Ben Schmidt

Ben Schmidt

@bschmidt.bsky.social

CTO, Nomic. former history professor/digital humanist. https://benschmidt.org

7K followers846 following1.7K posts

OK but business school professors are not exactly central to what the institutions do; if the guy who sells peanuts at Fenway says it’s time to stop playing baseball, would we listen? Let’s hear from the person who books the class ski trip to Vail before we throw the baby out with the bathwater.

This post is unavailable.

I had forgotten about this Jack Handey joke but it is obviously the germ from which the GLOAT (Greatest Lede of All Time) evolved.

This post is unavailable.

Copyright strikes again. Went to check this 2019 kickstarter to digitally fix The Departed bc: "the movie has one giant glaring flaw. In the last shot, Scorsese has an actual rat crawl across the screen. The rat symbolizes rats." We can't have nice things, chapter 237.

Doing my dissertation one of the big early questions was “what happened to the internal CBS archives?” Somewhere in the paramount/Sony/etc flow they just vanished. Corporations are terrible at preserving things. We rely on states and philanthropists:nonprofits to do that…

Unions tend to deposit their records at universities In a world where recent historical records have considerably greater economic value, I could see a case for legislation that more aggressively enshrines unions not unis as primary custodians of a variety of records in their industries…

Gerrymandering makes nicely named legislative districts harder. Makes me wonder—are there egregious examples of gerrymandering at the city ward level? Or do municipalities always have sane-looking wards?

Mark J. Nelson@mm-jj-nn.bsky.social

Buffalo's the most extensive version of this I know of, with 9 named council districts.

Wow Deutsche bank “apex of civilizational ambition oftentimes expressed in steel and fire” gives pat buchanan’s 1992 convention speech a run for its money as “better in the original German”

Carl Quintanilla@carlquintanilla.bsky.social

DEUTSCHE lays it on thick: “.. SpaceX represents in our view the apex of civilizational ambition, oftentimes expressed in steel and fire, bending the arc of history to make humans multiplanetary ..” $SPCX

"My favorite founding father is Thomas Paine" is an opinion roughly equivalent to "my favorite ice cream flavor is cocaine."

Bo Thompson@gaudipern.bsky.social

Thomas Paine is my favorite founding father. He was famously abolitionist and one of the earliest voices to point out the hypocrisy of fighting for independence while keeping slaves. He also firmly believed that keeping any friendship which required compromising your morals made you a bad person.

Ben Schmidt reposted

Saw that report on the supposed politicization of humanities & social science scholarship, ppl would be well served by reading John McCumber's account of what happened to US academic philosophy under McCarthyism, so much chimes w that today: nupress.northwestern.edu/978081014607...

nupress.northwestern.eduTime in the Ditch - Northwestern University PressIn Time in the Ditch, John McCumber explores the effects of McCarthyism on American philosophy in the 1940s and 1950 and the possibility that the political p...

Carl Sagan's books-as-seed metaphor shows what a milquetoast ninny he was compared to John Milton. "I know they are as lively, and as vigorously productive, as those fabulous dragon's teeth; and being sown up and down, may chance to spring up armed men."

Saganism@sagan.bsky.social

“Books are like seeds. They can lie dormant for centuries and then flower in the most unpromising soil.” — Carl Sagan

Ben Schmidt reposted

i’ve only seen one brief clip of Jonathan Haidt’s NYU commencement speech but it’s him saying purple is his favorite color and then immediately mispronouncing “2026”

Fresh torment nexus unlocked! 1. Job seeker spams a list of AI companies with resume/ llm-written cover letter. 2. The AI companies all have e-mail auto-reply bots that start responding to chain. 3. Classic reply-all e-mail chain with a twist: nobody on it cares that it keeps going!

Ben Schmidt reposted

Recently, FamilySearch digitized and uploaded tons of microfilmed records, including many from 18th-century Massachsuetts. They're using some sort of AI to transcribe/summarize the handwritten documents. I've noticed that the AI strips out references to race and enslavement in 18thc documents.

More garden of heroes reporting! Since last I indulged my obsession with this story, they've abandoned the idea this would be in North Dakota and moved it to Washington DC. Completely predictably it's over budget and behind schedule... www.nytimes.com/2026/05/02/u...

nytimes.comTrump’s Vision for ‘Garden of Heroes’ Keeps Getting Bigger and Higher in Cost
Ben Schmidt@bschmidt.bsky.social

This was reported a while ago, but still insane to see that this is what’s replacing federal humanities funding. Two logistical points. 1. Is $34m is enough for this? WwII memorial was $200m. 2. July 4 2026 is really soon. How have they not even picked a site?

View full thread

Oh wait John Lewis was already dead in 2020! It was just the Trump/Lewis feud I guess. But the diversity effort stops at black people -- 4 hispanics and 2 asians.

Definitely a pro-Catholic slant -- I couldn't have told you who Louise McManus, Nellie Gray, John Neumann, or Augustus Tolton, or John Carroll were.

More garden of heroes reporting! Since last I indulged my obsession with this story, they've abandoned the idea this would be in North Dakota and moved it to Washington DC. Completely predictably it's over budget and behind schedule... www.nytimes.com/2026/05/02/u...

nytimes.comTrump’s Vision for ‘Garden of Heroes’ Keeps Getting Bigger and Higher in Cost
Ben Schmidt@bschmidt.bsky.social

This was reported a while ago, but still insane to see that this is what’s replacing federal humanities funding. Two logistical points. 1. Is $34m is enough for this? WwII memorial was $200m. 2. July 4 2026 is really soon. How have they not even picked a site?

View full thread

The list of great americans remains utterly inscrutable -- not representative of the MAGA worldview or any other. Nobody's making them put Dorothy Day or Mohammed Ali on here: and although they whitewash DuBois, Rustin, Baldwin out of black history they strive to include lots of black names…

IIRC the list got thrown together in 2020 during the BLM protests in defense of statues-as-history, so it has five people who died in 2020, while not including anyone who died after. This means we somehow get Kobe Bryant but not Bill Russell, C.T. Vivian but not John Lewis. And of course, RBG.

More garden of heroes reporting! Since last I indulged my obsession with this story, they've abandoned the idea this would be in North Dakota and moved it to Washington DC. Completely predictably it's over budget and behind schedule... www.nytimes.com/2026/05/02/u...

nytimes.comTrump’s Vision for ‘Garden of Heroes’ Keeps Getting Bigger and Higher in Cost
Ben Schmidt@bschmidt.bsky.social

This was reported a while ago, but still insane to see that this is what’s replacing federal humanities funding. Two logistical points. 1. Is $34m is enough for this? WwII memorial was $200m. 2. July 4 2026 is really soon. How have they not even picked a site?

View full thread

OK, so -- the 250 years/250 heroes list has actually *increased* from 243 to 245 people over the last year. The two new honorees are the Marquis de Lafayette and Prince Estabrook.

More garden of heroes reporting! Since last I indulged my obsession with this story, they've abandoned the idea this would be in North Dakota and moved it to Washington DC. Completely predictably it's over budget and behind schedule... www.nytimes.com/2026/05/02/u...

nytimes.comTrump’s Vision for ‘Garden of Heroes’ Keeps Getting Bigger and Higher in Cost
Ben Schmidt@bschmidt.bsky.social

This was reported a while ago, but still insane to see that this is what’s replacing federal humanities funding. Two logistical points. 1. Is $34m is enough for this? WwII memorial was $200m. 2. July 4 2026 is really soon. How have they not even picked a site?

View full thread

Wait no Grover is still there! With a straight face they say he is the only non-consecutive term holder and Americans *really* like a non-consecutive term prez BTW the anti-Trump talking point on Cleveland needs to become "One of only two presidents to win the popular vote at least three times."

One extremely confusing thing is that their new list of bios has a 'grouping by category' at the top that doesn't actually include all the people on the list.

More garden of heroes reporting! Since last I indulged my obsession with this story, they've abandoned the idea this would be in North Dakota and moved it to Washington DC. Completely predictably it's over budget and behind schedule... www.nytimes.com/2026/05/02/u...

nytimes.comTrump’s Vision for ‘Garden of Heroes’ Keeps Getting Bigger and Higher in Cost
Ben Schmidt@bschmidt.bsky.social

This was reported a while ago, but still insane to see that this is what’s replacing federal humanities funding. Two logistical points. 1. Is $34m is enough for this? WwII memorial was $200m. 2. July 4 2026 is really soon. How have they not even picked a site?

This part is interesting -- AFAICT they removed some people! I checked my list of the most hilariously undeserving people from last year and while Alex Trebek is still there, Grover Cleveland seems to have been nixed... who else has been taken off the list?

Ben Schmidt reposted

Extremely funny that Bard’s trustees have called for “an orderly transition,” like Botstein has been deposed by a color revolution

Stephanie Kirchgaessner@skirchy.bsky.social

Botstein is stepping down after WilmerHale completes its review. Among other things it suggests Botstein was warned not to have dealings with Epstein www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026...

I’m struggling to remember what Richard Dawkins is actually famous for—at first I thought he was the racist guy who stole the double helix, but no, James Watson. The entomologist positivist? Nope EO Wilson. Now struggling with the idea the word “meme” somehow explains why I’m supposed to know him?

Matthew Sheffield@matthew.flux.community

In totally unsurprising news, Richard Dawkins is developing AI psychosis. Paywall bypass: archive.is/6RdK9

Ben Schmidt reposted

One of those "essays I'll write one day" is that a great many people forget that Du Bois really was a PhD economist in-all-but-title and thought with economist brain sometimes. The much discussed "psychic wage of whiteness" thesis from Black Reconstruction really just is classic economist reasoning.

Ben Schmidt reposted

Here's an important read for today: policymakers are encouraging students to learn trades that are costly to teach, but community colleges and apprenticeships don't have the capacity to meet demand. This sends students to the more expensive for-profit sector, where they take on debt.

wsj.comThey Chose Careers in the Trades and Still Wound Up With DebtAs community colleges and union apprenticeships fill up, more students are turning to pricier training options for blue-collar careers.

Godzilla vs Erin Brockovich

ponder@ponder.ooo

most people focus on the immediate & obvious dangers, but actually the worst aspect of godzilla romping thru a city tends to be the hazardous particulates that get kicked up into the air. way more people die of godzilla-related mesothelioma than get crushed, radiation-lasered, &c

Although you greenlight that movie *please* check how long it typically takes for godzilla-related mesothelioma to manifest; actuarily we should probably be more worried about years of potential life lost, not raw death counts.