Post

Aaron Rupar@atrupar.com

Look at the shabby state and increasingly authoritarian trajectory of the country and ask yourself if we can endure 2 more years of a lawless Trump administration wreaking havoc with no check from Congress, then vote accordingly. This is not the time for a protest vote or purity politics.

705 reposts4.5K likes

It's definitely demonstrated to me that there's a fraction of the left that will never be satisfied, and there's no point appealing to them, but the bulk of the left are people who would be happy with trans rights, less genocide, and maybe stop bragging about how the fascists are your best buds

We have to get elected so we can pass incremental reforms, lose the next election, panic, lose everything we gained and more, then do it all over again after moving toward the "center", which shifts further to the right every cycle, and we can't figure out why.

When they say "purity test" they mean "oh my god stop being mean to me because I said a thing it was no big deal why can't you just give up stuff for the greater good" and then lose their entire shit when you talk about raising taxes.

Nobody ever flips it. Ok, why don't you suck it up and accept trans women in sport, which you insist is the only trans issue? Why don't you renounce your purity test and let trans girls and women participate?

he could have said nothing. could have kept going with his good work. could have linked to a check your voter registration page. could have pointed out the dems that are good on things like trans issues. Did chose to punch down

I'd say this is not the time for trying the same old tired "vote blue no matter who" tactics that literally got us into this fascist mess in the first place. But what do I know?

They've spent decades convincing themselves that "the groups" have no choice but to stay loyal and will listen to their chosen "community leaders." I'm not even sure 'Political Scientists' even talked about "Sister Souljah moments" until the 2010s.

We need to weed out the establishment dems who “want to reach across the isle” and “trans rights but not really tho please vote for me”. The cold truth is that accepting the bare minimum is what got us here. Say what you will about Conservatives, but they’re all united in their narrow ass beliefs

Whereas Democrats are sharply divided in what direction they should go. Establishment is convinced they can bring over people who will never vote Democrat even if their lives actually depended on it, and this approach has failed each time. We need to purity test, simple as.

Honestly I don't want to support either party. I will probably reluctantly vote Democrat until I can help coordinate or have a reliable third party (never green, never libertarian). And people like the "don't purity test" are why

It's exhausting that they still haven't learned that this is so not the way to galvanize their base.... They said this shit over and over every fucking election and it never works. It's the logic that got us to this exact point in time

"Purity politics" is Nazi code for, "stop judging authoritarianism, genocide, white supremacy, and child rape. We NEED those things. We DON'T need your to have your needs met."

Most of those who invoke "purity politics" are not affected by the current policies. They are like MAGA in that regard; it doesn't hurt THEM, so we should just ignore it for the greater good (e.g., THEIR comfort and security).

Standing behind basic human rights (reproductive rights, minority rights, trans rights, protection from genocide) is NOT a purity test. It is a baseline.

I wouldn't call that odd, selfish to the point of being sociopathic, sure, but that's the deal "moderate" conservatives (and many liberals) have always made.

i'm not supporting candidates who want to compromise with the fascists by letting them murder me to save themselves. trans rights or we all lose

They’re all listening to the same “advisors” who have been pitching the same losing strategy for years: “throw minorities under the bus to gain right wing votes!” And it doesn’t work cause right wingers will never vote Democrat and they lose minority votes!

They think "median voters" are persuadable, but they leave all the actual *persuading* to Republicans and then just adopt a less extreme version of their position. The advisors always tell them to run and hide, never seeming to realize that Republicans *run on this stuff anyway*. ->

<- You can't hide from it. You have to punch back in a way that links these social issues back to the "kitchen table issues" the consultants and talking heads insist you focus on. Democrats want to think they're separate and can be kept that way. Republicans have known for a long time they're not.

IDK about any other person, but when I say purity tests are bad, I mean berating someone due to a failure to boycott something, and stuff like that.

I remember how amazingly following this logic went when Starmer in opposition was welcoming Tory MP defectors into the "big tent". One of them was even from the *right of the tories* and had been found attempting to sway judges sentencing her husband who was convicted of 3 counts of sexual assault

Trans rights are human rights. My hometown and province are both about to have elections and my friends and I have done research into the candidates and their social media histories, ruling out anyone who has made queerphohic comments or supported queerphobic causes and businesses

i am talking about politicians specifically campaigning to take rights away. and i am addressing people demanding i vote for them. trans rights or i help their guy lose.

"or else we vote Trump, because the GOP loves Trans so much !" Obama and Biden did not campaign on LGTBs rights. But they are the ones who advanced them the most. Your calls to help Trump and the GOP stay in power if your navel is not put in the center of everything is dumb as fuck.

None. And not the transgenders either You are using a scarecrow. You are voluntarily confusing "campaign" with "policy". Obviously, you are willing to have the worst transphobes in power as long as the democrats don't make the trans right their front and center issue during the campaign.

*Trans people asking their representatives to help them not be murdered by the government* Average liberal: "Why are you trying to make this all about yourself you selfish fuck?"

Obama literally campaigned to protect gay marriage in California during his original presidential run. Stop trying to rewrite history. Try showing this much spine about telling people not to help the GOP when it's Marcy Kaptur bragging about voting with MAGA to hurt trans people.

right? people will say to me with a straight-face that I'm being an insufferable moral puritan because I draw the line at something silly like supporting genocide or some shit 🙄

Meanwhile half of them refuse to support the candidate trying to unseat Pete Ricketts in Nebraska simply because he isn't wearing the color of jersey they like, despite being more liberal than the quislings they constantly tell us not to criticize.

I would take this a lot more seriously if the "vote blue no matter who" Democrats actually did anything once they were voted into power. Are we supposed to ignore that the Democrats were handed control of the Presidency and Congress, and went out of their way to not use that power?

If I help elect people who don't think that my nephew or my trans friends deserve right, or that my Palestinian friends deserve to have their home defended then all I have done is allow evil to exist cause my cis passing behind will be a bit more comfy. I refuse to do that.

What if instead of finally getting a cleaning company for the mold in my house I used the spray bottle again. No the spray bottle did nothing and it just came back worse but now it's too urgent for the cleaning company so I need the spray bottle again.

If you vote to strip rights from people, campaign on stripping rights from people, and tell them to go fuck themselves when they complain, do not be surprised when they don't vote for you! Why is democracy so hard for hypothetically democratic voters to understand?

This post is unavailable.

Once again, I beg you all to contemplate the stupidity of “a couple of you said you might vote to have a couple kids not be able to play sports! Therefore I don’t give a shit about the rest of the country or all my other very important priorities!!!”

You being willing to sacrifice trans people means you've already lost because you're now a willing tool of fascism. Get bent, shitgibbon.

I beg you to instead direct your criticism at anyone on that list. I've got Tammy Baldwin, the first openly gay Senator, voting against trans people's right to exist and that is a much better place to direct my fury than at some innocent person she might harm with her stupidity.

Once again, I beg the far right cult of shitlibs to just give up and accept their fact that their burning need to embrace Nazi rhetoric the Nazis themselves has no merit and exists silly to normalize anti trans bullshit all across the board means y’all are jsut braindead Nazi supporters.

That’s…. Not a list with a couple names. Human rights are no laughing matter. Politicians voting for people to be genocided can’t also expect those people’s votes.

If the future of the entire country truly hinges on the votes of people who care about trans rights, perhaps your time would be better spent pressuring your candidate to accommodate those voters?

I shouldn't have to tell you "this is how a political movement slides into fascism" while we're struggling to survive in a fascist regime that started by targeting the EXACT SAME MINORITY. Fix your hearts. You know the rest.

what amount of transphobia is acceptable to you in a democratic candidate before you stop voting for them? where is the line? do you have one?

The fact you think it’s only about kids playing in sports is hilarious. It’s healthcare & how you’re treated by med personnel, it’s equal rights in the workplace & protections from being fired for being who you are, anti harassment laws, & disallowing the trans/gay panic defenses when they kill us.