Hendrik Erz, PhD reposted
+++ NEW ARTICLE +++ Gary King is Wrong About Peer-Review — But Not the Way You Think www.hendrik-erz.de/post/gary-ki...
Hendrik Erz, PhD
@hendrik-erz.de
Political Sociologist, studying discursive dynamics and democratic lawmaking. Program Chair MetaCRiSP 2026 (IEEE S&P) Website: https://hendrik-erz.de I develop @zettlr.com, a free academic writing app.
1.4K followers615 following1.2K posts
Hendrik Erz, PhD reposted
+++ NEW ARTICLE +++ Gary King is Wrong About Peer-Review — But Not the Way You Think www.hendrik-erz.de/post/gary-ki...
+++ NEW ARTICLE +++ Gary King is Wrong About Peer-Review — But Not the Way You Think www.hendrik-erz.de/post/gary-ki...
Current polls for the German federal elections. I think today's a good reminder that right-wing politics tend to be sticky. Cases in point: Poland, Hungary, Serbia, Brazil, Argentina, U.S., …
Sonntagsfrage zur Bundestagswahl • INSA/BILD: AfD 29,5 % | CDU/CSU 19 % | SPD 14 % | GRÜNE 14 % | DIE LINKE 10 % | FDP 5 % | BSW 3 % | Sonstige 5,5 % ➤ Übersicht: wahlrecht.de/umfragen/ ➤ Verlauf: wahlrecht.de/umfragen/ins...
Critical Security Update for Zettlr. (+ fixes a big annoyance)
+++ NEW RELEASE +++ We are pleased to announce Zettlr 4.9.0. Two crucial changes: 1. No more annoying "Update failed" errors! 2. Updates Electron, so drops support for old macOS and Ubuntu, but also fixes a critical security vulnerability. Update highly recommended! github.com/Zettlr/Zettl...
Hendrik Erz, PhD reposted
Don’t have time to check the appendix yesterday, but I already suspected something like this. In short, my suspicion that they just had the most favorable data and measurements they could have gains more evidence.
I dug into the methods and appendix, and hoo boy is that title "AI Article Reviews Dominate Human Peer Reviews at Their Best" deceptively broad. The overwhelming number of submissions were quantitative and statistical, only 9 were formal mathematical, and 11 were qualitative.
Also CC @pengzell.bsky.social — I think this fits into your experience that LLMs are pretty bad at more complex things, which we talked about yesterday
Hendrik Erz, PhD reposted
This (excellent point) is even worse bc of the set-up that looks at a scenario where both peer reviewers & AIs don't _evaluate_ the paper but seek to improve it. I.e. it's measuring not peer review but peer feedback. And for that, editors' assessment is even less meaningful.
A serious weakness in this paper by King and Worthington: The judges for the AI peer reviews are *not* experts in the field. They are former journal editors but no claim is made to substantive expertise in the reviewed papers. AI-generated reviews sound good *if you don't know the substance well.*
Hendrik Erz, PhD reposted
Hendrik Erz, PhD reposted
I have worked for the German center for federal political education for two years as a student, and believe it is of utmost importance. However, formally under the interior ministry, they have been forced to engage with alleged “left wing extremism”. It’s a shame to see it go down like that.
Modellprojekte für 2027 und 2028 gesucht! Bis zum 15. November können Sie Ihre Idee zu den Themen linke Gewalt, linke Radikalisierung und linkem Extremismus einreichen. Weitere Infos zur Bewerbung finden Sie unter www.bpb.de/581542
The paper itself looks fine tbh. I’m not even mad; they have an ethics statement and addressed critique. The question is not whether AI is good in reviewing (it is, from my experience). The question is rather: (a) whom do we write for? And (b) do *I* want to encourage authors sending me AI papers?
I'm sorry, but I'll call it: King has jumped the shark
The paper itself looks fine tbh. I’m not even mad; they have an ethics statement and addressed critique. The question is not whether AI is good in reviewing (it is, from my experience). The question is rather: (a) whom do we write for? And (b) do *I* want to encourage authors sending me AI papers?
I'm sorry, but I'll call it: King has jumped the shark
Recommended read on why we should not blindly trust “AI detectors,” a point I have been making for years and will continue to make, but @emilymbender.bsky.social is obviously much better at explaining why that is.
Some words on how to evaluate language technologies (and caution against using them to undermine others' work) buttondown.com/maiht3k/arch...
+++ NEW ARTICLE +++ What yesterday's security vulnerability can teach us about Granovetter's threshold models. www.hendrik-erz.de/post/php2she...
An amazing must read on the open source that drives the world. Great interactive article.
The people holding up the internet Paul Eggert, tzd Lasse Collin, xz Denis Pushkarev,core-js Todd Miller, sudo DRC, libjpeg-turbo D. Richard Hipp et al., SQLite Mark Adler, zlib Chet Ramey, bash Behdad Esfahbod, HarfBuzz Daniel Stenberg, curl Daniel G. Moreno, libxml2 sheets.works/data-viz/hol...
How about the EU finally uses those frozen Russian assets to send aid to Ukraine…? Absolutely nothing of this is surprising, but seeing it written in this sharp analysis is devastating. (Gift link) www.nytimes.com/2026/10/22/w...
Hendrik Erz, PhD reposted
Had a chat with a Finnish colleague on Monday who said that, in the past, the Finnish army often just trained for attacks “from the east” but never mentioned Russia specifically until recently. Seems like the same will happen in GER as well soon.
Bundeswehr warnt vor russischen Anschlägen #Bundeswehr #Russland
Hendrik Erz, PhD reposted
Hallå Helsingfors! This week I’ll be spending time at the university of Helsinki to work on CSS teaching in an age of Gen AI, together with @matnel.bsky.social — and of course take one or another stroll to discover the city!
Selbes pattern wie in den USA, wo die Republikaner schon vor langer Zeit angefangen haben, liberale erfolgreiche Konkurrenten diskursiv unwählbar zu reden. Konservatismus ist sowohl eine Ideologie, als auch eine Selbstbeschreibung, und beides muss nicht zusammen gehen.
Es ist schon ein bisschen ulkig, dass die Union offenbar zu verdrängen versucht, dass es in Deutschland schon Ministerpräsidenten der Linkspartei gab und diverse Regierungsbeteiligungen der Partei gab und gibt. Und es ist absurd, dass sie mit ihrem Narrativ gerade so einfach durch kommt.
Selbes pattern wie in den USA, wo die Republikaner schon vor langer Zeit angefangen haben, liberale erfolgreiche Konkurrenten diskursiv unwählbar zu reden. Konservatismus ist sowohl eine Ideologie, als auch eine Selbstbeschreibung, und beides muss nicht zusammen gehen.
Es ist schon ein bisschen ulkig, dass die Union offenbar zu verdrängen versucht, dass es in Deutschland schon Ministerpräsidenten der Linkspartei gab und diverse Regierungsbeteiligungen der Partei gab und gibt. Und es ist absurd, dass sie mit ihrem Narrativ gerade so einfach durch kommt.
Hendrik Erz, PhD reposted
no kings includes billionaires who think they’re kings
Meta took down the No Kings instagram; TikTok banned the Musk documentary account for supposedly violating its political posting policies. A reminder that platforms are owned by the wealthiest of people, control the means of media distribution, & put their thumbs on the democracy scale as they wish
Hendrik Erz, PhD reposted