Post

So I'm more positive on AI than a lot of people here and... I do not understand using this example at all? This... does not seem like a useful way to use AI. I can easily come up with 3 words to describe my kids and would never trust AI to do so accurately.

David Gura@davidgura.bsky.social

cool, cool

19 reposts275 likes

It's a commercial Mayer is perfectly capable of doing this "impossible task" Here, she's just selling a product She's "on top of the world" and with enough money that her grandkids won't spend it all, and yet "inept enough" to need handholding of a program that regurgitates the text made when

"the most probable character follows some other also most probable character" with probabilities drawn from some slice of the world's knowledge that its makers had managed to buy or steal Whoever takes the image portrayed here seriously ..... I mean, c'mon, seriously?!

It's not a good commercial. If the tool did something most people would actually find useful, that's what you lead with.

There's so much money sloshing in the "AI" arena, no one is checking the quality of anything, commercials, events, conferences, whatever They are throwing everything against the wall and hoping for something to stick, this time it was Marissa

By now they've exhausted all good ideas so the future can get only more ridiculous I'm half expecting them to try summoning the Dark Lord (no bad ideas in a brainstorm and all that)

using ai to describe your kids is a weird way to say you've outsourced your own personality. if you can't distill three traits yourself, you're not using a tool, you're just letting the tool think for you.

I'm sure you've spent quality time with your kids. Between this and the guy who couldn't be bothered reading to his child, it's clear that they see raising their kids as a task to be assigned to others or now, to ai. I wonder if they see relationships with anyone as important in their own right.

I have built my own. Which generally reminds me what's on my calendar, alerts me to important emails I missed, and sometimes alerts me to news I'm interested in. All of those I find helpful.

Sometimes, the hardest decisions are because the choices are so similar or the choice does not really matter. This seems like the latter.

I don't have kids but I also found this kind of jaw dropping. Not only the "would it meaningful do this task" angle but also from WHY WOULD YOU EVEN ASK IT THAT WHAT KIND OF PARENT ARE YOU ASDFLKJSDALFK

Even setting aside the “what kind of parent couldn’t do this for their child” aspect, saying this out loud to the press so that your daughter finds out about it… holy shit, like, when the kid tells her therapist about reading this a lot is going to click into place

I remember getting really stuck on homework problems as a kid, just really getting fucked up by my own brain on simple questions. So maybe I could see using AI to talk you through a visualization exercise or something to get past a block, but this is just sad.

Also, "oh no I can't pick only three" is so ridiculous. Send in six. You think they're gonna fail your ten year old? Give her detention? HTF were you a CEO if you can't brainstorm some shit and narrow it down to 3? How'd you make ANY decisions?

honestly it's just a damning indictment of how out of touch these people are more than any commentary on AI.

Kind of funny that you don't recognize how people get sucked into outsourcing basic thinking. They are *not* asking 'is this a useful way to use AI'! It's a big problem.

It’s wild to me she thought this was a difficult question like you can’t think of three things you like about your kid?