Post

People get confused about the trans sports thing because at a glance it seems like a small issue that impacts a very small number of people and thus makes sense as a "reasonable" concession. But it isn't, because conceding that is accepting that a kid's trans identity is on some level fraudulent

Which is exactly why they've turned it into the Most Important Issue Facing America. It's not because they give a shit about youth - especially girls - sports. They obviously do not!

They use it to make participation harder, have women/girls/LGBTQ face harassment for their looks, lessen participation & then end female sports as too LGBTQ positive. Don’t support or attend female sports, except to complain. Aren’t protecting women, are discriminating.

Once you've granted the idea that it's dangerous to allow trans kids to play organized sports, you're already 99% of the way to agreeing to bathroom bans. You've stipulated to the transphobes' central argument.

Here's my point, we all breathe oxygen, resperate and need to pee, truth do you look at the person next to you while doing a human function, my wife would just jump on ole porcelain while I was shaving, ITS NOT A BIG DEAL If, it is a big deal It's the bathroom Look in the mirror It's you

Scapegoating marginal groups is how fascism demonstrates expanding oppression for its intimidating minority control. There is no way to meet this abuse "in the middle" without enabling more of it. bsky.app/profile/ianb...

Ian Boudreau@ianboudreau.com

Once you've granted the idea that it's dangerous to allow trans kids to play organized sports, you're already 99% of the way to agreeing to bathroom bans. You've stipulated to the transphobes' central argument.

But Ian said "Once you've granted the idea that it's dangerous to allow trans kids to play organized sports..." So if you *don't* think that's dangerous, he's not talking about you.

The problem with this argumentation on your behalf is that the people who need to understand it are not ready to admit conceptual throughline or material conditions matter. They live in a world where each of these debates are separate issues in a vacuum you can have a convo about in a college class.

You cannot get these people to admit that funding Harry Potter is transphobic! Not "should you fund..."; not "ought" or any of that! That it is transphobic at base. An incontrovertible fact! To them, making the leap that "handing transphobe who is doing transphobia money = transphobia" is too far.

if trans kids are disgusting, moral taste CANNOT clarify and worldview stays small, dim, and safe the instant brains see love is good and hunger is evil, self-expression is love and profit is hunger, the WHOLE system will wake up to the self-enslavement we've taught ourselves to suffer under

The ballot initiative here in Washington would require all who want to play in woman’s sports to prove they are eligible by genitalia, chromosome, or testosterone level. Every single student would face an invasions of their privacy to for a nonexistent issue. Except those who play men’s sports.

It's explicitly a stalking horse for education (college and under) and employment (everyone else) discrimination. Which are the main kinds of discrimination. They have at times been very very explicit that they want to use trans participation sports as a wedge to undermine and overturn Title IX!

I am extremely skeptical that the way to win these people's votes is to tell them their assumptions are ignorant and their concerns are invalid. The trick is telling them what they think they want to hear and then doing the right thing after they elect you.

if anyone reading this belongs to a minority group, how would you feel if a progressive darling endorsed one of the most persistent libels against you and gave a plausibly deniable endorsement to a policy that retracted your rights?

if you wouldn't feel great about it, why? nothing material was conceded, after all. why are trans people (trans children!) seen as acceptable to do this kind of treacherous disavowal to?

They really don't, they push their religious conservatism however they can, even by pretending it's not religiously driven. From 2017.

You are ignoring this is an 80/20 issue where many people-- women, liberals, parents, athletes, Democrats-- do not want gender id overriding sex when sex is the relevant divisor. In sports male sex, regardless of self image, confers advantages.

Disagree with you there. They’ve turned it into the Most Important Issue Facing America because it does exactly what it’s doing: it divides the Democratic coalition, and unites the right.

Someone's trans identity directly flies in the face of the American Christian's belief in god and their religion as a whole and because of that they can never accept it as being anything other than fraudulent.

Also, so many of these people obsessed with school sports will use any little bit they're given to start terrorizing any girl or boy who doesn't conform to how they think a boy or girl should look. They'll be wanting legal permission to peek in underpants.It's just the first step on a horrible road.