Post

I'm a firm believer that if your "straightforward", "simple" street layout requires a 1 minute instructional video to try and explain what the ambiguous signs and all that paint on the road wants you to do, it's not nearly as straightforward and simple as you imagine it is.

The City of Edinburgh Council@edinburghcouncil.bsky.social

Two stage right turns for cyclists have been introduced on Summerhall. This will make it safer and easier for cyclists to turn right onto Hope Park Terrace and from the opposite direction on Summerhall, right onto Melville Drive.

36 reposts123 likes

I dunno, I always thought they reinforced predictable behaviour by less confident cyclists by accommodating it in the road system without rebuilding an entire junction. Not perfect by any means, and you always have the choice to just stay with the rest of the traffic.

It's effectively the council saying, 'We didn't bother to design this junction properly, therefore as a cyclist you compensate for our inadequacies by taking a convoluted route for what should be a simple maneuver.'

Round here motorists just use them as extra space to sit in traffic jams (the road to the left has a red light and cycle lane a green at this point)

There is already a somewhat similar arrangement on Bruntsfield place for accessing the cycle path down through the links. There is a wee ramp up on to the pavement if you are heading down towards Tollcross. Then use the pedestrian crossing.

This doesn't at address the problems that cyclists have to see behind them and drivers need to be looking sideways. The Dutch roundabout model that ensures all bike/car interactions are at 90° makes that work naturally.

I think I’d just use the advanced green light to make sure I crossed the junction in time. Make the green long enough and everyone could do the same before the cars start?

This only works if you get to the lights and they're red. If they're green then the video method is actually decent because it adds very little time and theres no lane changes needed and you get to do the turn ahead of cars. Either way it's not mandatory, i'd only use it when its busy

Agree it will take some getting used to - a bit like floating bus stops for pedestrians - but two part turns are quite widely used at busy junctions in more cycle-friendly places in Europe

It’s a Copenhagen-left, isn’t it? Prevents cyclists from ever having to cross traffic and keeps things safer. Sure it takes a little more time, but works really well from my experience (and everyone knows how to do it …)