Post

I thought America was starting to get over this knee-jerk reflex that the minute we criticize Israel or more accurately its current leadership (bc Israel is not monolithic), we are somehow anti-semitic. Lots of blame for Middle East to go around.

No... it's anti-Israel, not antisemitic. Unless, perhaps, you believe that criticism of Idi Amin was anti-black racism, for example. It helps to know the difference between 'Jews' and 'The Netanyahu regime'. For example, genocidal behaviour is NOT a Jewish characteristic. I hope this helps.

I don’t know. But it’s a stretch to call that antisemitism. If he’s taking money from AIPAC that’s a problem if you’re a voter opposed to the genocide in Gaza and Lebanon

The antisemitism getting mainstreamed through the DSA seems unstoppable at this point. Why don't centrist Dems understand they plan to hollow them out like one of those hornets that lays eggs inside a caterpillar? I assume they don't understand because they're not acting like they know.

The problem is that you think opposing Israel is antisemitism. Antisemitism has nothing to do with Israel or Zionism. Antisemitism is about Jewish people.

Is it antisemitism or antizionism? Because if it’s antizionism, that’s based as fuck and it’s one of the reasons many of us joined. If it’s antisemitism, provide proof of your claim.

DSA is like 75% white. What worries people is that some are old enough to have spent time in the Eastern Bloc for example. Socialists committed atrocities like Nazis in these countries.

“Antisemitism” and it’s people who don’t support a fascist apartheid/jim crow state committing genocide using our tax dollars. Shut up lmfaoooo centrist Dems are why we got Trump twice with their fecklessness

When you say "centrist Dems" who exactly are you talking about? If you have a legitimate complaint about specific Democrats, then address them by name. Otherwise, I'm going to assume you're talking about Black/Jewish/Women Democrats.

Pretty gross imo to try and do "America First, but leftishly" even aside from the rest but yeah slapping "Israel First" over four policy points that have nothing to do with foreign policy in a role that does not engage with foreign policy is hard to interpret as anything but blatant antisemitism

That ad is one of the most blatant nonsequiturs I’ve seen. Just of the four issues had anything to do with Israel, & it was about an endorsement from MI’s Attorney General (who happens to be Jewish), not a position Moss actually took.

oops, all foreign money! what's antisemitic is YOU trying to lump every member of a religion under the banner of a NATION that is committing genocide against people it is supposed to care for. Jewish people are welcome in America. Piles of money in our political system from a foreign nation is not

oh, no wonder you're mad about this, lmao. get money out of politics and consultant class dudes like you lose their cushy job sucking up to billionaires, no wonder you hate the left wing and favor foreign money subverting the will of the voters.

Nooo send your kids to die for israel, wait we need a trillion dollars please USA how will we genocide these children with rocks they're scary, omg did a college student say the word gaza ok no more universities for america

People need to get it through their heads that whatever they *might* have “actually” meant a couple of years ago, when leftists say “AIPAC” or “Israel” NOW they often mean (((Jewish))) just as when MAGA says “DEI” they mean “Black.” If you can’t get that I don’t know what the else to say.

that's not true. when we say Israel we mean Israel. if a leftist believes in intersectionality EXCEPT for Jewish people then they don't really believe in intersectionality. and if a leftist doesn't believe in intersectionality then I'm sorry but they're just not a leftist

Wtaf? The Israeli government sucks. Just like ours sycks. Just like many others...but moreover in many eyes because they are much more visible...and loaded with hypocrisy!

outside of Maine I have not seen an uglier Senate race in America by far. Texas got testy this is outright brutal. Trump won in 2024 so El Sayed has to earn not just Stevens supporters votes but also independents who won't take kindly to being called Zionazis and baby killers for not falling in line

There's plenty to say. That's a very antisemitic post. So when people were decrying Idi Amin it was an attack on black people? Attack Putin and we've got it in for Eastern Europeans? Do the actions of Augusto Pinochet in your mind justify Trump's attacks on Hispanic immigrants? You may be an...

its crazy how dems like you just openly disparage the idea of being left-wing now, you hate 'leftists' more than you hate the republicans that are actually in control of the country lol guess it's fascism forever then thanks a lot

That's certainly a really convenient way to never have to believe anyone gives a shit about the things they profess

To paraphrase: (Spending 70 million on one race in another country, then crying “It’s because I’m jewish isn’t it?” Is like slapping someone, then putting the glasses on, and saying “you wouldn’t hit a man with glasses, would you?”)

Bullshit. Both Democratic politicians and the Israeli government are desperately trying to define “Jewish” to mean “pro-Israel” and “anti-Israel” to mean “antisemitic.” The last Jewish Republican in the Senate (it’s been about 17 years since there was one) was Arlen Specter, who switched parties to

become a Democrat in 2009. I couldn’t remember his name for a minute, so I searched for “Jewish Republican Senator Pennsylvania.” The first result Google gave me was the Wikipedia page for John Fetterman. I cannot emphasize enough how not Jewish Fetterman is. But he backs the IDF so close enough

My leftist Jewish friends have explained many times that they find exactly this sort of conflation of Israel (which, for the record, is a genocidal, settler-colonialist state that's existed for less than a century) with Judaism or Jewish people in general, deeply antisemitic. I'll listen to them.

I think there's a lot of conflation with, say, AIPAC and J-Street and similar organizations with similar goals for the Zionist project and similar means for achieving them, but if there were a few fascist gun-lobby organizations similar to the NRA i wouldn't think it our of pocket to conflate those.

I am against hating individuals for characteristics about them, including place of birth. I am against rich people buying my fucking government. And I’m really against people seeing an entity that is political, cultural, and religious and trying to pretend it’s only two of those at any given time.

Which is what you seem to be doing here. Israel is a country AND an ethnostate AND the world capital of one of the largest religions. AND it has a unique position of having a rich ancient history and also a tumultuous modern reformation. Sprinkle in the rise of fascism and it’s a powderkeg of

I think of AIPAC as a foreign influence group with too much power and influence over US politicians and US elections. Too much = has funded a successful challenge to an incumbent they didn't like. (Crypto has too, also bad). Also what's this about combining US and IS military?

I currently disagree with what AIPAC is lobbying for, but the focus on AIPAC, ignoring ACTUAL AMERICAN PROBLEMS, is a red flag that it is a way to be politically correct while spreading yhe idea that Jews, rather than your own bad decisions, are responsible for your life not being perfect.

Wrong! When I say Israel, I fucking mean Israel. Stop defending genocide by gaslighting critics of Netanyahu with bullshit “oh sure, blame the Jews!” Good lord. This is ridiculous.

Thank you for putting words in my mouth. AIPAC ≠ Israel ≠ Netanyahu ≠ people of Jewish faith ≠ people of Jewish descent That’s like saying apples are oranges because tomatoes are fruit. Sure they may be related to varying degrees, the VENN circles may overlap, but they are not the same.

They talked Trump into joining them in an insane unwinnable war with Iran, and does everything they can to keep it going. Millions will die because of this war (mostly because of the loss of fertilizer). Everyone except Trump and the Israeli government knew this would be the outcome.

When goose-stepping Regressives,DemocRATS&Zio-Nazis claim victim-status while punching left, it tells us their propaganda is not working as well as it did prior to the most recent mass atrocities by the terrorist state of Israel.Your true flag, Shit-Weasel.

Sorry but I've seen and met and heard from enough anti-AIPAC Jewish people that you're never going to be able to convince me that Judaism, ethnically or theologically, is synonymous with genocide and apartheid. No matter how hard you try! Sorry.

So what you would prefer is a cultural context in which people could genuinely not be antisemitic, and instead focus explicitly on the specific actions of the modern nation-state of Israel and its world-wide backers, criticizing the institutions without implicating the religion or ethnicity. Right?

I’m really sick of zionists like Charles pretending criticism of Israel or AIPAC = anti-Semitism. Israel bootlickers like the ADL have been pushing this nonsense, making American Jews like me less safe. This is vile behavior all so you can pretend a genocide isn’t happening.

The left is increasingly openly antisemitic. Are Democratic voters and electeds supposed to pretend that this is not the case? I hope our tent is not big enough for this.

Since a lot of people seem confused: Saying “AIPAC sucks” is not antisemitic (and I agree, they do). Calling a candidate “AIPAC powered” when they haven’t taken money from AIPAC (or one of their subsidiaries) because they’re Jewish is.

Saying “I hate the Israeli gov’ts actions wrt Gaza!” isn’t antisemitic (I hate a lot of it as well). Calling a Jewish candidate “Israel first” based purely on the fact that they’re Jewish is. And no, supporting a strong U.S./Israeli relationship doesn’t make you “Israel first.”

You can call it what ypu want. I see another government doing endless gwot shit that only makes things worse over time.. so hurray for that I guess.

so fucking funny to be like "leftists are using israel as a stand-in for all jews" when israel constantly declares itself to be a stand-in for all jews and leftists are constantly bending over backwards to separate israel from all jews seriously just say you love genocide and hate muslims

Yeah we noticed you don't know what else to say. That's why you keep saying this tired, empty dogshit nobody cares about. You're irrelevant and your genocidal rape state will be consigned to the pages of history like all its crusader predecessors

What a disgustingly cynical lie. AIPAC exists. Israel exists. "DEI" is not an explicit organisation that murders people or provides money to ensure that murder can continue. What people need to get through their heads is fanatics like you will say anything, no matter the damage.

⬆️⬆️⬆️ This is just the same old same old smearing that finally is being chased out of town. We are very close to breaking the back of AIPAC and its corruptions and deadly lies. Keep your eyes on the prize and give this red-baiting "antisemite" shit no respect. www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-i...

theguardian.comThe pro-Israel lobby has swayed US presidents since Truman. It must end with Trump | Ian Lustick and Eli CliftonOur new book tracks the growth over nearly eight decades, of the most powerful foreign policy lobby in US history

when people criticize Israel’s policies of butchering civilians or AIPAC’s meddling in our politics to fund campaigns to do more of said butchering, I think that’s what they mean. And it isn’t antisemitism to not be in favor of that

How is it possible to believe this, AFTER we all watched a genocide unfold on our phones? And multiple leftist leaders get run out of congress by AIPAC donations?

“AIPAC” is still shorthand for “foreign government lobbyists” to me. We don’t seem to be paying for Israel’s defense. We are paying for the persecution and displacement of their neighbors. And it looks like Netanyahu doesn’t want peace at all, so why are we giving money to his government.

I don't like AIPAC *or* Netanyahu & I actually would be OK with us cutting off offensive military aid to them, at least for the time being since he's clearly out of control. HOWEVER, there's a difference between "opposing AIPAC" & "opposing (((AIPAC)))" and a LOT of people clearly mean the latter.

If your shorthand for "corrupt money in politics" is a Jewish lobby- that's antisemtic as F. Why isn't the shorthand "corrupt money"? Or "PAC Money"? Or "Big Pharma"? Or "Big Tech"? Or "Wall Street"? Or "White Christian Nationalism"? So curious that it's a lobbying group outside the top 100...

If you think it's impossible to criticize Israel – especially when it commits genocide, state-sponsored terrorism, and ethnic cleansing – and AIPAC – which is a foreign influence op in support of said atrocities – without being antisemitic, then you are part of the problem.

AIPAC is an organization supporting Genocide! I don't care who those people are!! I am Color Blind & Fuck Religion Religion is probably 50% of the worlds problems IMO And when ever I have time I read your work Charles & Recommend it. Thanks for all you do for Team Blue

That's a completely nutso thing to say, now more than ever people actually are very concerned with the actions of the literal real life Israel and the pro-Israel lobbying ecosystem AIPAC is part of

But he fully supports Israeli apartheid & refuses to admit Gaza genocide so calling him Israel first is fair even if he wasnt Jewish. Stevens (not Jewish) but def Zionist propped up by AIPAC & other Zionist PACS. MANY GOP in congress r psycho evangelicals funded by AIPAC & are raging zionists.

Never heard of this guy so I looked him up. Seems like this guy wants us to associate Israel with Jewish people at large. If he wasn’t Jewish, we would be (rightfully) calling this wildly antisemitic

Checked out his website and while he appears to be wise enough to not mention Israel anywhere he does have an endorsement from the person who tried to prosecute protestors

Legitimately how is this not antisemitism, even if he is Jewish it is straight up doing “dual loyalty” dog whistle shit.

Funny, but as an adult I understand words; AIPAC, Israel is not "Jewish". I oppose the aims of the former, decry the actions of the government of the latter; don't even have to bring Jews into the convo. I support the arrest and rendition to the ICC of Netanyahu, even were he a closet Presbyterian.

Your post inspired me to look him up and… you seriously think framing this statement as pro-Israel is an anti-Semitic dog whistle?

Please don't tell me what we think. AIPAC is a far right reactionary group, supporting Israel's current far right politics. Jewish liberals also exist, we just don't have billionaire funding. I will happily ignore any and all responses.

Really ? ‘Cause I’m pretty sure people are smart enough to realize not all Jews are committing genocide but the Zionists are. What it means a couple years ago is the same as it means today if not more so. Aipac politicians put Israel before America.

Yet another Zionist insisting that any opposition to Israel's rapacious genocide is an attack on Jews because Jewish people cannot be allowed to exist as independent humans beings and are all mere agents of Israel.

You need this to be true but it simply isn't. Israel committed one of the worst, most thoroughly documented and in real time witnessed atrocities in human history and any person still supporting the perpetrators shouldn't feel comfortable. This is permanent.

Charles, you know I am a big supporter of your work, but that just isn't right. When I say #AIPAC I mean the Political Action Cmte funded by the genocidal folks hanging on to Netanyahu as Dear Leader. Not the country or the people. THE PAC influencing US politics.

You may mean that. A lot of people clearly mean (((AIPAC))) including the candidate in the flyer above who is falsely accusing Moss of being “AIPAC powered” even though he hasn’t taken money from either AIPAC or any of their subsidiaries, and of being “Israel first” based on absolutely nothing.

How does that work to support antisemitism when every legit voice on the matter clearly distinguishes that they mean Israel, and AIPAC? If they changed their messaging to be actually antisemitic they would lose popular support. Your conspiracy theory folds with a second's thought. Racist idiocy.

on the political side, I do think (and have thought for awhile) we need an org thats dedicated to recruiting, training, and supporting Jewish candidates for office, because there is clearly an effort to drive Jews from public life.

No silly it’s just about Palestine and the “genocide” They don’t hate us Jews, just the “Zionists”. You know, Jews who support Israel’s right to exist (We hate BIBI more than anyone, and want him gone as much as his enabler Trump)

“Former prosecutor” ✅ How much you wanna bet she’s prosecuted someone for exercising their 1st Amendment rights? It’s pick the facts that look best and then say “Israel first” as a cover for antisemitism

Which one of the issues in this poster represent a position that would be 'Israel first?' The 'dual loyalty' trope has been a part of antisemitism since the Roman period, but more commonly since the Tsarist era. (To a lesser extent this is also part of anti-catholic vitriol, as it was for JFK)

What would you call 'repeating an antisemitic trope about a Jew and citing no evidence to support it' other than naked antisemitism?

Because Moss hasn’t taken a fucking dime from AIPAC, for starters. And the attack piece doesn’t even say what supposedly makes him “Israel first.” Literally the only “reason” is that HE’S JEWISH .

He’s very pro Israel. So it is not shocking that they are framing him this way. I’ve seen a lot from both sides framing Israel issues with antisemitism. Despising the Netanyahu government isn’t antiemetic as much as supporting Israel’s right to exist doesn’t mean you support Netanyahu.

It’s too easy for both sides to frame political voices either way because they come up on one side or another. If I were running, I’m sure I’d be called antiemetic because I hate Netanyahu. Always have, long before the attacks and the following war on Palestine. This is always the way with politics.

The irony here is that this nonstop fixation on Israel doesn't actually put Michigan first. That is one reason I am leery of centering Israel/Palestine as "the only thing that matters". It doesn't address the very real domestic issues we have.

I understand the dangerous nature of this trope: it’s well-worth pointing out when it’s being leveled inaccurately. But is it inaccurate? There seem to be plenty of centrist democratic candidates, Jewish and not, who are putting Israel’s agenda (more war) before a domestic one.

Except he doesn’t. AIPAC hasn’t donated a penny to his campaign. The largest donation to his campaign comes from Equality PAC, an LGBTQ rights group. So yeah, it’s antisemitic.

you should for sure show your work better than this ad does if you want to say that he's "israel first," but saying an ad that is kind of lazy and stupid is on level with holocaust denial just makes people take allegations of antisemitism less seriously

Thinking that the only and worst bad thing in the world, in a world of bad conflict, is Israel; and also tying everything domestic to Israel, is antisemitic. Stop obsessing on the Jews. Climate change: Israel! My 401(k) dropped: Israel! 

what really happened: 1. israel established 2. arabs voluntarily leave israel 3. arabs invade israel 4. israel kicks ass 5. israel denies enemy arabs re-entry 6. arabs refuse to assimilate other arabs 7. “refugee crisis” 8. more arab invasions 9. israel kicks more ass 10. 50 years of terrorism 11.

Did you not see the “Moss is Israel First”? That’s a direct call up of the antisemitic smear that an American Jew’s first alliance is to Israel over the U.S. and that they really aren’t American.

It's the (alleged?) AIPAC funding. Any politician who takes AIPAC money, Republican or Democrat, is condoning Israel's genocide in Gaza, and of course the US funding toward it. And as of February 28th of this year, very literally putting Netanyahu's goals before the security and solvency of the US.

Don’t do this. On what planet is anything said here suggesting that being against genocide is antisemitic? She said he’s Israel first based on nothing other than the fact that he’s Jewish.

Fuck you. The first four points aren’t a problem at all, assuming they are true. They are within the lines of a campaign. What makes him Israel first, though? That’s what’s anti-Semitic, you obtuse douchebag.

It’s weird when bigots think they’re riding a high horse but are too hateful to understand that Jews are not the same thing as the Israeli gov’s actions under one PM. Holy crap, when the f*ck did these ham sandwiches think they got the right to tell Jews what’s antisemitic????

this is incredibly embarrassing that you people are so mentally broken by US politics that you take not sending bombs overseas, bike lanes, and higher taxes to be “racism, misogyny, and antisemitism the literal mentality of a servant

Just remember when it’s election time you better vote blue no matter who when it’s mostly DSA and leftists, or you could just mask off as a republican now, whatever though I don’t care

Kamala won my state by 13 points, shame she lost all the swing states though. Maybe someday democrats running for president will understand the electoral college.

Is the recording of him saying essentially this, fake…or real? Asking honestly as I’ve seen it shared and sounds pretty bad, just unsure if it’s been authenticated.

Yeah, I hear you, I just haven’t heard him refute it. It’s not like it would be be a bombshell if it was true, it’s literally what Chuck Shumer has said on record.