Post

I love hanging out with my parents because they are great parents: have these parents considered trying “not being terrible parents”

Michael Hobbes@michaelhobbes.bsky.social

This is a quietly metastasizing moral panic

133 reposts1.5K likes

My dad didn’t even tell me when his mom died. His brother did. Same with his dad. And NOBODY told me when my great aunt or uncle died. So like. Feels like there’s some room for him to grow. I’m just giving him the space to do so.

I have been very lucky to be raised by parents who were at least warmly cordial with their parents and clearly loved them even though they often needed to keep them at arm's length (both my parents moved hundreds of miles from home before they met). I try to use that as an inspiration.

Ayup my parents know exactly why I stopped coming to visit for christmas, despite now being able to self fund the trip.

Whenever I see this (usually as a window sticker on an oversized SUV) I think to myself "Lady, that ain't really up to you, and it isn't likely to work out the way you're hoping." These people feel entitled to their kids' entire lives, like they have a right to decide who they're going to be.

My parents did not. Let me tell you, it's not easy to put even a little distance between yourself & them. You carry guilt and all the rest of your extended family think you're terrible. Even when you stll partipate in the holidays & birthdays. Kudos to people for putting themselves first.

My dad went on a rant last week about how it's "okay for men to beat women after a certain point" when the subject of how badly he used to beat my mother came up in conversation. Last time I spoke to my mother, she told me she was happy I was homeless. Gee, wonder why nobody likes these people.

Thank you. It's rough. I have it really bad, and yet somehow, there are still people out there who have it worse than me. Breaks my heart to think about.

I would steal away in the middle of the night, but not before drawing glasses and a mustache on that Trump poster :-)

Mine have definitely not tried this, in fact they are repelled at the idea that they have not always been the best parents anyone could ever have despite 2/3 of their children being no- or very low contact and all of their children having moved thousands of miles away

also this nails it. people have been quietly cutting off their horrid family members since the dawn of time, it just used to be easier to get away with it unnoticed before we had instantaneous global communication. bsky.app/profile/lasr...

Hipster Vampire Amy@lasrina.bsky.social

Kind of hilarious how they’re acting like this is a brand new thing because Woke and not possibly part of the reason people have been fucking off across the sea in extremely fragile oceangoing vessels since the dawn of humanity, though

Meanwhile in my family history I have a great grandpa who ran away from home at 13 (his grandpa tracked him down and then decided that he was lost to them- he had become a carpenter), and all these editorials make me miss the days you could run away and be lost to another occupation

but also like people who are belligerently unapologetic about their awful views (to say nothing of their actions) have narrative cover and support from the media to tell a story that this treatment is unfair and that they are in fact the victims

You didn’t have to come out and SAY that you were packing up your ocean-crossing canoe to search across the seas for a new land just to get away from your awful family, but you know that had to have been a FACTOR for a lot of history’s intrepid explorers and settlers

This thread is reminding me that the cause and effect of terrible politics and low productivity in rural areas is backwards from what most pundits (left and right) say it is - these places have bad economics because they have driven every creative and intelligent person out.

Me: <Looks up stereotypes of Polynesian parents> [Strict discipline... authoritarian... the silent glare... mothers enforcing discipline with a broom... no back-talk... unrealistic expectations... love expressed through food, not words... expectations of financial support...] Yeah, that fits.

On a more contemporary and less wholesome note, I have heard a few ex-members of the FARC or paramilitares tell me in essence "I grew up in a tiny village and my mother was constantly hounding me, so when the recruiter came around promising me a salary and a way out of (t)her(e) I joined".

mfs out here being like “if I have to see my uncle Teuira and my aunt Uira one more fucking time on this tiny island, I will drown myself in the sea, so guess I’m packing up the outrigger canoe and brushing up on my star navigation”

“Oh, there’s a frozen land bridge leading to uncharted territories across the Bering Sea now? Where my horrible family won’t follow me to judge my mammoth spearing technique ever again? Sign me up.”

See now I'm trying to gauge how annoyed you'd have to be to go find Australia and then decide you were good to stay put.

I bet it was a lot of walking types. Guys and gals who like to take a nice walk you know. They get addicted to it and the next thing you know they’re in Kamchatka thinking about the sea

Literally starving to death on an open raft becalmed in the middle of the Pacific gyre would be better than spending one additional New York minute with my in-laws, said many many many people in the history of humanity.

Captain Nemo took it a step further and figured out how to make cheese from the milk of marine mammals, which means that he and his crew were milking marine mammals. (tbf they censored the backstory that he was a Polish noble whose family was killed by the Russians, so he hated all other families)

My English grandma married my American grandpa who was stationed there in WW2 in 1945 just to get the hell out of town and go to the USA. Like, she sorta loved him, I think but more than that, she wanted OUTTTT from her family and this was cheaper and more accessible than therapy lol

I’ve been doing Duolingo, and sometimes in my practice conversations, it will ask me if I would want to live in the past, and I’m like, I’m a woman, so no.

His parents, what little we see of them in the first book, seem very nice. But it's weird how little contact they have with family when they seemed quite close in the first book. I didn't clock until later that the cousins are *double* cousins, so quite close relatives.

I never really thought about it that way, but yeah, maybe going on a boat facing the high likelihood of death was just preferable to being home with your parents.

Members of my family have been putting literal seas between them and their parents since the Spanish Inquisition. Finding two generations that stayed in the same country is rare, making for lots of genealogy headaches.

No one in my family moved to the other side of the country in order to facilitate going LC/NC with terrible parents, definitely not (jk yes they did)

I come from a proud line of fuck-off-ers. My parents were both ‘black sheep’ (of black sheep!) so I never had much extended fam to deal with—and I cut off my in-laws (my spouse in full support, though he still has contact with them).

I have an ancestor who moved to Australia and his name when he left the UK was Roy Batty (better known for other work), and his name when he got here was something entirely different. The suspicion is he too was getting away from family.

So many movies from the 70-90 are about the horrible yearly visit to the ancestral home, like people moving to the other side of the US and keeping the barest minimum contact with the parents very much was already an accepted reality.

I know, right? As someone on the other end of this (estranged from parents for the last 2 years), I'm like... I would love to have a great relationship with my parents, and had worked hard to get to that - only to have it thrown in my face. How hard it is to just not be a total jerk to your kids?

The reality of this is that many parents, terrified by the rate of change they see in the world, decide that their "woke kids" make a great punching bag because unlike the rest of the world, they won't punch back. Then they're shocked when the de-escalation via cut contact inevitably occurs.

Estrangement is not a one way street. Some children, especially those with substance abuse, gambling problems or criminal activity would bankrupt their parents if continued support offered. My partner knew of a prisoner who killed his mother for speaking to his daughter in a manner he disliked.

Sure - but this discussion is specifically about parents very publicly complaining about their children and demanding parental rights, not about parents who cut their children off for whatever reason (sometimes good reasons).

parents whose children are in the control of an abusive partner find groups about partner abuse. What’s left are the people who have no idea why their children left them. And that, my friends, is a vast and waving red flag."

my parents have long been open about the fact that they don't *understand* my life, but they're glad I'm having a good time living it, and they're welcoming and kind to the people I share it with I think this is a mature and healthy way of going about it and definitely recommend it to other parents

As parent to adults, I have found pleasure in witnessing my offspring grow into their own selves. A key to achieving that positive experience is learning when to keep my mouth shut.

That’s the thing. I really hope my kids will still want to spend time with us once they’ve flown the nest. But ultimately it’s like any relationship, it needs mutual affection and respect and is never owed.

When I’ve moved abroad the amount of times I visited my parents went down to once or twice a year, because of cost and logistics. But there have always been regular calls inbetween. Once they got older and sicker and I found a job where occasional working abroad was allowed visit frequency went up

There are many factors that govern how often you’re in touch with people you care about . But if someone actively decides to cut you off, there is probably a reason. And not being in touch often isn’t the same as cutting off either.

Talk with my dad a few weeks before I went back to Cleveland for my senior year of college: Dad: You're graduating next year. Any idea what you're doing after that? Me: Getting a job, duh. D: And where do you think that'll be? M: Probably Cleveland. D: And if you don't find one there?

M: I guess somewhere around here (NYC area, LI specifically). D: If that happens, you weren't planning on living here, were you? M: Why would I do that? D: Good. And I got along pretty well with mom and dad.

All three of us moved from Michigan to Florida to get away from our mother because of the abuse (physical for my older sisters, mental & financial for me). Ostensibly it was for school or work, but because our grandfather had retired here, vacation memories & warm weather had us looking here.

When I left, I did confront my mother and told her I didn’t like who I was when I was around her. We only spoke 2x more, once to request some legal paperwork she never did send, once to tell her she wasn’t needed at the hospital where I was recovering from an accident I’d died & been resuscitated.