Post

I do feel like part of the hatred extended toward Bluesky is a function of preferring to think that the alarm about the state of the country that’s common here is misguided or exaggerated. Dismissing the site as liberal doomers allows you to dismiss those concerns, too.

782 reposts5.6K likes

For the last decade, America has been polarized, not according to parties or ideologies or left & right, but into two opposing consciousnesses: those who think Donald Trump’s ascendance is a moral emergency for the country that exceeds other political and social considerations, and those who do not.

This is actually really profound because I think that more than left/right divisions right now, THIS is the division. People who see this for what it is and are sounding the alarms, and ppl who are like stop I just want to live my life in peace. And those ppl can be and are from the left AND right.

The battle in America right now is not between Democrats and Republicans or liberals and conservatives, that’s just window dressing. It’s between liberals and authoritarians. You can be democratic or republican and still be a classic liberal. The modern GOP is illiberal.

Yeah, it’s not like the professional cynics have ever underestimated what this admin is capable of & willing to do. If any POV has been vindicated since 2016, it’s the POV of those of us who knew what he was then & what he is now. The rest is cope & denial.

Oh yeah, cos none of us issued any kind of warnings about Trump 2.0. Do the haters feel that those concerns were misguided or exaggerated? Probably yeah, if they’re already haters. But hey, if they’re listening: 🚨‼️ 📣A FARAGE GOVERNMENT WILL DESTROY THE UK IN THE SAME WAY!🚨

It's part of the Nazi Playbook to engender doubt and denial about facts so when those using BlueSky are targeted It's proof we are not going along with their false narratives. Any decent person simply seeking the truth will be able to arrive at the conclusion 47 et al and the Republicans are a 1/

clear and present danger to America through their plethora of treasonous and abhorrent acts. That is evidenced across your country as Americans have been placed in peril in every possible way by the regime. From air safety to food safety to disaster response to national security and so much more 2/

the regime has malevolently pursued its' dark agenda and denigrated vital services (FBI, DOJ, FEMA, FDA to cite just a few!) to strip away safeguards that protect Americans. The blatant greed of 47 and his family as they enrich themselves by gleefully defiling the presidency is shared with 3/

every individual in the regime as they seek $$$ and power rather than protecting and caring for Americans. There is plenty of proof of such avarice and one example is the refusal to put common sense gun laws in place. $$$ has been callously chosen over lives, beyond sickening. The reality 47 et 4/

Listen to scholars on fascism and authoritarianism. Listen to or read survivors of Nazi death camps. Read books on WW2. Look who this administration doesn't insult and lie about. Believe your eyes and ears Trump Inc is destroying our democracy. It's just what are we going to do about it.

I often find myself in conversations (including on TV) trying to recenter the conversation on the big picture. The nuances and developments are important, but it’s also incredibly important to recognize the project that’s underway for what it is.

Motives of people who post obviously include a desire to say something, not necessarily listen to something, but I have had meaningful discussions on BlueSky and have been corrected as well. So far it is decently fast with news and refreshingly decent in tone, unlike eX which is a sewer.

Kinda feels like another species of "liberal media bias". It's discrediting the message by discrediting the messenger, and provides an easy way to dismiss what is being said without having to actually engage on the merits. I know MAGAs who dismiss anything not reported on FOX as fake news.

This was my take on the hate...

Jay W@jaydeedouble.bsky.social

“How can you be a social network without any Nazis?!?? Can’t you see how exclusionist and non-entertaining for profit you’re being?!?!” - Tech Bros, Modern Republicans and Major Media

I prefer to assess the threat. I research if there is legal precedent for Trump or Miller or Bondi etc…to do whatever it is they’re threatening to do, and then decide if said idiotic threat/proposal is worthy of doom. It usually isn’t.

etc.toHome

Some are angry bc so many frustrated people turned on their heels and went to place where they have more control to what they see, can say and want to hear. They cannot force themselves (see a pattern there) yelling to our ears their hate towards world they see unfair towards them.

His supporters deep down know he is a danger to our democracy, society in general and to the world order. On Bluesky, we forewarn & heed the battle cry to defend & protect our country from him and his followers who want to destroy our way of life & our rights including right to even have opinions.

I jump between the two sites for a variety of reasons & I can honestly say I experience alot more intensity & hate in comments on Bluesky. Don’t get this wrong – I’m not saying there is more politics of hate, but I find people on bluesky are more intense and respond with more hateful comments.

Up to now you have posted ar 150 posts and nearly none got a direct answer. You obviously are on the right, so it's not really astonishing that you get more positive answers elsewhere. You called all the people here unhappy, how can you expect to be taken seriously?

I’m primarily at the other site and my anxiety about what’s happening has never been higher. Also, spouse, who is not as dialed in as I am but whose father lived under Nazi occupation is getting increasingly alarmed. And he is a big picture kind of guy.

No it’s because the conservative right only allows like thinkers else those indoctrinated to obey without question might get an ounce of critical thinking skills and question WTF they have been indoctrinated to!

Meanwhile in the UK The owner of Twitter made an appearance via video link at a far right rally in London on Saturday, inciting violence "Violence is coming to you" "You either fight back or you die" "The left are the party of murder" "There’s got to be a change of government in Britain"

theguardian.comElon Musk calls for dissolution of parliament at far-right rally in LondonUS-based tech boss was addressing the ‘unite the kingdom’ protest organised by Tommy Robinson via video link

More details on the rally from @hopenothate.org.uk

HOPE not hate@hopenothate.org.uk

🚨 Yesterday we saw Britain’s largest ever far-right protest with police estimating 110,000 people in attendance for Tommy Robinson's “Unite the Kingdom” rally. Read our analysis of the day with all the details of just how extreme it really was. hopenothate.org.uk/2025/09/13/b...

most of the criticism I've seen of bsky out in the wilds is that it's the last bastion of progressive-ish people who care more about the wording you use to complain about an issue than how you'd want to solve it

Too too many critical thinkers posting on Bluesky. Makes the control freaks very nervous. Hard to spew propaganda when so many people can think for themselves.

It is getting harder every week to find media that is not being controlled or in the process of being bought up by the American government or some billionaire tech bro. A platform that promotes truthful conversation is the real threat I think.

A rich white landlord stands to lose nothing from a genocidal pedonazi regime. A leftist regime on the other hand, could make housing affordable and make it harder to squeeze out workers. In that context it's easy to rationalize how you're not a fan, but "it can't be that bad either"

A lot of this bullshit about “ the left is violent” is trolls seeing phrases like. “Not happy about issue xxx? light up your legislators! “ and rushing to See? See? That leftist just told people to commit arson!

Haters are gonna hate. As far as being labeled a liberal doomer, I’m A-Okay with that. It’s bad now, but I have hope that folks will use the best means they have to change things… And that’s your vote 🗳️. Let’s vote better. Next time. And every time. Don’t skip it. Uncle Sam needs YOU!! 🇺🇸

The ruling class really doesn't know why others unwaveringly protest office holders trying to re-instate Jim Crow, continue a genocide, demonize transgenders. Those "dismissing" Bluesky aren't dismissing our concerns. They see nothing wrong with the official agenda and want us to surrender.

The far left is a problem. I got swamped and attacked for defending Elissa Slotkin's speech from trans flags, commies, foreigner, and even moderate Dems We are destroying Western Liberalism, and these people attacked Liberals. You will miss Liberalism. Ironically, many of them help create this.

It still cracks me up how fixated they are. I spend exactly zero seconds pondering the folks on Twitter. I mean, historic crises and realignment. It takes a fantastically dull mind to light on "these woketards on BlueSky really piss me off" as an abiding concern.

Well said. Most on BlueSky read, listen to, watch & stream msm outlets & podcasts. What’s funny, and reminds me of the “both sides are extreme” argument by msm journos in the 00s re: MSNBC & Fox, is that msm journos STILL say both sides go to their echo chamber. When BlueSky is primarily msm driven

I’m clear that the hatred is due to the decentralized nature of this platform. They characterize things as left or woke when they are trying to control or undermine something. Look at the “woke AI” EO. It’s just a pretense to remove any ethical barriers from LLMs. Online hatred by power is a bluff.

I am independent, former Republican, and love BlueSky so how does that calculate as liberal? I am opposed to X because of all the things Musk did to us period. I left the Republican Party because of its extreme far right direction & Trump’s craziness in first term. They are nuts!

Trump picks the extreme posts because that benefits him in his extremism. There’s a different media for MAGA, for Trumpism, for Republicans and for Democrats. Bluesky is free speech, where the majority want to keep free speech. That’s the first difference from X and Taco’s site.

I'd argue #Bluesky provides two really important social functions for the #Left. 1. Reinforcement of #Progressive #OntologicalSecurity 2. Pushing the window of acceptable ideas to the left ( #OvertonWindow if you will) by providing a 'deviant' who is more 'left' than the observer.

People just want to be on the site everyone else is on. It’s owned by a drug addicted Nazi who wants to control people’s minds. Why would I want to be there? People get stuck in the monotony of monopoly