Eliminating the Impossible xkcd.com/3210/
459 reposts2.8K likes
Eliminating the Impossible xkcd.com/3210/
459 reposts2.8K likes
But this is a fallacy: when Holmes says "when you've eliminated the impossible" it entails actually eliminating the impossible, not that you might have. Doyle's syntactic construction doesn't allow for this "gotcha" because it doesn't follow from the first condition, the impossible being eliminated.
Title text: "'If you've eliminated a few possibilities and you can't think of any others, your weird theory is proven right' isn't quite as rhetorically compelling." Alt text: https://explainxkcd.com/3210#Transcript