Pinned
#helloesr CNRS senior researcher, working on the political economy of academic publications, scientific director of matilda.science?l=fr and tempted to make a corpus of how French academics present themselves when they reach bluesky
polecopub
@polecopub.bsky.social
The bluesky account where academic publications are treated as social, political, technical and economic objects #STS #Openscience #PoliticalEconomy Blog: https://polecopub.hypotheses.org/ Matilda scientifc director: https://matilda.science/?l=en
961 followers369 following599 posts
Pinned
#helloesr CNRS senior researcher, working on the political economy of academic publications, scientific director of matilda.science?l=fr and tempted to make a corpus of how French academics present themselves when they reach bluesky
polecopub reposted
Already in chapter 1. A must read on the social history of #peerreview, #reviewers and #referees
I am absolutely delighted to announce that the open access version of "In Referees We Trust? How Peer Review Became a Mark of Scientific Legitimacy" is now live! Want to know more about how scholars' lives came to be ruled by Reviewer 2? Download the book FREE at: direct.mit.edu/books/monogr...
polecopub reposted
85% of #OA journals in sociology & political science are #DiamondOpenAccess #DOA. They lag behind Gold #OpenAccess in technical standards, visibility & citation impact—but more often let authors retain copyright. Read the study by Joachim Schöpfel and me: doi.org/10.5281/zeno...
polecopub reposted
The redefinition of authorship. I love "a human author" which seems to reject collective authorship And publisher work. Not mentioning many non-humans (computers, printers, multiple software,...) were involved into the "creation" of "your book".
Canada is refusing to issue ISBNs to books primarily generated with AI. This illustrates both the urgency of the problem of the growing flood of slop books, and also the toothlessness of addressing it on the honor system without there also being consequences for lying
polecopub reposted
I'm standing for election to the Crossref Board of Directors. You may be familiar with the important work Crossref does to connect and preserve the scholarly record. 2 billion citations ! Read my statement here bit.ly/4jbgK6A and vote if you are a Crossref member. @crossref.bsky.social
polecopub reposted
🌍 150+ signatories, and counting! The Barcelona Declaration now brings together 150+ signatory organizations across 37 countries. New signatories come from Brazil, El Salvador, Georgia & Spain. Together, we’re making open research information the norm. barcelona-declaration.org/signatories/
That is the new normal: in some cases, fake data open to publish, in others genuine #opendata "analyzed" by #GenAI to quickly publish crap. 50 years ago, "sloppy and dirty science" already existed (see Latour's portrait of a biologist as a capitalist), it has become "clean" fake science.
This is a disturbing story - two published neuroscience papers that were seemingly completed AI generated retractionwatch.com/2026/10/01/o... It was only detected because of a vigilant peer reviewer on a third submission @deevybee.bsky.social.
Inflation is everywhere, except at @crossref.bsky.social #openscience #opendata
Key decisions our current board has made: lowering DOI registration fees doi.org/10.64000/nvf... & rebuilding the Crossref system doi.org/10.64000/enn... Meet the candidates standing for election 👉 bit.ly/4jbgK6A. Who will represent you? 🗳️Vote by 22 Oct 2026 #Crossref2026
The never ending catastrophe of #GenAI in academia: #openscience infrastructures forced to close just to be able to survive. After limitations on review papers, limitations on new authors, limitations on the number of posted preprints.
arXiv has updated our policy on rate limiting for all submitters. This update was made to fairly distribute moderator time & support the arXiv community of staff, volunteers, readers & authors. Please read our announcement to learn more: https://blog.arxiv.org/2026/10/01/updated-rate-limit-policy/
polecopub reposted
Replying to @petersuber.bsky.social
Update. I have no plans to write a retrospective essay on #OATP ( @oatp.fediscience.org.ap.brid.gy ). But I've started writing up some Tagging Principles that I learned from OATP. It's a work-in-progress and I welcome comments. docs.google.com/document/d/1... #Folksonomy #Ontology #Tagging
polecopub reposted
Today is Pub Day for "Data Are Made, Not Found: A Story of Politics, Power, and the Civil Servants Who Saved the US Census"!!! ::bounce:: Please support me by buying a copy of the book or asking your library for a copy! press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/bo...
polecopub reposted
They already are, see SocArxiv posts for moderation nightmare. And of cours chemistry and biology crap have been there for quite some time through paper mills or more amateurish sources. You can "publish" a systematic review of any given discipline, full of crap of course, but that looks legitimate.
"All corners of academia will soon be flooded with AI-generated research....Maths and CS go first because their entire output is symbol manipulation...Biology comes later not because biologists are cleverer but because the rate-limiting step is physical" giorgio.gilest.ro/the-weimar-o...
polecopub reposted
polecopub reposted
📢 CALL FOR PAPERS | Manufacturing (Dis)Trust: Predatory Journals, Paper Mills, and the Crisis of Research Integrity. RC23 session at the XXI ISA World Congress of Sociology. Abstract deadline: 14 October 2026. #ISA2027 #RC23 #SociologyOfScience #STS Details: isaconf.confex.com/.../webprogr...
It is not as if "colors" or even "Unpaywall colors" were enough to share a common #openaccess landscape. In this preprint, we show how OpenAccess Monitors completely différ in their scope and categories from one country to another #openscience hal.science/hal-05661835v2
A classical example of centralized/decentralized French HER system. ABES negotiates and define standards, thousands of librarians/curators in hundreds of différent HER institutions daily work on metadata #openscience
[auto] New on the ROR blog: "How ABES Became the Second-Largest Provider of ROR IDs in Crossref Metadata"
polecopub reposted
📢 The Ministry of Higher Education, Research, and Space has unveiled the new French Open Science Strategy 2026-2033! www.enseignementsup-recherche.gouv.fr/en/launch-fr... www.enseignementsup-recherche.gouv.fr/en/french-op... @enseignementsup-recherche.gouv.fr @marind.eurosky.social
polecopub reposted
Do people understand that this is just starting? The US Gov declining only means that we are now carrying this forward ourselves. I have had a few conversations with folks that thought this meant the case was over.
1/ In 2024, I filed a false claims act lawsuit against Elsevier, Springer, Wiley & Informa alleging they systematically overcharged US federal grants for article processing. The gov declined to intervene and now it's public. Some thoughts on what this is, and what it isn't:
polecopub reposted
Matilda has reached 170M deduplicated publications, among which 38.5M are full-text searchable. Everything is free, sharable and reusable and will remain as such under our #POSI commitments and following our mission matilda.science/mission?l=en #openscience #opendata
polecopub reposted
Congratulations to Elsevier on this insanity my colleague found. Is anything in this clinical trial from Spain and UK real? www.cell.com/the-innovati...
polecopub reposted
polecopub reposted
Colada[139] Artificial Deadlines Part 2 Evidence of fraud in the 25 year old gradesheet behind the key finding in an influential paper on deadlines and procrastination. datacolada.org/139
@petersuber should be thanked for decades of engagement and work for the #openaccess #openscience community.
This is the last month of activity for the Open Access Tracking Project (#OATP, @oatp). September 30, 2026, will be the last day of tagging and updates. The Harvard instance of #TagTeam -- the #OpenSource tagging platform on which OATP ran -- will start winding down soon after. But the code […]
polecopub reposted
polecopub reposted
Dean of Science at Stellenbosch University writes that although AI generates almost all the words for his articles (including this one): "AI did almost all of the writing. I remain the expert and the thought leader behind the piece." www.nature.com/articles/d44...
polecopub reposted
REAL ISSUE: scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2026/08/14/g... as we increase reliance on trust markers and the like we risk shutting unaffiliated scholars out of the system
polecopub reposted
polecopub reposted
A very interesting case in sociology of #ignorance. Science bigotry pushes a journal not to consider evidence given in court (and public knowledge) that the data was biased by the very company making the drug. It won't retract it, then allow it to be cited in other papers and clinical guidelines.
The request — which initially included two of the paper’s original authors — stems from 19-year-old court records revealing the sponsor of the study withheld evidence about opioid withdrawal that contradicted the paper’s conclusions.
polecopub reposted
✨New Work✨ forthcoming at #AIES2026: 1️⃣ "Data Annotation as Measurement" by me, @allisonkoe.bsky.social, and @kizilcec.bsky.social explores how data annotation can go wrong, and how measurement theory can help improve it. 🔗: arxiv.org/pdf/2608.07297
polecopub reposted
A very insightful post on how #researchmisconduct inquiries happen (and diverge). IMHO, the only oddities in Arday's case are his weird extra-academic claims (charities, sport...) and the fact that he resigned so quickly. #researchintegrity #peerreview
The Jason Arday case may seem highly unusual. But the reality is it follows a typical pattern found within academic cases of plagiarism and research misconduct. Check out my new piece, which provides further context to Arday’s case. academiclife.substack.com/p/how-do-aca...