.

That is definitely one possible explanation, but they *keep buying* the GPUs, and most of the data centers aren't actually bought, just planned. Alternate explanations include (1) calculated stock price manipulation, and (2) simply not understanding the slow pace of construction at this scale.

And a more specific variation of (1): they're doing what it takes to book those juicy commitments from OpenAI for compute, but knowingly dragging their feet on the actual build-out, because they doubt whether OpenAI will actually be good for it.

Hey Ed, if you had to pick a handful of easily-understandable stuff to convince a dummy not to tank their business with AI, what would you choose?

Could tell them to make their marketing videos with Sora. Last week. This week, not so much. bsky.app/profile/rj-p...

RJ Palmer@rj-palmer.com

This is the really big news here imo, its not just the sora app thats gone but chatgpt wont be doing videos either. This is a massive hit to openAI. Hopefully this hit causes internal bleeding that kills them as painfully as possible.

There's an accounting fraud where a distributor is incentivized to take delivery of product they knowingly can't sell so that the producer can fake increased sales. Aka, channel stuffing. It could be temporary, product could get returned next quarter, or it could get diverted to black/grey market.

Yup. Servers that I was running 15 years ago in a rack on-prem were super efficient for the time but still pulled like 400 watts each. Now a freaking mini-PC can out perform those beasts while pulling 20 watts. Combine that with virtualization and data centers had a lot of extra capacity in power.

This is such a boon for business idiots and ambitious jerks. While the tooling can be helpful to a certain degree, I feel it is also causing me literal brain damage.

Yeah I’m one of those designers you mention ( I do actually know FE closing at a decent level) and can confirm we’re being expected to design by prompt code to be pushed into production. Welcome to the suck.

This is exactly where things feel off — not speed or scale, but trust in what’s being produced. That’s the layer we’re focused on with Veracity: making every claim traceable back to a real source, so you don’t have to take AI at its word.

Wonder if this would work to help head off data center construction as well... bsky.app/profile/proj...

Project Salt Box@projectsaltbox.com

Maryland sued to stop an ICE detention warehouse. Then New Jersey. Then Michigan. Each case cites the same fifty-year-old environmental law — and a federal judge has already frozen construction in Maryland using it. Arizona's warehouse went through the same process. Arizona hasn't filed anything.

This is absolutely perfect: "Do you actually want to know stuff, or just have the ability to call up information when necessary?" Also, "Silicon Valley Hapsburgs" is a little niche, but also as good a description as there is.