Post

Candidates from *both* parties are calling for the federal and/or state gas taxes to be suspended, which makes sense from an election POV but seems like a TERRIBLE idea from a fiscal/budgetary (and also environmental) POV. Even if you support doing so, when exactly would they be reinstated?

23 reposts108 likes

If you leave it open-ended, you give Republicans a MASSIVE in-kind donation for 2028, since Dems would be put on the spot to "vote for a huge tax hike on the middle class" etc etc even if they're just restoring to to where it is now. If you put a hard deadline on it...when would that be, exactly?

For that matter, it wouldn't do much good in most states anyway. The federal gas tax is 18.3¢/gallon. The average price of regular gas has gone up $1.50 since Trump decided to invade Iran for no particular reason, and could go up another $0.50 or more by Election Day.

There are 32 states where the gas tax is $0.33 or less, so suspending BOTH the federal AND state gas taxes *completely* would only cancel out about 1/3 of the price hike to date, and only 1/4 of what it's likely to go up to by Election Day... ...while wiping out all of the road maintenance revenue.

The state of Washington has suffered enough from stupid initiatives to starve the state of revenue, to the point where some offices can't even be staffed for basic services like driver's licenses. Tax cuts are an emotional sugar high that leads to crashes and more problems for Dems to clean up.

Plus, as several folks have noted, there's no way of forcing the gas companies to pass the savings along to the customers anyway! So you could end up wiping out billions of dollars in federal *and* state revenue without reducing the price of gas one cent (they'd probably drop prices *somewhat*).

Look how Mamdani is making it sexy. He's out there showing how government and tax dollars serves every day people. The work is already being done. It's probably low hanging fruit to go out and show people a lot of the little things that improve their daily lives.

Rs know if Dems don't vote for suspending the gas tax now, they'll catch hell. And, as you say, if Dems try to reinstate the tax, they'll still catch hell.

The R candidate for MA gov is pushing that now but not saying that MA is lower than 31 other states, and that roads and bridges and intersections are funded by the gas tax. Btw the guy is a multi millionaire who gave $15m to his primary campaign and has given Trump >$1m