Ryan Broderick

Ryan Broderick

@ryanhatesthis.bsky.social

Chilling online. I write a newsletter called Garbage Day.

81.5K followers1.5K following994 posts

Ryan Broderick reposted

"Silicon Valley created a new, worse version of popularity that everyone just accepted at face value at some point between 2019-2023." The Garbage Day newsletter is talking here about pop music, but I'm gonna hold onto this and apply it everywhere.

Of the 14 songs that broke the same record "Choosin' Texas" just broke, nine of them were this century and six were in the last decade. Is a hit song still a hit if it climbs to the top of streaming charts and gets algorithmically stuck there for sixth months?

Garbage Day@garbageday.email

Why "Choosin' Texas" doesn't feel like a hit www.garbageday.email/p/why-choosi...

Ryan Broderick reposted

Many years ago, there was a yearly internet-themed Halloween costume contest in New York City called Hallowmeme. Our next live show at Baby’s All Right in Brooklyn on October 27th is NOT Hallowmeme. But it is a tribute. It’s a night of comedy, music, journalism, and of course, a costume contest.

There was so much neurotic moral policing when I was a kid in the 90s and 2000s about what people were doing outside of their homes — how they dressed, how they talked, where they went — but after 2020, we've become obsessed with what we think people are doing or not doing at home.

Ryan Broderick@ryanhatesthis.bsky.social

On how the fear that no one is reading anymore is sorta the same fear that no one is having sex anymore which is really just a fear that, for those of us old enough to remember the before time, the world feels different now in ways we can't really explain www.garbageday.email/p/every-new-...

Ryan Broderick reposted

You can’t beat the GOP by adopting their tactics because the fight is asymmetrical. You have to come up with something new!

Ryan Broderick@ryanhatesthis.bsky.social

Couldn't fit this into the piece, but the belief that the left needs its own oaf means that Trump is still dictating the rules of engagement. Believing 1) white working class men are the voters that matter and 2) that they will only vote for themselves is just MAGA with a different coat of paint.

Couldn't fit this into the piece, but the belief that the left needs its own oaf means that Trump is still dictating the rules of engagement. Believing 1) white working class men are the voters that matter and 2) that they will only vote for themselves is just MAGA with a different coat of paint.

Ryan Broderick@ryanhatesthis.bsky.social

A lot of leftist men were — and seemingly still are — willing to accept Graham Platner's many many faults because they have a sneering, condescending belief that working people in this country are white townie oafs who will only listen to other white townie oafs. www.garbageday.email/p/the-curdli...

Leftist strongmen like Platner is not Democrats telling a new story. It's the same laziness leftists accuse mainstream libs of. It's the same losing strategy Dems have pursued for a decade, but from a different direction: Tell Republicans what they want to hear and they'll vote blue.

OK so I finally saw both: -Backrooms was technically impressive, prettier, and better paced. Would watch again. -Obsession had a tighter script, better characters, and was scarier. But it suffers from orange sludge lighting and is a meaner, nastier film I don't want to ever watch again.

They claim that the anti-trans movement started in 2014 which is just wrong. I've spent the last few years binging a lot of old TV shows and what's very strange about the shows that ran across the 2000s is that many of them start making trans jokes completely out of nowhere between 2005-2007.

"They just shouldn't have participated in society" Fucking panel of cis gays discussing what trans people did to deserve genocide. Cool.

View full thread

Now that we're on the eve of woke 2.0 or whatever, there are a lot of people who want to fix the overreach or cringe of woke 1.0 or whatever, but if you go back and look at media before the 2010s, you can clearly see that we are still buried until culture war shit that started in the Bush era.

I'd have to go deeper on this than just watching old TV shows but I think it's very likely the anti-trans movement at least within the media started in earnest during the recession, actually receded as the economy recovered, and then completely exploded after Trump took power.

They claim that the anti-trans movement started in 2014 which is just wrong. I've spent the last few years binging a lot of old TV shows and what's very strange about the shows that ran across the 2000s is that many of them start making trans jokes completely out of nowhere between 2005-2007.

"They just shouldn't have participated in society" Fucking panel of cis gays discussing what trans people did to deserve genocide. Cool.

2 random examples, but House and Entourage, completely politically incorrect by today's standards, basically never mention trans people until suddenly both deciding to drop the T-slur in 2007. It comes out of nowhere and is very clearly tied to some larger anti-trans sentiment building at the time.

My guiding principle is that platforms actually don't — or even can't — suppress anything beyond nudity, gore, swears, some hate speech, etc. But I do think they can promote different content and incentivize users to make more of it. Which is what I think is happening on YouTube right now.

Lucy Hamilton@lucyham.bsky.social

Interesting piece from Ryan Broderick at @garbageday.email Speculation on the degree to which a change of focus at YouTube might have suppressed the wave of invidious panics that have swung elections. www.garbageday.email/p/youtube-do...

Good not be more excited about this!!!

Lisa Tozzi@lisatozzi.bsky.social

Super excited to work with @ryanhatesthis.bsky.social @cates.bsky.social and the rest of the @garbageday.email team! Thanks @status.news for calling me a splashy hire! www.status.news/p/new-york-t...