Post

this particular line is maybe the best statement of purpose i have seen for those of us who want a more militant opposition to this administration

Liberal Currents@liberalcurrents.com

“Let us be clear: we want the power of the state. We wish to hold the criminals of the regime accountable. We wish to seize back the public funds looted by Trump and his cronies. We wish to undo the damage he has done to the government. More than any of that we wish to rebuild.”

1.2K reposts5K likes

Ok but leading off with a pre-Civil War example and then the Bolsheviks indicates she’s got not clue what an applicant “more militant” opposition would be…

Before the Civil War, the Republicans won control of the state and its security apparatus through an election The Bolsheviks tried violent resistance and it failed So actually she does have a clue: first you get the state, and not by violent insurrection. Then you use the state.

Adam Gurri@adamgurri.liberalcurrents.com

In the first place, because we've done that more than once www.liberalcurrents.com/how-to-win-a... www.liberalcurrents.com/we-can-organ... www.liberalcurrents.com/we-have-orga... And also looked at Douglass www.liberalcurrents.com/against-the-... www.liberalcurrents.com/neutralizing...

1. Republicans won control of the state because of the COLLAPSE OF THE SECOND PARTY SYSTEM followed by IMMEDIATE SECESSION OF SLAVE STATES. I mean, we could TRY to orchestrate a 4-person race where we win 39.7% of the PV, and then fight a whole war. Seems against what the writer had in mind 1/2

2. The Bolsheviks are an even worse touchstone. Not sure how to have a centuries old monarchy ready to collapse under widespread poverty/starvation, world war and incompetent leadership, but sure? Also, no elections, just whoever takes control? 2/2

The second party system collapsed because the northern voter base started to prioritize stopping the expansion of slavery above other concerns and voted accordingly I do think that conservative attempts to do a civil war when our side wins an election would greatly help our side

Oh I also wish to sue them all personally for their private wealth. Trump, Musk, McMahon, etc. Build an endowment for NSF, repay government workers, etc.

It does make me worry that the Democrats are making themselves vulnerable of a takeover not by the political left but by a militant center-right populist in 2028.

A critical number of Trump voters chose to not hear his explicit promise to impose a govt of certain people for certain people. They feel bad & want to atone. Promise those voters to restore a govt of all the people for all the people & they’ll gratefully contribute to the “by all the people” part.

“More than any of that we wish to rebuild.” Nope. Accountability first. Real punishment. We can’t rebuild until the rot had been excised from public life, and an example made for future lawbreakers. Delaying rebuilding until we have accountability is hard, but necessary.

If you read the article, it’s pretty clear that “rebuilding” refers to fixing the loopholes and counter-majoritarian mechanisms that allowed them to take power and putting safeguards in place to make a second attempt at fascism less likely to succeed.

rebuilding while cleaning up will at times be disconnected if not contradictory. both are necessary, but the pressure to “move on,” “look forward not backward,” and “not criminalize political differences” will be as strong as ever was when Obama and Biden were inaugurated.

That's why we need to elect a mixture of big ideas, forward-looking people, and out-for-blood prosecutorial type people. They need to give each other room and not interfere with each other's mission.

100%. It's infuriating that so many people are not getting the grand larceny committed by this regime. A friend asked "Where are they getting the money to fund ICE and buy Venezuela?" Ask the countries and NGOs robbed of USAID. Ask the people losing their healthcare/insurance. We have been robbed!

We need to tear down every single thing this administration has built, from the ballroom to the Kennedy Center to the Department of war, every single thing they've touched and out their name on has to be demolished and rebuilt immediately regardless of cost.

Trump’s entire message that led to his power was, “you’re mad at the system and I’m going to destroy it at whatever cost” So for some of us the retort message cannot be “let’s all just be friends again, ok”

I am grateful that you have a job as a NYT opinion columnist. I am grateful that you post so often (though it does'nt help my phone addiction.) I especially gratful for your links, this morning to

www.npr.org/2026/01/31/n... “In 1940’s, Norwegians made, RED POINTED HATS with a tassel as form of visual protest against NAZI occupation.‘Knitting is a great way to find community, great way of protest. I cannot sit by and watch really good people being torn apart by actions of the federal govt."

npr.orgA red hat, inspired by a symbol of resistance to Nazi occupation, gains traction in MinnesotaA Minneapolis knitting shop has resurrected the design of a Norwegian cap worn to protest Nazi occupation. Its owner says the money raised from hat pattern sales will support the local immigrant commu...

Agreed. Key word is accountability. But there must also be a serious revision of the tax code and overthrow of Citizens (dis)United. Otherwise we’ll be right back here again.

YES. Every dollar of revenue of every Trump company should be seized. It is all bribes. Don't want that to happen? Should have divested your holdings.

Thanks — great article. A peaceful resistance is the way. When the violence comes from the regime, public sentiment is swayed against the regime. But we absolutely must hold everyone who enabled this disaster accountable, and clawback all the stolen funds and resources for the people.

The most important thing a 2028 candidate can do is make the convincing case they’ll rebuild in 6 months. Newsom, Pritzker, AOC, Beshear, whoever. Make the case you’ll plow past kludgeocracy & restore things quickly