Post

Growing up with the phrase “Wikipedia isn’t a valid source,” only to end up in a daily life where everyone says, “Just ask ChatGPT.”

862 reposts2.5K likes

Yes, I was told 'Wikipedia isn't a valid source' immediately followed by '... but it's a great place to start'. They provide the high-level summary and then dive into the references.

Also, for some topics, Wikipedia provides absolutely the real deal, and you don't need to go elsewhere: I'm thinking of shorter proofs of theorems in Mathematics or Theoretical Physics. If you read, follow and digest a Wikipedia proof of Pythagoras's Theorem, for example, it's as good as a textbook.

AI is fine to get a quick overview of something you already know .. on all other tasks it may be a helping hand, but i also might be useless if you cant verify for possible errors or if you take everything for real ..

I warn my students off of most things. They ask where they should get their information. I point them to actual dictionaries, encyclopedias, and news sources. They ask for links. I give them and they ask what makes them different. “It’s you checking real information, not an algorithm.” A struggle.

The worst part about the former narrative is that it caused my old school district to straight up block Wikipedia on all the computers meaning I had to go to different, generally worse sites for general knowledge (not even for like research for school or anything)

TBF As a teacher, I did not accept Wikipedia references for many years, but as it gained solidity, I would take it as one of several references required. I would NEVER take ChatGPT because as it gains more knowledge, I believe it will widen what it says to the point of nonesense.

its worse than that. Most people dont click the link to where the informatino is from on google ai. If you ask google a question you really should learn where the answer comes from because often its extremely obscure.

and sometimes they ask a question, Google's ai summary says "yes" in a paragraph and lists 3 points that explain why not, and the source where it's apparently from... and the person shows it saying "you see, internet says yes"

I grew up whith the phrase: "You dont need any typewriter, we do all the writing for you." That was in the 1980ies, in the leninist authoritarian East Germany. It did not end well for those who did all the writing... Lets see how it ends for those who now do the filtering of whats written.