Post

The switch from the age of confronting an empty browser search box - which forced you to identify your own desires - to the age of auto-playing content social media platforms has harmed our psyches: discuss.

Social media that simply serves up Whatever the Algorithim Wants in automatic play-mode is a parasite upon human attention, degrading our own ability to identify what we even actually WANT at any given time: discuss?

22 reposts184 likes

Absolutely. How many times have you opened your phone/tablet/computer to do something and got drawn into a social media feed that made you forget what you meant to do in the first place?

I think this is a different problem. You go to an app you don't actually need for whatever it is, you're only going to look at it for a minute, then whoops it's 20 min later & you forgot the original thing. This isn't because you didn't know what you wanted but because the feed was more appealing.

The problem I think Faine is identifying is, like, you want to listen to music, you open up Apple Music, which isn't the wrong app for your goal, and then you're just staring at it going "what *do* I want to listen to?" because you're out of practice at picking what gets played to you.

Part of it is that people often have aspirational preferences that don't always match their revealed preferences. Until recently, resisting the temptation to indulge the latter so one could focus on the former was a sign of virtue and discipline. Now it's "proof" people can't be trusted to choose.

Agreed - and also insulting I severely dislike the banal assumptions on which the rec algos run - life as seen thru marketing focus groups and never accurate

So actually yes, we have studies showing that eg you can clicker train yourself even though you are fully aware of what you're doing. Eating a piece of a favorite candy after completing a task (or a step of it) makes you more likely to do the task in the future even though you know what's going on.

i feel like this too contributes to the erosion of hobbies as well. why discover something that you have a genuine interest in and can build skills in when the algo is designed to placate that as much as possible