Post

Talking about how heists are inherently cool and sexy is really not helping you beat the “a core problem of our age is that too many people think movies are real” charges, tbh

134 reposts1.1K likes

All the very best heist movies (Asphalt Jungle is the best example) go wrong at the end due to the various character failings of the protagonists. So maybe yes for your point and maybe no. PS: The ending of the original Rat Pack Ocean's 11 speaks to my point.

Ack I don’t agree with this particular group but this I think is an ahistorical read. Way WAY before movies -people romanticised about daring robberies and priceless jewel thefts. Ballads and folk hero mythology and dark glamor were accorded to highwayman and smugglers.

Basically if your theft can somehow be framed as dashing in spirit and using your wits to your advantage -people thrill to it in fiction and in real life

Yes and that trio had a point about the dullness of cryptocurrency crimes in particular- ballads don’t get written about cybercrime lol Movies have ALWAYS wrestled with how to make that work dramatically on camera

Yes! Although in some cases I think an association with violence against a disliked symbol or tool of power adds to the allure. Smugglers strike back against the revenue men etc

Anyway, I am a museum enthusiast and stealing from public institutions then selling those historic works of art to evil, rich people who will stash them away where no one can see them makes me very angry

Of course, Indiana Jones destroyed around three UNESCO World Heritage Sites per movie so he might not be the best role model for ethical stewardship of historic objects either.

One of the advantages of them being fiction is we can root for conveniently unproblematic options to arise. If we ever get the granddaughter of Indiana Jones stealing artifacts from museums and repatriating to their cultures of origin, sign me up.

Why not instead working officially and legally as a museum to museum artifact recovery agreements by day, and heisting on rich people's secret private collections by night?

I have had the experience of watching a heist movie with someone who concluded, "But what was the POINT? What's the good in owning real art if you can't have a little "on loan from the collection of..." plaque hanging next to it at a museum?"

The painting "Who's Afraid of Red, Yellow and Blue" was damaged twice, by the same person, with a knive. The first restorer got a huge amount of money to restore it. But when the artwork had to be restored the 2nd time they found out that cheap house paint was used to restore it the first time.

they're doing a thomas crowne affair remake and as much as i love that movie it feels like the wrong cultural moment to make a bored billionaire who steals priceless works of art from the public into a hero

Perfect! Or a Matthew Bomer reboot where he steals back individual stolen works of arts from hidden illicit collections and then breaks into the museum they were stolen from and rehangs them in their old position I really think we all deserve this!

DON LaFONTAINE: In a world where billionaires are hoarding art, museums demand justice. In a world where priceless works are kept under lock and key, one group dares to strike back for the people. No one knows who they are. No one knows where they come from. All the police have is a name: The Met.

two-stage heist movie Part I: colonial appropriation c.1960 (the ugly heist) [decades pass] Part II: grad student figures out provenance of item in friend's dad's mansion c.2010 and tricks friend's dad into Nathan Jessup-style "yes I stole it!" confession into recording device

Growing up during the Satanic panic when the music and horror movies(later see porn) i kept hearing how all that would desensitize me, and that led me to always defend the idea that people understand the difference between reality and movies, and now many decades later i really don't know anymore.

It helps of you remind yourself that all art is political and flreframe your understanding of art to be "propaganda" for a certain worldview, then take a look around and try to see the narrative being pushed by mainstream art (like US pro-militarism or meritocracy).

ironically, the Gabriel Allon spy books were interesting in this regard, because art is always a big focus, but they make clear that the Russians or whoever is stealing/forging/etc are locking these in the Geneva Freeport and no one ever sees the Van Gogh.

also i might look for an interview with Daniel Silva because the last few have steered *hard* away from the mossad angle. interesting set of fiction, worth blowing a weekend on if folks have the time

If you can afford to hire a crack team of art thieves to steal a famous painting so you can put it on private display somewhere only you and your rich asshole friends can see it, then you can hire a talented craftsperson to make a near-perfect replica of said painting and leave the original alone.

Most stolen art doesn't end up in secret rich people galleries either. It's more often used as collateral for organized crime and either gets ransomed back within a year or two or can't really be moved and is only found decades later or never.

They are also very violent more often than not. Like not with propriety but physically violent. There’s no way to safely knock someone out that doesn’t result in medical damage.

I didn't see the earlier post about thefts from museums. I agree with the point that it's stealing from the public for the benefit of the wealthy (as do auctions of clearly relevant works) but maintain my position on KitKat heists.

Dead Presidents handles this pretty well IMO. There’s like 5 minutes where you think maybe it’ll be a sexy heist and then uh, it definitely isn’t

I used to work in an art museum and my only art theft story is a guy got drunk at a nearby street fest, ran out of cash, walked over to our museum and grabbed a sculpture off a pedestal and immediately tried to sell it at an antique store for quick cash

Like in Persona 5 Joker continuing to be a Phantom Thief by taking the deal at the endgame is positioned as a bad thing. The good ending sees the PTs resolve to change society in more mundane ways than channeling Arsène Lupin.

The Louvre heist was objectively bad but come on it was at least a LITTLE cool lol There was a kid dressed as a detective randomly on site! There was a security system flaw that got exploited! It was a news item that didn't involve Trump in any way! We gotta take our wins where we can lol

What people like is Rube Goldberg machines What is real is stuff like 'someone left a utility ladder up so me and the lads hopped in on the second floor and knicked stuff after hours'

It's even funnier if you consider that the latest Louvre heist was kinda pathetic in hindsight: a bunch of randos exploiting a security issue caused by a chronic lack of funds, to steal ugly jewels, half of which were found in a gutter a few days later. Then getting caught at the airport.

Fantasies about heists both acknowledge and exploit the threat of the priviledged and the violence of inequality we confront in our desperate age. A lazy daydream built on cowardice. We need to learn other work. Larceny. Extortion. Piracy. Informed and executed In Solidarity. Run Em. 👉🤛

I'll be honest I'm not sure why this is causing so much traffic on this website (except for pent up hostility to the participants) because "oh yeah I love a heist" is not an especially scalding take

yeah, like there are how many video games, board games, cartoons, and books about this topic. this doesn't really indicate they think movies are real. it was also clearly a joke because it was being compared to crypto scams that are "lame" crimes

Yeah, like I’m sorry but liking a very popular genre of fiction doesn’t mean you think it’s real? Genuinely not sure what the issue even is here, aside from people already not liking Hasan and needing something lower-stakes to complain about amidst all the chaos I guess?

Not so low key think the anti-hero 90’s blockbusters (Willis, Arnie, etc) put it in our heads that wars were won quickly by buzzer-beater derring-do and catchphrases which helped grease public opinion for Afghan/Iraq.

1st saw Topkapi as a kid & was entranced, subsequently learned more abt 💸antiquities still a great film (watch it for location shots of Istanbul in the 60s alone), absolute gem & a gem of a heist! but yes sales of looted antiquities into private hands has been a curse forever & should be condemned