Charlotte O'Brien

Charlotte O'Brien

@cobrien.bsky.social

Professor of Law, University of York (she/her). Social security; EU law; discrimination; migration; social justice.

2.3K followers1.2K following289 posts

Pinned

Carry on Campaigning? Or Brexit as Not-So-Jolly Gents' Japes, plus Wives and Sisters making dinner. I have just done a rough and ready analysis of the 'talking head' contributions to the BBC's 'Brexit: a Very British Civil War'. A short 🧵about this Blokey Affair: www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/epis...

bbc.co.ukBrexit: A Very British Civil War - Series 1: 1. Demons UnleashedThe promise of a referendum helps David Cameron win a majority. Nigel Farage starts to campaign for Brexit. Boris Johnson and Michael Gove decide whether to back Leave or Remain.

JOY! Genuinely one of the best things ever. Went with family group, ages 7-78 and we all came out raving about it. Ages since I've been in such a packed cinema, and I can't remember ever being in one where the whole room laughed and *cheered* at the same moments. Go - not a moment to lose!

This post is unavailable.

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

New article in Punishment & Society 📢 Anti-torture advocates know the prison's failures, yet rely on it to punish torturers. Drawing on a survey and 18 interviews, I call this 'carceral fatalism' and argue for an abolitionist alternative. Read here: doi.org/10.1177/1462...

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

The interpretation of hope at the end of the Pandora myth is much disputed: but this is a good one. Also, it is my sister’s middle name.

Charlotte O'Brien@cobrien.bsky.social

“Hope is the warrior emotion” 🔥🔥🔥

'Thuggery' somehow does not seem quite serious enough to name what we are seeing in the increasing violence of anti-migrant hate-spinning. Thugs steal your lunch-money. These guys want to steal your humanity.

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

NEW | I’m not surprised, but I am livid. BBC NEWS, ‘DANNY TOMMO’ AND THE DINGHY ATTACK THAT DISAPPEARED While the rest of the media – even the very worst parts – report on Daniel Thomas’ actions, BBC News fails to give its audience the facts. brokenbottleboy.substack.com/p/bbc-news-d...

brokenbottleboy.substack.comBBC News, ‘Danny Tommo’ and the dinghy attack that disappearedWhile the rest of the media – even the very worst parts – report on Daniel Thomas’ actions, BBC News fails to give its audience the facts.

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

The number of cases of cervical cancer reported in Scotland among women given the HPV vaccine at 12-13 years of age is now zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. Zero. www.bbc.com/news/article...

bbc.comNo cervical cancer cases in fully HPV-vaccinated women in ScotlandA study published by Public Health Scotland finds that the HPV vaccine is "highly effective".

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

View full thread

All of which overlooks the point that the Human Rights Act creates strong duties of judicial review, which are in danger of being shrugged off, while the Court adopts an extremely dubious approach to disability discrimination. So - we do not hold back, as the quotes in the image in the OP indicates

We keep coming back to the UK Supreme Court's problematic framing of social security as a matter of 'politics' rather than law, hence the striking line in Jwanczuk that "There is no proper basis, consistent with the separation of powers, on which to overturn Parliament’s judgement".

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

If you're looking for some light summer reading, there's still time to snap up your copy! bristoluniversitypress.co.uk/trade/what-i...

bristoluniversitypress.co.ukWhat Is Immigration Policy For?What Is Immigration Policy For?; This book explores what immigration policy seeks to achieve and why so many people end up unhappy with the outcome. Drawing on decades of research and examples from hi...
Madeleine Sumption@msumption.bsky.social

A piece on my book "What is Immigration Policy For?" in Civil Service World - featuring the curious case of the UK's troubled attempts to admit migrant investors, among other things www.civilserviceworld.com/in-depth/art...

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

Andy Burnham correctly points out in an interview that small boat crossings are massively down this year compared with last. The comments in the post are filled with people suggesting he is lying about this very clear, data-evidenced fact. It’s almost as though they don’t want it to he true…

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

Much needed.

Charlotte O'Brien@cobrien.bsky.social

WAAAH! I can't believe I'm typing this - but I have a book contract for a non-fiction book for a general audience with @brisunipress.bsky.social to challenge damaging rhetoric about immigration and welfare, arguing that xenophobic law-making goes hand-in-hand with punishing the poor and hurts us all

Massive shout-out to the A-MAZ-ING people who read the proposal and advised me along the way, especially @colinyeo.bsky.social, @drproudman.bsky.social, Zoe Forbes and Rebecca Tomlinson. YOU ROCK! ❤️

Charlotte O'Brien@cobrien.bsky.social

WAAAH! I can't believe I'm typing this - but I have a book contract for a non-fiction book for a general audience with @brisunipress.bsky.social to challenge damaging rhetoric about immigration and welfare, arguing that xenophobic law-making goes hand-in-hand with punishing the poor and hurts us all

View full thread

BUP publish a select range of general non-fiction; this project relied on the incredible support of FIVE anonymous peer reviewers (some quotes on first post, some below). Watch this space – and to those supportive of the ideas and the mission, please *let’s help change the brutalising discourse*!

View full thread

The demonisation and Othering of immigrants and of welfare benefit recipients goes hand-in-hand. Xenophobic law-making hurts us all: when we use the law to create duties to discriminate, to increase our tolerance for human suffering,...

and to lower our concerns about child poverty, we degrade our legal framework, and ourselves.” And the intended price is: £22.99 hardbook, £14.99 paperback/ebook! Planned Sep 2028. The hope is this will not just go into university libraries, but will help shift discussion beyond academic corridors.

From the proposal, this, in a nutshell is the aim: “Bad things happen when laws are designed to divide and disempower. Political shifts have led to the law being weaponised and used as a tool of stigma, to encourage, rather than prevent, discrimination, and to isolate and penalise minorities...

The result does not just damage the rights of ‘others’ it is a brutalised law-making, that dehumanises the disadvantaged, and degrades us all. This book will argue that xenophobic law-making goes hand-in-hand with punishing the poor...

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

Replying to @peterwalker99.bsky.social

I go on quite a lot about Reform’s migration plans but not enough people seem to realise the effect they would have on hundreds of thousands of people, many of whom have made their lives here. It would be Windrush x 20.

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

A few token places on safe and legal routes for refugees cannot in any way mitigate or atone for what this government has done and is doing on asylum or immigration policy. A thread trying to be clear-eyed about this.

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

The EU's asylum pact applies from today - here's a reminder of my blog posts on this legislation from when it was agreed 1/ The new 'qualification regulation' - on the definition of 'refugee' and 'subsidiary protection' - eulawanalysis.blogspot.com/2023/12/the-...

eulawanalysis.blogspot.comThe New EU Asylum Laws, part 1: the Qualification RegulationProfessor Steve Peers , Royal Holloway University of London* Photo credit : Ggia, via Wikimedia Commons *sentences with an asterisk ...

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

Replying to @ottoenglish.bsky.social

Very illuminating thread on how the Brexit documentary is wall to wall men, virtually no women. bsky.app/profile/cobr...

Charlotte O'Brien@cobrien.bsky.social

Carry on Campaigning? Or Brexit as Not-So-Jolly Gents' Japes, plus Wives and Sisters making dinner. I have just done a rough and ready analysis of the 'talking head' contributions to the BBC's 'Brexit: a Very British Civil War'. A short 🧵about this Blokey Affair: www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/epis...

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

Excellent thread. We saw something similar with Covid when the decisions were made by men for men.

Charlotte O'Brien@cobrien.bsky.social

Carry on Campaigning? Or Brexit as Not-So-Jolly Gents' Japes, plus Wives and Sisters making dinner. I have just done a rough and ready analysis of the 'talking head' contributions to the BBC's 'Brexit: a Very British Civil War'. A short 🧵about this Blokey Affair: www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/epis...

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

Brexit. Reform. All this right wing shit. It's men from top to bottom. If we're not viewing all of this through a feminist lens, we're doing it wrong. This thread is utterly enraging.

Charlotte O'Brien@cobrien.bsky.social

Carry on Campaigning? Or Brexit as Not-So-Jolly Gents' Japes, plus Wives and Sisters making dinner. I have just done a rough and ready analysis of the 'talking head' contributions to the BBC's 'Brexit: a Very British Civil War'. A short 🧵about this Blokey Affair: www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/epis...

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

I was a political reporter during #Brexit. I remember watching Boris Johnson drive that Leave truck out of that trading estate at the start of the campaign. I followed it to see where it went. It parked up around the corner.

Charlotte O'Brien@cobrien.bsky.social

Carry on Campaigning? Or Brexit as Not-So-Jolly Gents' Japes, plus Wives and Sisters making dinner. I have just done a rough and ready analysis of the 'talking head' contributions to the BBC's 'Brexit: a Very British Civil War'. A short 🧵about this Blokey Affair: www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/epis...

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

A necessary thread.

Charlotte O'Brien@cobrien.bsky.social

Carry on Campaigning? Or Brexit as Not-So-Jolly Gents' Japes, plus Wives and Sisters making dinner. I have just done a rough and ready analysis of the 'talking head' contributions to the BBC's 'Brexit: a Very British Civil War'. A short 🧵about this Blokey Affair: www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/epis...

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

I kept waiting to hear from a woman in the Brexit doc who wasn’t married or related to one of the male “protagonists”. I spent a lot of time waiting!

Charlotte O'Brien@cobrien.bsky.social

Moreover, of that 7 minutes 6 seconds of women speaking, only 185 seconds (3 minutes, 5 seconds) are with women who are not Boris Johnson's ex wife, or Boris Johnson's sister, or Michael Gove's wife.

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

Excellent analysis of this ridiculous piece of preening nonsense.

Charlotte O'Brien@cobrien.bsky.social

Carry on Campaigning? Or Brexit as Not-So-Jolly Gents' Japes, plus Wives and Sisters making dinner. I have just done a rough and ready analysis of the 'talking head' contributions to the BBC's 'Brexit: a Very British Civil War'. A short 🧵about this Blokey Affair: www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/epis...

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

Ffs. Great thread. She has counted so that we don’t have to.

Charlotte O'Brien@cobrien.bsky.social

Carry on Campaigning? Or Brexit as Not-So-Jolly Gents' Japes, plus Wives and Sisters making dinner. I have just done a rough and ready analysis of the 'talking head' contributions to the BBC's 'Brexit: a Very British Civil War'. A short 🧵about this Blokey Affair: www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/epis...

Charlotte O'Brien reposted

glad someone did this so we didn't have to but dear god

Charlotte O'Brien@cobrien.bsky.social

Carry on Campaigning? Or Brexit as Not-So-Jolly Gents' Japes, plus Wives and Sisters making dinner. I have just done a rough and ready analysis of the 'talking head' contributions to the BBC's 'Brexit: a Very British Civil War'. A short 🧵about this Blokey Affair: www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/epis...