Post

I actually keep having the problem where I think "I absolutely brought my thing in from the car, I *remember* bringing it in, where did I put it down???" And then it's always in the car, and I gotta get my shoes on, and go into the garage, and it's a whole thing...

Remember also that Sherlock Holmes was incredibly thorough. It's far less likely that he would have overlooked something, compared to today's pseudo scientists who try to persuade the general population that their non sense idea must be correct.

Can’t pass up an opportunity for a Discworld quote: “It wasn't by eliminating the impossible that you got at the truth, however improbable; it was by the much harder process of eliminating the possibilities.”

Also: “Once you’ve ruled out the impossible, then whatever is left, however improbable, must be the truth. The problem lay in working out what was impossible, of course. That was the trick, alright.”

The fact that you might not consider every remaining possibility doesn’t make Holmes’s adage wrong. “The keys are in the car, or they’re somewhere I overlooked them, or they’re somewhere I haven’t thought to look yet” is a true statement.

As an odd and curious child, I read Freud's "Psychopatholgy of Everyday Life" in which he described the very common human mental trick of hiding things from ourselves. I can't say it helped, though; I still do this regularly.

Once you eliminate all the scenarios the author thought of you are left with only the remaining scenarios the author thought of.

But this is a fallacy: when Holmes says "when you've eliminated the impossible" it entails actually eliminating the impossible, not that you might have. Doyle's syntactic construction doesn't allow for this "gotcha" because it doesn't follow from the first condition, the impossible being eliminated.

If i gould tag my dad.. Couldnt find the meme i was looking for. So ..spice girls! I guess i could email it from the main website.... No the emails have the alt under the img. I will send the email 🤓

If you haven’t eliminated all possibilites or you’ve overlooked one, then you’re technically still on step one of the rule. It’s not Sherlock’s fault you’re not thorough.