Post

I have to admit that the one tiny silver lining of our horrific current moment is that you just don’t see people shanking each other over stuff like “is it cultural appropriation for a white woman to sell coconut water” anymore

James@gravitysra1nbow.bsky.social

>remembering that people used to knife fight for weeks about how fusion cuisine was imperialism

126 reposts1.2K likes

My favorite example of this was the Baby Wearing controversy. Thinking about how an exhausted, long-suffering parent would receive the gentle critique about them appropriating an ethnic technique to carry their infant. So funny.

somewhat: the specific incident was slightly problematic in that a white person needed help finding something and assumed that every asian person in there was an employee and was shocked that they didn't know where it was. in my experience this really never happens outside of this incident

oh yeah that specific person was embarrassing as fuck for doing that (but can’t say I’ve observed that behavior anywhere myself at H Mart and I go to H Mart all the time)

Some white dude running an ice cream shop said he "discovered vegan ube ice cream," which is obviously barely any different from ube sorbetes, which has been around for decades. Discourse! A couple asian creators made videos drawing attention to this fact and pile on insued. Idk what happened after

Given the last twenty years, I think there have been people intentionally driving wedges about that stuff by roleplaying exaggerated wokesters since WAY before we started to notice, and they were ops not even from this country. Somehow that started eons ago.

I’ve never really understood the cultural appropriation thing. I get that it’s bad to try to pass off someone else’s idea as your own. But as long as you give credit to your influences, why would you avoid using good things from other cultures?

Oftentimes if it was white people making money off of good things from other cultures in lieu of the people from those cultures. Appropriation was always about the power imbalance and not only that a white person really liked making mole or dandan mian for the sake of it.

Yeah, this, it's the phenomenon where the abuela with a tamale stand gets treated as low-class, low-culture, and then some white guy starts a restaurant "inspired" by it and it becomes a posh hotspot & rakes in a gazillion dollars. It's a problem of profiting off people & culture you don't respect.

Or like, the Cowichan sweaters in British Columbia, where big stores sell knock-off versions of a culturally-important Native craft that Native artisans earn a living at. White business undercutting them in a sleazy way. But that's not at all the same as learning other cultures' food & loving it!

There should be a name for people opening a restaurant with a bad version of food from their own culture to cater to bad American tastes. There's an Indian place by us that my Indian coworker couldn't stand because it is objectively bad. Sadly, it's my daughter's favorite place. 😀

Unfortunately, people even within the practices often don't agree on whether or not they are closed and some will offer initiations to anyone who wants to pay for them. It's a really complex issue that is best left to hereditary cultural/religious leaders and philosophers to decide.

Yeah, I feel like a feature of the 2010s was that everyone decided to appoint themselves the culture police. It’s not just believing that a white woman making tacos is cultural appropriation, it’s believing it’s on you to yell at her for it. Why do YOU care?

I'm gonna say 'social contagion' and the presence of somebody studying culture looking for how to hurt it. Who knew how prevalent it would be to make sockpuppets and bots explicitly to act the fool dressed up like your enemy? Or the utility of recruiting idiots to do likewise with social contagion?

If AC Space Buns woman happened now nobody would care... At least on here. Twitter would just do racism about it still. It's not like dumb controversies don't happen here (Isabelle Normal Body Type) but it's genuinely better than every other most times.

It has definitely chilled out and i think the main point ppl focus on now is "is the food good and made sincerely?" I will still stand by how insanely funny this recipe was and how right everyone was to roast Chris Morocco for it. www.bonappetit.com/recipe/ode-t...

bonappetit.comOde to Halo-HaloMacerating the fruit makes the halo halo extra juicy and saucy, but you could just throw in any unadulterated berry. The key to this dessert (as with any sundae) is a mix of textures: icy, creamy, che...

(I also couldn’t help but notice at the time that white *men* running restaurants and selling products from cultures they didn’t originate from usually got way more of a free pass than white women doing the same thing, but well, so it goes).

The other one i still think about frequently are the posters (inevitably white themselves) who were convinced white people saying “y’all”, because they are Southern, are Deeply Problematic

And yes, we of course should still call out white people who are being shitheads who refuse to acknowledge who they got their ideas from or who inspired them, but I still think deeming randos history’s greatest monsters over stuff like coconut water was not, perhaps, the best use of our energy

I sincerely wish I could pull off a "y'all", but it sounds so ridiculous in my accent that I have to settle for lesser options. (I continue to work to not say "you guys" because even though where/when I grew up it was considered non-gender-specific, it isn't here and now. Despite "bruh")

Are bruh/ bro non-gendered now? I'm on some Korean drama reddit groups and posters (whose native language may or may not be English, there are international fans) always annoy me by addressing random posters they're arguing with as "bro" Or maybe they think it's just cool slang in English?

I mean, just from a pragmatic perspective the fact that English doesn't have a standard second person plural pronoun, and there are a lot of situations where one might want such a thing. "Y'all" is certainly more intelligible than "yinz."

my secret identity once had a south african white girl on twitter claim she was appropriating aave for using "y'all" nope, kid, just texan

Suppose it's your culture to appropriate culture? I don't wanna be a romebro, but to my understanding that is a huge part of why their military did so well for so long. Just copy the stuff that works well from everyone you meet.

Well yeah, of course. Cultural appropriation is a long-standing tradition among white men, and appropriating cultural appropriation is basically spitting in my face.

Culture can’t be appropriated or stolen. Culture is influence. The purpose of culture is to influence — to change art, fashion, food, language, music, etc. Cook, wear, play what you want. Take ideas from other cultures and create new things. Give props to creators and don’t be an asshole. Simple.

In case you‘re wondering, the Chinese largely fell on the side of “if you look good in it, what’s the fuss?” (Probably one of the few times my Taiwanese ass found myself in agreement with pro-CCP Chinese nationalists).

Yeah, it always struck me as disingenuous to police "this person selling tacos is white" as cultural appropriation when the actual harm here is when someone is disrespectful to the cultural tradition that spawned the dish. People often like it when you learn how to cook their culture's food!

A pretty 17 year old white girl excited about her prom dress from a vintage boutique and getting freaking ROASTED on Twitter because it was a 60s Chinese style. Thank God some actual Chinese ppl came in to tell her to just wear the dress and have fun.

And so many people not realising that the main point of workplace diversity training seminars is to lay down a paper trail in case the employer ever needs to prove in court that it doesn't run a racist workplace. Actually making the workplace less racist is a nice-to-have.

i mean i like to think that people just called a temporary truce so we can kick the fascists back to hell but im pretty sure once we establish woke 3 or something we'll have even worse discourse like "is brunch problematic" or something

Saying "brunch is problematic" is, in fact, problematic. It is an outgrowth of the elitist online privileged class's way of dismissing the vital employment and psychological benefits the working classes and offline-interacting classes obtain from brunch. It is a criminal hate crime. Minimum. ;-)

I wonder if someone will take that seriously and the post will accidentally go viral, starting major global discourse. Which, naturally, will itself be problematic. Noting that is also problematic. An observation that is problematic. It's problematic all the way down.

Like I'm not saying there can't be kinds of food that are a closed practice other people shouldn't thoughtlessly copy, but generally speaking food is the frontier of cultural exchange, shared freely, eagerly, and often insistently. The gatekeeping around it was bizarre.

Don’t worry, a Michael Jackson truther called racist for calling out Michael Jackson’s odd behavior towards children. They insisted the children’s parents were to blame, not the adult man who brought children to his super fun theme park home for private no adults allowed sleepovers.

but more seriously bsky.app/profile/sent...

POTUS@sentientpotato.bsky.social

I cannot co-sign hard enough There is of course harmful cultural appropriation, but many or perhaps even most things people get upset about they absolutely should not be IMO taking things from other cultures is -typically- Good, Actually

Coconut Water discourse (Woke 1) —> casually lighting fires outside Kansas City warehouse slated to become a concentration camp (Woke 2)

omg, now I'm remembering all those times when some pundit would do a "look what this college freshman wrote in their campus paper about hair" or whtv